作者ak1290 (ak1290)
看板Eng-Class
標題[文法] which has/have/had + p.p. 的省略
時間Thu Nov 1 13:23:05 2012
舉一個句子為例:
He had an accident before, which has caused him much inconvenience.
如果這裡不用 which,
在不影響原意和時態下
改成怎麼樣才是正確的呢?
我自己可能會這樣寫:
He had an accident before, causing him much inconvenience.
但是似乎就失去present perfect的時態了。
如果更進一步,舉另外兩個類似的句子:
..., which had caused him much inconvenience. 以及
..., which caused him much inconvenience.
如果不用which又該如何修改呢?
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 140.112.41.55
1F:推 tijj:"He" 還活著嗎? 11/01 13:46
2F:→ ak1290:把accident看成injury好了XD 11/01 13:54
3F:→ tijj:"He" 是否還活著 或 "He"是否現在已經痊癒了 會影響句子的 11/01 14:00
4F:→ tijj:表達 11/01 14:00
5F:→ ak1290:第一句的"has caused"已經清楚表達了還活著 但尚未痊癒 11/01 14:06
6F:→ tijj:an accident has caused him much inconvenience 11/01 15:53
7F:→ ak1290:如果He had an accident這一段保持不變的話呢? 11/01 17:53
8F:推 Deadshot465:, and it has caused him much inconvenience? 11/01 20:34
9F:→ ak1290:也是一個選擇。那接上having caused much...呢 11/01 20:42
10F:→ hopeliu:主詞不一致而省略 dangling modifier ? 11/01 22:29
11F:→ hopeliu:不過我文法也不強就是了^^ 11/01 22:30
12F:→ dunchee:"但是似乎就失去..."--> Yes. 以你問的"reduced relative 11/02 00:22
13F:→ dunchee:clause(的一種)"來說,既然有經過reduction,在某程度上一 11/02 00:22
14F:→ dunchee:些訊息就得跟著犧牲:(然後我用關鍵字搜尋Google Books, 11/02 00:23
16F:→ dunchee:後的'should be regarded as "...."..'指的是符合"firmly 11/02 00:24
17F:→ dunchee:....generalizable"條件的才適合這樣子reduce 總結就是不 11/02 00:24
18F:→ dunchee:要亂化簡(這不是像數學公式那樣"="來"="去的變化就沒事的) 11/02 00:25