作者shitlock (名侦探ShitLock)
看板Eng-Class
标题Re: [文法] otherwise would be 的文法问题
时间Sat Mar 25 15:05:19 2017
※ 引述《david521 (sue)》之铭言:
: 你们好,刚刚读的一段文章,其中的一句为
: Geenhouse gases are necessary because they keep the planet's surface warmer
: than it otherwise would be.
: 就我的认知,otherwise 为副词,故为何不是it would otherwise be 而是 it otherwis
: e would be?
: 另外请问这句怎麽翻比较好?
: 谢谢
小弟的理解如下:
Greenhouse gases are necessary
温室气体是不可或缺的
because they keep the planet's surface warmer
因为它们能让地球的表面保持温暖
than it otherwise would be.
否则地球就不是现在这样了
这里的otherwise紧跟在it後面,
是为了单独修饰it (it指的是the planet's surface)
而主句既已明示 "Greenhouse gases are necessary";
反之,就是 the planet's surface without greenhouse gases
详细词意
=> than the planet's surface without greenhouse gases would be
使用otherwise单独修饰the planet's surface
=> than the planet's surface otherwise would be
再使用代名词it
=> than it otherwise would be
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc), 来自: 36.239.158.40
※ 文章网址: https://webptt.com/cn.aspx?n=bbs/Eng-Class/M.1490425521.A.112.html
1F:→ david521: 感谢精辟的解说,茅塞顿开 03/25 15:25