作者pkuguy (janice)
看板Eng-Class
标题Re: [请益] It would be... if sb. + have p.p.
时间Wed Jul 25 16:39:29 2012
这个是单纯的直说法,而非假设法。
只是一般的文法书都着重在 if 假设法,还设了许多「公式」,
因此一般人往往看到if的「直说法」就会开始搞混。
That way, it would be obvious if
someone had clipped off a piece of the coin.
上面用would是单纯配合文章讲过去式的事情,非假设法。
用if someone had clipped off是代表某人若「已经」把钱币的一小块刮掉…
表示「已经」之意,用『完成式』,而又因是讲过去的事,用「过去完成式」,
跟假设法无关,这是单纯的直说法。
对於 if 的假设法和直说法的进一步说明,
我推荐英文名师刘毅之前写的一篇文章,应该对你有帮助:
http://www.learnschool.com.tw/aboutus.cfm?letters=120502&p=1
※ 引述《aska1219 (bokuwamusic)》之铭言:
: 想请教一下这段说明钱币为什麽有突起的文章中的一个句子:
: (大意就是为了防止有人把金币刮下来卖,所以设计小突起,这样被刮就很明显。)
: In the past, coins were made out of gold. Since these metals are valuable
: on their own, people would often illegally clip off pieces of a coin. To
: prevent it, coins were made with ridges. That way, it would be obvious if
: someone had clipped off a piece of the coin.
: 我的理解是,最後一句的if someone had clipped off a piece of the coin是表示
: 条件的副词子句(也就是条件子句),用had + p.p是因为发生在过去,并对应主要子句
: 时间上的顺序。(因为要满足被刮掉的条件,才有可能很明显。)
: 前文有提到常有人把金币刮下来卖,所以似乎不符合假设语气;如果属於假设语气,那
: 麽主要子句应改为it would have been obvious.
: 我想请教大家以上的理解有哪些错误的地方。谢谢!
--
※地狱※
http://b5.ctestimony.org/200204/020423ttdy.htm
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 114.36.100.128