※ 引述《Kremer (紐倫堡的名歌手)》之銘言： : ※ 引述《DreamBlack (金色轟炸機)》之銘言： : (omit) : : 如果你很堅持 想自己買 或是借不到 : : 那推薦你Bruckner可以買Jochum指揮德勒斯登的錄音 : : 是EMI的低價紙盒版 應該不到1000元 : : Mahler就要看預算了 : Bruckner可參考Jochum指揮BPO與巴伐利亞廣播交響樂團錄的DG全集，以及上述。 : 當然，布魯克納全集很多，但是記得不要買蕭提的就是了。 : 馬勒的全集很多，我推薦的是鄧許泰特的emi超低價版和辛諾波里dg版， : 如果覺得不過癮，可以選擇Bernstein 在dg的版本。千萬不要買庫貝力克就是了 就以馬勒全集來說 大致上便宜的版本 鄧許泰德(1300~1500) 11CD 這套便宜又大碗，錄音佳，詮釋嚴謹 入門者強烈建議 蕭提(1800~2000) 10CD 適合已經初步了解馬勒音樂的人 不建議入門者，錄音極佳，風格暴力強烈，理性詮釋 庫貝力克(1800~2000) 10CD 錄音算是偏差，亦適合入門者 風格隨性所至，行雲流水 海丁格(1800~2000) 10CD 錄音佳，在當時可謂相當傑出，入門者不適合 風格為理性中帶點輕鬆 中等價位的版本 辛諾波里(2700~3000) 15CD 錄音極佳，不適合入門 解析式的詮釋試探聽眾的口味 對不同口味的聽眾都可以接受包容 阿巴多(3200~3400) 12CD 錄音中等，詮釋誠懇 入門者強烈建議，非常忠實的表現出馬勒 很貴的版本 伯恩斯坦(4000~4500) 16CD 錄音佳，不適合入門，且價格昂貴 但對於已經初步了解馬勒音樂的人是非買不可 風格非常激情感性，甚至有瘋狂的傾向 易白爾(6000~6500) ?CD 錄音佳，適合入門者，但價格相當恐怖 詮釋平淡卻又輕鬆，理性而嚴謹 塔巴可夫(6000~6500) 15CD 這就請ChaosCreator兄簡介一下了 至於伯恩斯坦在CBS的全集我找了好久都沒看過 所以也不清楚大約價位多少 小弟所說的適合入門者與否並未帶有太多個人意見 純粹是就馬勒本身的音樂來出發 因為對於曲子本身就已經不熟的入門者而言 如果給予太強烈的指揮個人色彩 反而會影響聽者對音樂本身的認知與了解 甚至是被指揮給誤導了 尤其是伯恩斯坦的版本更是如此 大家聽一聽感覺都是很爽很讚 可是在企鵝評鑑中伯恩斯坦的版本卻表現不好 台灣跟日本都有相當多的聽眾為伯恩斯坦抱屈 然而其實伯恩斯坦的詮釋可謂過分扭曲馬勒的原意 而是否馬勒的音樂是否會令人著迷呢？ 小弟的答案是肯定的 看看有多少人在瘋狂收集馬勒就知道了 至於非全集的馬勒版本如下 如果有闕漏的也請各位版友幫忙補齊一下吧 Symphony No. 1 Minneapolis SO/Mitropoulos 1940 VSO/Horenstein 1953 NYPO/Walter 1955 VPO/Kubelik 1956 LPO/Boult 1958 VPO/Kletzki 1960 LPO/Scherchen 1960 SWDR SO/Rosbaud 1961 Columbia SO/Walter 1961 Concertgebouw/Haitink 1962 BSO/Leinsdorf 1963 LSO/Solti 1964 NYPO/Bernstein 1966 Halle/Barbirolli 1967 Bavarian Radio SO/Kubelik 1967 ONF/Markevitch 1967 RAI Turin SO/Markevitch 1967 LSO/Horenstein 1969 CSO/Giulini 1971 LSO/Levine 1975 Boston SO/Ozawa 1977 LSO/Fabermann 1979 CSO/Solti 1983 Philadelphia/Muti 1984 Frankfurt Radio SO/Inbal 1985 Concertgebouw/Bernstein 1987 BPO/Abbado 1989 Philharmonia/Sinopoli 1989 Prague Festival/Urbanek 1989 Minnesota SO/de Waart 1989 Cleveland/von Dohnanyi 1989 CSO/Tennstedt 1990 CBSO/Rattle 1991 NYPO/Masur 1992 Florida PO/Judd 1993 Royal SNO/Jarvi 1993 Danish National RSO/Segerstam 1993 Symphony No. 1 Titan (1893 version) NPO/Morris 1970 Symphony No. 2 Resurrection Unknown/unnamed orchestra/Fried 1923 VPO/Walter 1948 Concertgebouw/Klemperer 1951 Columbia SO/Walter 1958 Vienna State Opera/Scherchen 1960 LSO/Stokowski 1963 NYPO/Bernstein 1963 Philharmonia/Klemperer 1963 Bavarian Radio SO/Klemperer 1965 Utah SO/Abravanel 1967 Bavarian Radio SO/Kubelik 1969 Stuttgart Radio SO/Barbirolli 1970 LSO/Bernstein 1973 BBC SO/Boulez 1973 Symphonica of London/Morris 1978 LPO/Tennstedt 1982 Philharmonia/Sinopoli 1985 CBSO/Rattle 1986 NYPO/Bernstein 1988 LSO/Kaplan 1988 San Francisco SO/Blomstedt 1992 Danish National Radio SO/Segerstam 1992 Polish National RSO/Wit 1993 Concertgebouw/Chailly 2002 Symphony No. 3 Wiener Konzertverein/Adler 1953 Leipzig Radio SO/Scherchen 1960 Bavarian Radio SO/Kubelik 1967 Utah SO/Abravanel 1969 BPO/Barbirolli 1969 LSO/Horenstein 1970 RAI Milan SO/Maderna 1973 CSO/Levine 1975 LPO/Tennstedt 1979 VPO/Abbado 1982 NYPO/Bernstein 1987 Polish National Radio SO/Wit 1994 Symphony No. 4 New SO of Tokio/Konoyo 1930 Concertgebouw/Mengelberg 1939 NYPO/Walter 1946 Berlin Radio SO/Klemperer 1956 Philharmonia/Kletzki 1957 CSO/Reiner 1958 Cleveland/Szell 1966 Concertgebouw/Haitink 1967 Bavarian Radio SO/Kubelik 1968 LPO/Horenstein 1971 CSO/Levine 1975 BPO/Karajan 1979 Concertgebouw/Haitink 1983 CSO/Solti 1983 VPO/Maazel 1984 Concertgebouw/Bernstein 1987 SWDR SO Baden-Baden/Gielen 1988 LPO/Welser-Most 1988 Netherlands PO/Haenchen 1991 LAPO/Salonen 1992 Polish National Radio SO/Wit 1992 Concertgebouw/Chailly 2000 Symphony No. 5 NYPO/Walter 1947 Vienna State Opera/Scherchen 1952 BSO/Leinsdorf 1963 NYPO/Bernstein 1964 ORTF/Scherchen 1965 BBC SO/Boulez 1968 NPO/Barbirolli 1969 BBC SO/Boulez 1970 CSO/Solti 1970 Bavarian Radio SO/Kubelik 1971 RAI Milan SO/Maderna 1973 Symphonica of London/Morris 1974 LSO/Schwarz 1975 Philadelphia/Levine 1978 Philharmonia/Sinopoli 1985 VPO/Bernstein 1988 LPO/Tennstedt 1988 RPO/Inoue 1990 Polish National Radio SO/Wit 1990 Finnish RSO/Saraste 1991 BPO/Abbado 1994 Concertgebouw/Chailly 1998 Symphony No. 5 (Adagietto) Concertgebouw/Mengelberg 1926 VPO/Walter 1938 Philharmonia/Kletzki 1959 Symphony No. 6 WDR SO/Mitropoulos 1959 Leipzig Radio SO/Scherchen 1960 Stockholm PO/Horenstein 1966 NPO/Barbirolli 1967 NYPO/Bernstein 1967 Bavarian Radio SO/Kubelik 1968 NPO/Barbirolli 1969 BPO/Karajan 1978 LSO/Levine 1979 LPO/Tennstedt 1983 Frankfurt Radio SO/Inbal 1986 Philharmonia/Sinopoli 1986 VPO/Bernstein 1988 RPO/Inoue 1988 Netherlands PO/Haenchen 1989 BPO/Haitink 1989 Danish National Radio SO/Segerstam 1990 LPO/Tennstedt 1991 Royal Scottish National O/Jarvi 1992 Polish National RSO/Wit 1992 VPO/Boulez 1994 Symphony No. 7 Vienna SO/Scherchen 1950 Vienna State Opera/Scherchen 1952 Vienna SO/Scherchen 1960 Utah SO/Abravanel 1965 Toronto SO/Scherchen 1965 NPO/Horenstein 1969 Bavarian Radio SO/Kubelik 1970 RAI Milan SO/Maderna 1971 CSO/Levine 1980 Concertgebouw/Haitink 1982 CSO/Abbado 1984 NYPO/Bernstein 1985 CBSO/Rattle 1991 Danish National Radio SO/Segerstam 1991 Netherlands PO/Haenchen 1992 LPO/Tennstedt 1993 Polish National Radio SO/Halasz 1994 Symphony No. 8 Symphony of A Thousand PSONY/Stokowski 1950 LSO/Horenstein 1959 LSO/Bernstein 1966 Bavarian Radio SO/Kubelik 1970 Concertgebouw/Haitink 1971 CSO/Solti 1971 Symphonica of London/Morris 1973 VPO/Bernstein 1975 BBC SO/Boulez 1975 Opernhaus- und Museumsorchester Frankfurt/Gielen 1981 Philharmonia/Sinopoli 1990 BPO/Abbado 1994 Gothenberg SO/Jarvi 1994 Colorado MahlerFest Orchestra/Olson 1995 Danish National Radio SO/Segerstam 1993 Concertgebouw/Chailly 2001 Symphony No. 8 Symphony of A Thousand (Part 1) Berlin Staatskapelle/Scherchen 1951 NYPO/Bernstein 1962 Symphony No. 9 VPO/Walter 1938 Vienna SO/Scherchen 1950 Vienna SO/Horenstein 1952 RAI Turin SO/Barbirolli 1960 Columbia SO/Walter 1961 BPO/Barbirolli 1963 Czech PO/Ancerl 1966 LSO/Horenstein 1966 Orchestre National de France/Horenstein 1967 Bavarian Radio SO/Kubelik 1967 NPO/Klemperer 1968 American SO/Horenstein 1969 BBC SO/Boulez 1972 RAI Turin SO/Maderna 1972 BPO/Karajan 1982 Concertgebouw/Bernstein 1986 Frankfurt RSO/Inbal 1986 VPO/Abbado 1987 RLPO/Pesek 1990 Danish National Radio SO/Segerstam 1991 Philharmonia/Sanderling 1992 Moscow Radio SO/Barshai 1993 Polish National Radio SO/Halasz 1993 Philharmonia/Sinopoli 1993 NYPO/Masur 1994 Symphony No. 10 (Adagio) Vienna State Opera/Scherchen 1953 Leipzig Radio SO/Scherchen 1960 Czech PO/Neumann 1966 Bavarian Radio SO/Kubelik 1968 LSO/Boulez 1971 Concertgebouw/Haitink 1971 VPO/Bernstein 1974 VPO/Abbado 1985 Frankfurt RSO/Inbal 1986 Philharmonia/Sinopoli 1987 Bamberg SO/Rickenbacher 1988 Czech PO/Pesek 1989 Danish National Radio SO/Segerstam 1994 Polish National Radio SO/Wit 1994 Symphony No. 10 (Cooke) Philadelphia/Ormandy 1965 Berlin SO/Sanderling 1979 Berlin RSO/Chailly 1986 Frankfurt Radio SO/Inbal 1992 Das Lied von der Erde VPO/Walter 1936 VPO/Walter 1952 Concertgebouw/van Beinum 1957 Philharmonia/Kletzki 1959 SWDR SO/Rosbaud 1959 NYPO/Walter 1960 VSO/Klemperer 1961 NPO/Klemperer 1964 Concertgebouw/Jochum 1965 Czech PO/Neumann 1966 Philadelphia/Ormandy 1966 VPO/Bernstein 1967 VSO/Kleiber 1967 Cleveland/Szell 1970 Israel PO/Bernstein 1972 BBC Northern SO/Horenstein 1972 Concertgebouw/Haitink 1976 LPO/Tennstedt 1982 Czech PO/Neumann 1983 BPO/Giulini 1984 Cologne Radio SO/Bertini 1991 National SO of Ireland/Halasz 1994 --

※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 163.31.116.93 ※ 編輯: ashkenazy 來自: 163.31.116.93 (07/24 15:11)