作者ashkenazy (谁杀了古典音乐!)
看板clmusic
标题Re: [问题] 马勒&布鲁克纳的版本
时间Wed Jul 24 15:07:08 2002
※ 引述《Kremer (纽伦堡的名歌手)》之铭言:
: ※ 引述《DreamBlack (金色轰炸机)》之铭言:
: (omit)
: : 如果你很坚持 想自己买 或是借不到
: : 那推荐你Bruckner可以买Jochum指挥德勒斯登的录音
: : 是EMI的低价纸盒版 应该不到1000元
: : Mahler就要看预算了
: Bruckner可参考Jochum指挥BPO与巴伐利亚广播交响乐团录的DG全集,以及上述。
: 当然,布鲁克纳全集很多,但是记得不要买萧提的就是了。
: 马勒的全集很多,我推荐的是邓许泰特的emi超低价版和辛诺波里dg版,
: 如果觉得不过瘾,可以选择Bernstein 在dg的版本。千万不要买库贝力克就是了
就以马勒全集来说
大致上便宜的版本
邓许泰德(1300~1500) 11CD
这套便宜又大碗,录音佳,诠释严谨
入门者强烈建议
萧提(1800~2000) 10CD
适合已经初步了解马勒音乐的人
不建议入门者,录音极佳,风格暴力强烈,理性诠释
库贝力克(1800~2000) 10CD
录音算是偏差,亦适合入门者
风格随性所至,行云流水
海丁格(1800~2000) 10CD
录音佳,在当时可谓相当杰出,入门者不适合
风格为理性中带点轻松
中等价位的版本
辛诺波里(2700~3000) 15CD
录音极佳,不适合入门
解析式的诠释试探听众的口味
对不同口味的听众都可以接受包容
阿巴多(3200~3400) 12CD
录音中等,诠释诚恳
入门者强烈建议,非常忠实的表现出马勒
很贵的版本
伯恩斯坦(4000~4500) 16CD
录音佳,不适合入门,且价格昂贵
但对於已经初步了解马勒音乐的人是非买不可
风格非常激情感性,甚至有疯狂的倾向
易白尔(6000~6500) ?CD
录音佳,适合入门者,但价格相当恐怖
诠释平淡却又轻松,理性而严谨
塔巴可夫(6000~6500) 15CD
这就请ChaosCreator兄简介一下了
至於伯恩斯坦在CBS的全集我找了好久都没看过
所以也不清楚大约价位多少
小弟所说的适合入门者与否并未带有太多个人意见
纯粹是就马勒本身的音乐来出发
因为对於曲子本身就已经不熟的入门者而言
如果给予太强烈的指挥个人色彩
反而会影响听者对音乐本身的认知与了解
甚至是被指挥给误导了
尤其是伯恩斯坦的版本更是如此
大家听一听感觉都是很爽很赞
可是在企鹅评监中伯恩斯坦的版本却表现不好
台湾跟日本都有相当多的听众为伯恩斯坦抱屈
然而其实伯恩斯坦的诠释可谓过分扭曲马勒的原意
而是否马勒的音乐是否会令人着迷呢?
小弟的答案是肯定的
看看有多少人在疯狂收集马勒就知道了
至於非全集的马勒版本如下
如果有阙漏的也请各位版友帮忙补齐一下吧
Symphony No. 1
Minneapolis SO/Mitropoulos 1940
VSO/Horenstein 1953
NYPO/Walter 1955
VPO/Kubelik 1956
LPO/Boult 1958
VPO/Kletzki 1960
LPO/Scherchen 1960
SWDR SO/Rosbaud 1961
Columbia SO/Walter 1961
Concertgebouw/Haitink 1962
BSO/Leinsdorf 1963
LSO/Solti 1964
NYPO/Bernstein 1966
Halle/Barbirolli 1967
Bavarian Radio SO/Kubelik 1967
ONF/Markevitch 1967
RAI Turin SO/Markevitch 1967
LSO/Horenstein 1969
CSO/Giulini 1971
LSO/Levine 1975
Boston SO/Ozawa 1977
LSO/Fabermann 1979
CSO/Solti 1983
Philadelphia/Muti 1984
Frankfurt Radio SO/Inbal 1985
Concertgebouw/Bernstein 1987
BPO/Abbado 1989
Philharmonia/Sinopoli 1989
Prague Festival/Urbanek 1989
Minnesota SO/de Waart 1989
Cleveland/von Dohnanyi 1989
CSO/Tennstedt 1990
CBSO/Rattle 1991
NYPO/Masur 1992
Florida PO/Judd 1993
Royal SNO/Jarvi 1993
Danish National RSO/Segerstam 1993
Symphony No. 1 Titan (1893 version)
NPO/Morris 1970
Symphony No. 2 Resurrection
Unknown/unnamed orchestra/Fried 1923
VPO/Walter 1948
Concertgebouw/Klemperer 1951
Columbia SO/Walter 1958
Vienna State Opera/Scherchen 1960
LSO/Stokowski 1963
NYPO/Bernstein 1963
Philharmonia/Klemperer 1963
Bavarian Radio SO/Klemperer 1965
Utah SO/Abravanel 1967
Bavarian Radio SO/Kubelik 1969
Stuttgart Radio SO/Barbirolli 1970
LSO/Bernstein 1973
BBC SO/Boulez 1973
Symphonica of London/Morris 1978
LPO/Tennstedt 1982
Philharmonia/Sinopoli 1985
CBSO/Rattle 1986
NYPO/Bernstein 1988
LSO/Kaplan 1988
San Francisco SO/Blomstedt 1992
Danish National Radio SO/Segerstam 1992
Polish National RSO/Wit 1993
Concertgebouw/Chailly 2002
Symphony No. 3
Wiener Konzertverein/Adler 1953
Leipzig Radio SO/Scherchen 1960
Bavarian Radio SO/Kubelik 1967
Utah SO/Abravanel 1969
BPO/Barbirolli 1969
LSO/Horenstein 1970
RAI Milan SO/Maderna 1973
CSO/Levine 1975
LPO/Tennstedt 1979
VPO/Abbado 1982
NYPO/Bernstein 1987
Polish National Radio SO/Wit 1994
Symphony No. 4
New SO of Tokio/Konoyo 1930
Concertgebouw/Mengelberg 1939
NYPO/Walter 1946
Berlin Radio SO/Klemperer 1956
Philharmonia/Kletzki 1957
CSO/Reiner 1958
Cleveland/Szell 1966
Concertgebouw/Haitink 1967
Bavarian Radio SO/Kubelik 1968
LPO/Horenstein 1971
CSO/Levine 1975
BPO/Karajan 1979
Concertgebouw/Haitink 1983
CSO/Solti 1983
VPO/Maazel 1984
Concertgebouw/Bernstein 1987
SWDR SO Baden-Baden/Gielen 1988
LPO/Welser-Most 1988
Netherlands PO/Haenchen 1991
LAPO/Salonen 1992
Polish National Radio SO/Wit 1992
Concertgebouw/Chailly 2000
Symphony No. 5
NYPO/Walter 1947
Vienna State Opera/Scherchen 1952
BSO/Leinsdorf 1963
NYPO/Bernstein 1964
ORTF/Scherchen 1965
BBC SO/Boulez 1968
NPO/Barbirolli 1969
BBC SO/Boulez 1970
CSO/Solti 1970
Bavarian Radio SO/Kubelik 1971
RAI Milan SO/Maderna 1973
Symphonica of London/Morris 1974
LSO/Schwarz 1975
Philadelphia/Levine 1978
Philharmonia/Sinopoli 1985
VPO/Bernstein 1988
LPO/Tennstedt 1988
RPO/Inoue 1990
Polish National Radio SO/Wit 1990
Finnish RSO/Saraste 1991
BPO/Abbado 1994
Concertgebouw/Chailly 1998
Symphony No. 5 (Adagietto)
Concertgebouw/Mengelberg 1926
VPO/Walter 1938
Philharmonia/Kletzki 1959
Symphony No. 6
WDR SO/Mitropoulos 1959
Leipzig Radio SO/Scherchen 1960
Stockholm PO/Horenstein 1966
NPO/Barbirolli 1967
NYPO/Bernstein 1967
Bavarian Radio SO/Kubelik 1968
NPO/Barbirolli 1969
BPO/Karajan 1978
LSO/Levine 1979
LPO/Tennstedt 1983
Frankfurt Radio SO/Inbal 1986
Philharmonia/Sinopoli 1986
VPO/Bernstein 1988
RPO/Inoue 1988
Netherlands PO/Haenchen 1989
BPO/Haitink 1989
Danish National Radio SO/Segerstam 1990
LPO/Tennstedt 1991
Royal Scottish National O/Jarvi 1992
Polish National RSO/Wit 1992
VPO/Boulez 1994
Symphony No. 7
Vienna SO/Scherchen 1950
Vienna State Opera/Scherchen 1952
Vienna SO/Scherchen 1960
Utah SO/Abravanel 1965
Toronto SO/Scherchen 1965
NPO/Horenstein 1969
Bavarian Radio SO/Kubelik 1970
RAI Milan SO/Maderna 1971
CSO/Levine 1980
Concertgebouw/Haitink 1982
CSO/Abbado 1984
NYPO/Bernstein 1985
CBSO/Rattle 1991
Danish National Radio SO/Segerstam 1991
Netherlands PO/Haenchen 1992
LPO/Tennstedt 1993
Polish National Radio SO/Halasz 1994
Symphony No. 8 Symphony of A Thousand
PSONY/Stokowski 1950
LSO/Horenstein 1959
LSO/Bernstein 1966
Bavarian Radio SO/Kubelik 1970
Concertgebouw/Haitink 1971
CSO/Solti 1971
Symphonica of London/Morris 1973
VPO/Bernstein 1975
BBC SO/Boulez 1975
Opernhaus- und Museumsorchester Frankfurt/Gielen 1981
Philharmonia/Sinopoli 1990
BPO/Abbado 1994
Gothenberg SO/Jarvi 1994
Colorado MahlerFest Orchestra/Olson 1995
Danish National Radio SO/Segerstam 1993
Concertgebouw/Chailly 2001
Symphony No. 8 Symphony of A Thousand (Part 1)
Berlin Staatskapelle/Scherchen 1951
NYPO/Bernstein 1962
Symphony No. 9
VPO/Walter 1938
Vienna SO/Scherchen 1950
Vienna SO/Horenstein 1952
RAI Turin SO/Barbirolli 1960
Columbia SO/Walter 1961
BPO/Barbirolli 1963
Czech PO/Ancerl 1966
LSO/Horenstein 1966
Orchestre National de France/Horenstein 1967
Bavarian Radio SO/Kubelik 1967
NPO/Klemperer 1968
American SO/Horenstein 1969
BBC SO/Boulez 1972
RAI Turin SO/Maderna 1972
BPO/Karajan 1982
Concertgebouw/Bernstein 1986
Frankfurt RSO/Inbal 1986
VPO/Abbado 1987
RLPO/Pesek 1990
Danish National Radio SO/Segerstam 1991
Philharmonia/Sanderling 1992
Moscow Radio SO/Barshai 1993
Polish National Radio SO/Halasz 1993
Philharmonia/Sinopoli 1993
NYPO/Masur 1994
Symphony No. 10 (Adagio)
Vienna State Opera/Scherchen 1953
Leipzig Radio SO/Scherchen 1960
Czech PO/Neumann 1966
Bavarian Radio SO/Kubelik 1968
LSO/Boulez 1971
Concertgebouw/Haitink 1971
VPO/Bernstein 1974
VPO/Abbado 1985
Frankfurt RSO/Inbal 1986
Philharmonia/Sinopoli 1987
Bamberg SO/Rickenbacher 1988
Czech PO/Pesek 1989
Danish National Radio SO/Segerstam 1994
Polish National Radio SO/Wit 1994
Symphony No. 10 (Cooke)
Philadelphia/Ormandy 1965
Berlin SO/Sanderling 1979
Berlin RSO/Chailly 1986
Frankfurt Radio SO/Inbal 1992
Das Lied von der Erde
VPO/Walter 1936
VPO/Walter 1952
Concertgebouw/van Beinum 1957
Philharmonia/Kletzki 1959
SWDR SO/Rosbaud 1959
NYPO/Walter 1960
VSO/Klemperer 1961
NPO/Klemperer 1964
Concertgebouw/Jochum 1965
Czech PO/Neumann 1966
Philadelphia/Ormandy 1966
VPO/Bernstein 1967
VSO/Kleiber 1967
Cleveland/Szell 1970
Israel PO/Bernstein 1972
BBC Northern SO/Horenstein 1972
Concertgebouw/Haitink 1976
LPO/Tennstedt 1982
Czech PO/Neumann 1983
BPO/Giulini 1984
Cologne Radio SO/Bertini 1991
National SO of Ireland/Halasz 1994
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 163.31.116.93
※ 编辑: ashkenazy 来自: 163.31.116.93 (07/24 15:11)