作者nikesecond (NikeXAdidas)
看板TaylorSwift
標題[情報] The 150 Greatest Albums Made By Women
時間Tue Apr 10 14:03:44 2018
來源:
https://goo.gl/upEduT
標題: Turning The Tables: The 150 Greatest Albums Made By Women
(As Chosen By You)
這個榜單是由NPR Turning the Tables readers' poll產生
Taylor有四張專輯入圍:
13. 1989
19. Reputation
33. Red
148. Fearless
有點驚訝Fearless的排名這麼後面
是因為這個榜單比較偏向流行嗎?
Speak Now跟同名專輯都沒入圍
另外Taylor是30歲下排名最高的(Adele還沒滿30啊?)
摘錄Taylor的部分:
Taylor Swift, whose music has dominated the current
historical moment just as Mitchell's strongly defined
the turn of the 1970s, stands for a different central
tenet of canon-making, one the original document,
assembled by "experts," obscured. Fan activism matters.
Swifties place four of her albums here — only one,
Fearless, made the first Turning the Tables, squeaking
into the Top 100 at 99. Here, Swift is the highest
ranking artist under 30, with 1989 claiming lucky 13.
13. Taylor Swift - "1989" (Big Machine Records, 2013)
"Without even considering the superb song-craft on this
album and its can't-get-this-damn-song-out-of-my-head
hooks, the cultural impact of 1989 is undeniable. Not
only has everyone heard at least a few songs off of this
album, but it also helped define the pop sound of this
decade, ushering in a new wave of '80s-inspired synths.
Its themes of independence and freedom resonate with mass
audiences, whilst concurrently reminding us that pop music
doesn't have to be vapid. How often do we get albums as
multi-talented as this?"
19. Taylor Swift - "Reputation" (Big Machine, 2017)
"The old Taylor can't come to the phone."
"In the death of her reputation, she felt truly alive."
"A grower. Unexpectedly vulnerable, poignant, under the
brash and aggressive armor."
33. Taylor Swift - "Red" (Big Machine, 2012)
"The first album to show not only her depth, but her
breadth as a songwriter, singer and purveyor of culture.
Speak Now was the album on which she fully took the
reigns and wrote every song alone. It may even flow
better as an overall album. But the high points of Red
are unimpeachable. Stadium rock, pop country, coffeeshop
confessionals, synthpop celebrations and the most
controversial EDM drop of the digital era were all
carefully housed under the watchful ear and pen of our
greatest and most consistently undervalued modern
songwriter. It's also home to her two best songs, 'All
Too Well' and 'Begin Again.'"
148. Taylor Swift - "Fearless" (Big Machine, 2008)
前20名如下:
1. Joni Mitchell - "Blue" (Reprise, 1971)
2. Carole King - "Tapestry" (Ode, 1971)
3. Lauryn Hill - "The Miseducation of Lauryn Hill"
(Ruffhouse/Columbia, 1998)
4. Kate Bush - "Hounds of Love" (EMI, 1985)
5. Janis Joplin - "Pearl" (Columbia, 1971)
6. Patti Smith - "Horses" (Arista, 1975)
7. Amy Winehouse - "Back to Black" (Island, 2006)
8. Beyoncé - "Lemonade" (Parkwood/Columbia, 2016)
9. Tori Amos - "Little Earthquakes" (Atlantic, 1992)
10. Joni Mitchell - "Court and Spark" (Asylum, 1974)
11. Adele - "21" (XL/Columbia, 2011)
12. Liz Phair - "Exile in Guyville" (Matador, 1993)
13. Taylor Swift - "1989" (Big Machine Records, 2014)
14. Aretha Franklin - "I Never Loved a Man the Way I Love You"
(Atlantic, 1967)
15. Björk - "Homogenic" (One Little Indian/Elektra, 1997)
16. Lucinda Williams - "Car Wheels on a Gravel Road"
(Mercury, 1998)
17. Tori Amos - "Boys for Pele" (Atlantic, 1996)
18. Tracy Chapman - "Tracy Chapman" (Elektra, 1988)
19. Taylor Swift - "Reputation" (Big Machine, 2017)
20. Joni Mitchell - "Hejira" (Asylum, 1976)
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 118.163.84.235
※ 文章網址: https://webptt.com/m.aspx?n=bbs/TaylorSwift/M.1523340226.A.40D.html
1F:推 light20735: Reputation居然能這麼前面我覺得這排行很愛泰勒了 04/10 16:44
2F:→ light20735: 上榜次數4次可能最多,反觀Gaga TheFameMonster才104 04/10 16:45
3F:→ light20735: Lorde我也覺得有點捧太高...第二章專輯超不抓耳 04/10 16:45
4F:推 swizzleyeh: 我覺得Melodrama很好聽欸 可惜沒有Speak Now 04/10 17:23
5F:推 amanda0ray: 為什麼Speak now這麼被低估QAQ 04/10 17:57
6F:→ swizzleyeh: 覺得rep出乎意料的高 發行五個月後 覺得1989比較耐聽 04/10 18:35
7F:推 light20735: 純粹因為我覺得Pure Heroine比較好聽 04/10 22:24
8F:推 jaemu734: 沒有我最愛的Speak Now QAQ 04/10 23:36
9F:→ nikesecond: 投票人數有4500名,看前二十猜這些讀者群不愛鄉村XD 04/11 01:03
10F:→ nikesecond: 上榜次數 Joni(7), kate b.(5) Madonna(4), Tori(4) 04/11 01:08
11F:推 bruceliu: Melodrama 很好聽呀~ 04/11 07:29
12F:推 lautomne: 有Red滿開心的 04/11 22:00
13F:→ lin881102: 抱歉speak now是她所有裡面我最愛的==那張才是神專 04/12 02:08
14F:推 carpediemdav: 果然1989還是排最高的…看入選四張專輯的排序,突破 04/14 16:21
15F:→ carpediemdav: 性應該是最主要的評比標準 04/14 16:21