作者MathforPhy (Wakka)
看板Physics
標題[新聞] 中微子實驗忘記GPS誤差
時間Mon Oct 17 20:58:32 2011
Don't fire up your spaceship's FTL drive just yet, folks. Those neutrinos
that CERN scientists thought they saw traveling faster than the speed of
light a few weeks ago look like they may have only been moving at close to
light speed.
Last month, a team of international researchers shocked the scientific world
with the news that particles they had been firing for several years from the
CERN particle accelerator in Switzerland at detectors at the OPERA facility
in Gran Sasso, Italy placed about 450 miles away appeared to be arriving at
their destination faster than the time it would take light to get there.
The particles, traveling through air, water, and rock, shouldn't have hit the
Gran Sasso detectors sooner than about 2.4 thousandths of a second after
being fired, which is the time it would take light to travel the distance
between the two points. Yet the CERN researchers reported that their
neutrinos were getting to the target 64 nanoseconds faster—meaning that they
were traveling faster than light, supposedly impossible according to the
Theory of Special Relativity.
Now other scientists say that a failure to fully account for the effects of
relativity is what caused the original researchers to supposedly mis-measure
the time it was taking the neutrinos to travel using a GPS satellite, despite
the CERN team saying they had factored relativity into their calculations.
A new paper by Dutch researcher Ronald A.J. van Elburg lays out the case that
the GPS satellite measuring the neutrinos' movements was also moving relative
to the CERN and OPERA facilities as it orbited the Earth. Briefly, van Elburg
asserts that the effects of relativity as they pertain to the GPS satellite's
measurements require two corrections to the perceived time of travel.
Lo and behold, it turns out that applying that double correction shaves 64
nanoseconds off the neutrinos' travel time, according to van Elburg, "[t]hus
bringing the apparent velocities of neutrinos back to a value not
significantly different from the speed of light."
It's too early to say whether that's the final verdict on this story—the
CERN scientists did claim to have accounted for such factors in their report.
But for now, it appears that making the jump to hyperspace may be just as far
off as it was before some seemingly super-fast neutrinos got us all excited
about being Han Solo.
http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2394747,00.asp#fbid=Txpjiai5wg_
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 114.41.219.117
1F:→ caseypie:昨天聽到這個消息的時候辦公室的一致反應是這未免也太囧 10/17 21:09
2F:推 xgcj:結果XD 10/17 21:23
4F:→ caseypie:發這種文章還真不留情面,要對嗆了 10/17 21:30
5F:→ caseypie:有人說arXiv就是全世界物理鄉民的戰場,果真不假 10/17 21:30
6F:推 xgcj:開戰瞜!(沙發) 10/17 21:31
7F:推 sunev:有Ig Nobel的等級...XD 10/17 21:52
8F:推 zealeliot:.....要得搞笑諾貝爾了嗎? XD 10/17 22:17
9F:推 ren1072:爆米花(伸 10/17 22:20
10F:推 j0958322080:不知道OPERA會怎樣反擊耶 10/17 22:24
11F:推 herstein:突然覺得臉被打得很痛喔XD參考文線第一篇XD 10/17 22:44
12F:推 sunev:他還有引用Michelson & Morley耶...XDXD 10/17 22:45
13F:推 herstein:哈哈~~~這一系列真精彩 10/17 22:49
14F:推 j0958322080:CERN表示: 10/17 22:51
15F:推 agoodjob:果然是之前猜測的儀器誤差 10/17 22:52
16F:推 Farady:為何需要GPS? 對時用? 10/17 23:12
17F:推 yeahhuman:現在只是另一個團隊提出 又還沒確認就是這因素吧...? 10/17 23:14
18F:→ yeahhuman:怎麼已經有版友用到"果然"這個詞 10/17 23:14
19F:推 agoodjob:那很重要嗎? =.=|| 10/17 23:21
20F:推 yeahhuman:因為還沒確認啊 原研究團隊還沒出來說明是不是這樣 10/17 23:24
21F:推 herstein:反正每個人都有自己支持的觀點Why not XD 10/17 23:26
22F:→ agoodjob:.............. 10/17 23:26
23F:→ agoodjob:沒想到有人那麼介意.. XD 10/17 23:27
24F:推 CJO1I6:終於落幕了XD 10/18 01:06
25F:→ pipidog:沒有落幕,這只是某個group的challenge吧? 類似的challenge 10/18 02:08
26F:→ pipidog:去網路上搜一狗票耶? 所以哪篇質疑才是對的? 言之過早吧 10/18 02:09
27F:推 laertes:他用參考文獻超狠...直接用最原版的...哈哈哈... 10/18 07:57
28F:→ chungweitw: 還好吧. 講歷史的時候順便 cite 一下而已 10/18 08:47
29F:推 rbgspydm:CERN糗了...雖然結果有可能還是>C, 但這個真的很囧 10/18 09:05
30F:推 CJO1I6:soga~很期待cern到底如何應對 10/18 11:33
31F:推 stella323:最後還是挑戰失敗 10/18 15:42
32F:推 waddler:CERN有特別需要應對嗎? 目前他們處理這樁"發現"還挺得體的 10/18 20:57
33F:推 yeahhuman:其實怎麼想都覺得忽略gps衛星自身移動很誇張 10/18 22:16
34F:→ yeahhuman:對做粒子實驗的 data是在哪個frame看到是本能反應 10/18 22:17
35F:→ yeahhuman:所以我覺得這challenge搞不好會失敗... 10/18 22:18
36F:推 amozartea:arXiv本來就戰場阿 有大師不愛期刊專發arXiv的.... 10/19 02:03
37F:→ amozartea:然後裡面嗆另一個(比較晚輩的)大師XD 超有趣 10/19 02:03
38F:推 JohnMash:愛因斯坦並沒有忘記GPS誤差 10/20 12:47