作者DPP48 (落跑的小五郎)
看板Orl-Magic
標題[新聞] 2023魔術選秀結果各網站短評
時間Fri Jun 23 18:17:00 2023
選完了,轉貼一下各家網站對魔術選秀的評價
平均來說No.6算是選得中規中矩,No.11就有點慘,謎之選擇,只能說相信GM吧
今年各家網站唯一選前預測魔術第一輪正確的是CBS Sports
就從CBS Sports 開始貼起
(1) CBS Sports
6. Orlando Magic: PG Anthony Black, Arkansas
Grade: A
I love it. This is someone who many thought would last to No. 8, but that
would have been too late for a player who can contribute on both sides. He
has proven himself to be a true big point guard, adding weight without losing
speed or agility. The question is his shooting, and he has looked better in
the draft process than he looked in college. If he can figure that end out,
he will be a top five player in this class no doubt.
11. Orlando Magic (via Bulls): SG Jett Howard, Michigan
Grade: C+
This pick is one of the first real head-scratchers of the night. The son of
Michigan coach Juwan Howard is one of the best tough shot-makers in the draft
and has solid positional size. But he is a defensive liability, and though he
can shoot, there are better shooters on the board to help Orlando with that
issue (Jordan Hawkins and Gradey Dick). Many expected him to be drafted
toward the end of Round 1, not in the lottery.
---------------------
(2) Yahoo Sports!
6. Orlando: G Anthony Black, Arkansas
Grade: A
Black has the potential to be one of the best guards in this draft class with
his size as a primary ball-handler, vision in the open court and length on
defense. Black was one of the best passers in college basketball this past
season and has high upside.
11. Orlando (from Chicago): G Jett Howard, Michigan
Grade: C-
Howard comes from an NBA pedigree with his dad, Juwan, playing almost 20
years in the NBA. Howard is a solid outside shooter, particularly in
catch-and-shoot situations. Howard needs to improve his lateral quickness on
defense but makes up for it with his length. He joins Orlando's very crowded
backcourt.
--------------------
(3) Sporting News
6. Orlando Magic: Anthony Black, Arkansas
Grade: A+
The Magic needed guard help and they land the best playmaker in the entire
draft class in Black. Adding the 6-7 jumbo guard alongside skilled forwards
like Paolo Banchero and Franz Wagner gives Orlando a number of intriguing
lineups that should pose mismatches for opposing teams. If they add a shooter
at No. 11, we’re looking at a very successful draft night for the Magic.
11. Orlando Magic (via CHI): Jett Howard, Michigan
Grade: B
The Magic address a massive void for a perimeter shooter, but Howard is an
interesting choice with prospects like Gradey Dick and Jordan Hawkins on the
board. However, Howard will still provide Orlando with a 3-point marksman who
has the potential to be a versatile defender with a 6-8 frame if it can get
him to buy in on that side of the ball.
--------------------
(4) NY POST
Orlando Magic — Grade: D
No. 6: Anthony Black, G, Florida
No. 11: Jett Howard, G, Michigan
First, Orlando chose another guard who can’t shoot in Arkansas’ Anthony
Black at No. 6, then they reached for Michigan’s Jett Howard at No. 11, who
wasn’t expected to go until the mid-20’s.
Howard, the son of former NBA player and Michigan coach Juwan Howard, does
shoot the ball at a high level – and Orlando had a major need there –
hitting 36.8 percent on 7.3 attempts.
But he doesn’t impact the game in any other way. Curious decisions, to say
the least.
---------------------
(5) Bleacher Report
6. Orlando Magic: Anthony Black (PG/SG, Arkansas)
Grade: B+
The Magic arguably entered the night with more point guards than they needed,
and they added another here. I actually like that, since it shows Orlando
felt Black was the best player available and valued that more than anything.
That's the smart move for any rebuilder to make.
Black arrives in the Association with an advanced understanding of the game
of basketball. Fortune-tellers don't pick up on things as quickly as he can.
And he's not just a step ahead of the defense, he's also often a few inches
taller as a 6'7" floor general. That means he can already read and see the
floor better than most. His playmaking will make him a quick favorite in the
locker room.
There aren't many boxes he leaves unchecked, but the exceptions are
worrisome. He can't shoot, and he isn't super shifty as a ball-handler. If he
isn't a shooting threat and can't beat defenders off the bounce, how is he
going to run an NBA offense? For someone with so many winning traits, his
lowest-end outcome looks rough.
Still, his combination of size, smarts and skill is enough reason to buy in.
Orlando will have to clear out its backcourt congestion at some point, but
that's because Black might already be the best of the bunch.
11. Orlando Magic (via Bulls): Jett Howard (SF, Michigan)
Grade: D
The Magic entered the night with a clear need for shooting, and using the No.
6 pick on Anthony Black did little to address that. Clearly, that was the
motivation behind this pick, but it could be the night's first big reach.
Howard has NBA pedigree as the son of longtime pro (and his college coach)
Juwan Howard, plus the size, shooting and basketball IQ to carve out a
lengthy career of his own. He is a lights-out shooter with his feet set and a
potential sharpshooter on the move. He is comfortable (though not dynamic)
with the ball in his hands, either side-stepping for threes or making the
simple, smart pass to an open teammate.
But he isn't a great athlete by NBA standards, and that could limit his
utility as a defender. It's hard to project which players Orlando will even
ask him to defend, since he's had trouble against both quickness and strength.
If the Magic were fine with a shooting specialist, why not Gradey Dick or
Jordan Hawkins instead? If they wanted shooting and more, why not stop Cam
Whitmore's skid here? This one is a puzzler.
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 112.78.93.172 (臺灣)
※ 文章網址: https://webptt.com/m.aspx?n=bbs/Orl-Magic/M.1687515422.A.937.html
1F:推 withouttalk: 6:A,11:F 06/23 18:32
2F:→ withouttalk: jett穿鞋6‘8不是6’10,真的悲劇 06/23 18:34
3F:→ withouttalk: 如果向下交易加上1隻未來首輪才合理,虧到只輸勇士 06/23 18:35
4F:推 rbking21: 看起來是#6多數好評 #11被批得慘不忍睹XD 06/23 18:42
5F:→ rbking21: 不過我們也不能忘記21年選秀,再看看吧 06/23 18:42
6F:→ rbking21: 要投射要size都有 唯一爭議是reach 06/23 18:43
7F:推 withouttalk: Jett應該還不如Houstan 太傻眼了 06/23 18:44
9F:→ rbking21: 好圖值得一發再發 06/23 18:46
10F:→ JameerNe1son: 我們前場又不缺人,Jett長太高反而沒球打,6’7打搖 06/23 18:46
11F:→ JameerNe1son: 擺人差不多 06/23 18:46
12F:→ rbking21: 經過這幾年 我的定論就是別太早下定論 06/23 18:47
13F:→ JameerNe1son: 說Jett不如Houstan就真的太誇張了 ...... 06/23 18:48
14F:→ rbking21: 我反而對Black比較有意見 除非把他當側翼組織前鋒用 06/23 18:48
15F:→ rbking21: 可能就#6 BPA #11 fit的想法吧 06/23 18:48
16F:噓 withouttalk: Dick只輸Jett一點,未來沒先發留不住,Jett沒人搶 06/23 19:02
17F:推 JameerNe1son: 不過在活塞選Ausar之後,當下最好的選擇就只剩下Bla 06/23 19:02
18F:→ JameerNe1son: ck了,目前看起來會是富人版MCW?但是Black的彈跳力 06/23 19:02
19F:→ JameerNe1son: 很猛,加上空間感好,也許第一年能以空切二傳為主? 06/23 19:02
20F:推 withouttalk: Black1-3號都能打,又不黏球..Cole跟兒子沒便宜續的 06/23 19:05
21F:→ withouttalk: 肯定被交易掉 06/23 19:05
22F:推 withouttalk: Suggs每天苦練,未來Suggs+black的後埸很有趣 06/23 19:10
23F:推 oude: 不知道後衛群輪替變怎樣 SG改Jett先發? 後衛好壅擠 06/23 19:16
24F:→ oude: 之前替補都Franz幫忙控場 改Black帶替補? 06/23 19:19
25F:推 GGGHILL: 我覺得會給 Suggs 先發打2號,Black, Cole 替補出發,Jet 06/23 19:22
26F:→ GGGHILL: t 替補 3-2 號 06/23 19:22
27F:推 oude: 賣掉2輪籤覺得有點可惜 有很多大四即戰力的內線 本來以為會 06/23 19:38
28F:推 GGGHILL: 我猜 FA 會補強籃板 06/23 19:39
29F:→ oude: 補像Drew Timme之類的球員 06/23 19:41
30F:推 withouttalk: 我猜2年1000補強中鋒mo bamba 06/23 19:42
31F:→ withouttalk: Timme去公鹿了 06/23 19:43
32F:→ oude: Trayce Jackson-Davis 看庫奇在推薦 我也覺得不錯 沒想58勇 06/23 19:48
33F:→ oude: 士還真得還選得到 以為2輪初就被挑走 06/23 19:48
34F:推 slashmac: 感覺班霸回魔術也不是不可能@@ 06/23 19:50
35F:推 withouttalk: Sanogo 居然也落選 06/23 19:50
36F:→ withouttalk: Bamba:LA真好玩…LBJ太兇了 06/23 19:51
37F:推 slashmac: Sanogo去公牛囉 06/23 20:01
38F:推 GGGHILL: 我看,就是我大 V 回歸的時候了! 06/23 20:06
39F:→ GGGHILL: 來個 3年 60-65M 06/23 20:06
41F:→ DPP48: 大V好像會跟公牛續 06/23 20:44
42F:推 withouttalk: Juwan Howard是Jett的教練,Franz/houstan也是…所 06/23 21:14
43F:→ withouttalk: 以這是11換總教練?難怪Mosley臉那麼臭 06/23 21:14
44F:推 CHERRYCOLA: 不認為公牛會放掉那個9號 06/23 21:15
45F:→ withouttalk: 換個養成型的Juwan Howard教練這我突然能接受Jett了 06/23 21:16
46F:推 rbking21: 腦補太多了啦XDD 06/23 21:22
48F:→ withouttalk: Jett沒比Black高,估計就穿鞋6‘7,標準的SG身材 06/23 23:48
49F:推 rbking21: 這張Black鞋子超高的吧 還有爆炸頭的關係 06/23 23:54
※ 編輯: DPP48 (125.229.35.103 臺灣), 06/25/2023 02:17:46