作者pursuistmi (common people)
看板IA
標題[新聞]如果民調是錯的...?
時間Tue Nov 4 19:10:38 2008
標題:What If the Polls Are Wrong?
November 03, 2008 8:22 PM
There have been in the neighborhood of 159 national polls in the last six
weeks.
Most of those polls have Barack Obama ahead of John McCain, including our
ABC News/Washington Post daily tracking poll, that has Obama comfortably
ahead 53-44.
But what if the polls are wrong?
It's happened before.
Remember that famous Chicago Tribune newspaper headline "Dewey Defeats
Truman" back in 1948? But in that case, the last polls of the election had
been completed in mid-October. Not on the eve of the election.
If it turns out that McCain wins tomorrow night in the face of so many polls
that even at this late hour show Obama ahead comfortably, I think you have to
say that the industry of political public opinion polling in this country
will be shot.
They'll have to build from the ground up. People will have to rethink how
they do this work.
The same thing will hold true for the political media. We know that polls
are just a snapshot in time.
But I think Americans will really questions what they're hearing from now on
from the political media.
Probably even more important, if this happens tomorrow, I think a significant
number of Americans will be in a state of political shock.
They may not believe what they're seeing tomorrow night.
Right now we're looking at polls where not only is Obama ahead nationally,
he's ahead in the key states he needs to win.
Of course, anything can happen tomorrow. The media has had to eat crow on
election night before.
But we've never really seen so much polling at this late date all pointing in
the same direction.
--George Stephanopoulos
http://blogs.abcnews.com/george/2008/11/what-if-the-pol.html
新聞來源: (需有正確連結)
--
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 220.129.168.177
1F:推 tratrason:真正的民調數字其實就是前年的國會改選結果 因為那個就 11/04 19:13
2F:→ tratrason:近似於各政黨的政黨票了 因此歐巴馬53% 馬侃43%才對 11/04 19:14
3F:→ tratrason:那可是有8千萬樣本的超大型民調啊 就像台灣這次馬謝民調 11/04 19:15
4F:→ tratrason:最正確的數據應該是立委選舉的政黨票一樣 馬英九=國民黨 11/04 19:16
5F:→ tratrason:+新黨的政黨票=55%;謝長廷的則是民進黨+台聯黨+第三社會 11/04 19:17
6F:→ tratrason:黨的政黨票=41% 所以台(55%;41%) 美(53%;43%) 11/04 19:18
7F:→ pursuistmi:完全不可以這樣類比... 11/04 19:27
8F:推 zimt:最好兩年跟兩個月的間隔可以比較 11/04 19:33
9F:推 swallow73:恐怕您最好得查查1994年跟1996年各自的大選結果... 11/04 19:57
10F:推 creep1894:照一樓那種歪理 選舉只要選一次就夠了啊 科 11/04 22:54
11F:→ neutrino:一樓猛推這個拿台灣比美國的idea 不膩啊.... 11/04 23:18
12F:→ rayven:一樓你夠了沒 11/05 12:14