作者yyuweii (唯)
看板Eng-Class
標題[文法]高中文法
時間Mon Apr 26 20:33:43 2010
1. Choose the right sentence.
(A)Seating down, we began right away to talk about our lives.
(B)Finished my science report, I went to the movies with Jay.
(C)Feeling tired, my eyelids began to become heavy.
(D)Having been seperated for such a long time, we were surprised
we had so much to talk about.
A:(D)
請問這題的重點是不是考
若 前一句(先發生用have p.p.) 後一句(後發生用過去式)
前一句與後一句同時發生,都用過去式
那為什麼(A)要改成"seated down" 而不是having sat down?
(C)要改成 "When I felt tired" 而不是 having felt tired?
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 111.255.45.223
1F：→ double0077:be seated= sit. (use passive voice ) 04/26 20:58
2F：→ double0077:C 錯誤的地方 是因為兩個主詞不一樣 所以不能直接簡 04/26 20:59
3F：→ double0077:化成分詞 04/26 20:59
4F：推 smaface:(D)After we had been..., we were....After拿掉，前後主 04/26 21:25
5F：→ smaface:詞一樣拿掉，had改用動名詞having 04/26 21:26
6F：→ dunchee:".... 而不是having sat down?"-> 這也可以 兩者意思有差 04/26 22:40
8F：→ dunchee:(A)只是單純的"Seating"這寫法錯誤(seat和sit的用法差別) 04/26 22:41
9F：→ dunchee:(C) 這是考"dangling modifier" 你給的會變成--> 04/26 22:43
10F：→ dunchee:... 用"Having felt tired"的話，這的主詞是my eyelids 04/26 22:44
11F：→ dunchee:所以這會變成(My eyelids) ... felt tired (如果還是不懂 04/26 22:44
12F：→ dunchee:那麼改成/或是這樣子想 "我的眼睫毛覺得累" "我的兩根 04/26 22:45
13F：→ dunchee:頭髮覺得累" ... it doesn't make sense 04/26 22:45
14F：→ dunchee:你可以用Google找 dangling modifier 有很多相關的文法解 04/26 22:45
15F：→ dunchee:說 04/26 22:45
16F：→ dunchee: 我是故意用眼睫毛 以凸顯整體 04/26 22:47
17F：→ dunchee:意思的荒謬性 04/26 22:47
18F：→ dunchee:因為有這說法-> "My eyes feel tired" 而"eyelids"靠得太 04/26 22:48
19F：→ dunchee:近，我怕你會搞在一起，所以我故意用...毛/髮來打比方 04/26 22:49