作者timchen (Happy Days~)
看板AfterPhD
標題[討論]一個UW教授對中國CS領域的看法
時間Sun Jan 1 04:08:20 2012
JAMES LANDAY 在 MSRA 待了兩年半後，對中國環境及教育的一些看法
http://dubfuture.blogspot.com/2011/12/china-will-overtake-us-in.html
裡面最讓我震驚的是下面這段
One of the major differences I’ve noted between Chinese universities
(and in fact Chinese organizations in general) and American universities
is the power structure exposed in the academic hierarchy.
American universities are hierarchical in that Full Professors make decisions
about Associate and Assistant Professors, and Associate Professors in turn
also make decisions (e.g., tenure) about Assistant Professors. But, I’ve also
noticed that in the top departments I’ve been in that the more “senior”
faculty understand that a lot of the innovation and best work occurs in the
groups led by the “young” Assistant Professors and we in fact “protect”
them so as to allow them to better develop and get this great work accomplished
(e.g., we do not give them a lot of tedious committee work to do and we
encourage them to teach advanced courses in their specialized areas rather than
large, general undergraduate courses).
(在台灣，似乎是完全相反，雜事永遠都是新進教授在做…而經費/學生資源也都掌握在一
些資深的教授手上…真是令人難過…)
當然，我不覺得人類有這麼善良，不過在我對這段話提出疑問後，我的 mentor 和他的朋
友們 (美國大學的 CS 教授們) 倒是都不約而同的提到他們對新進教授們都很保護。也提
到在美國的研究型大學都是如此。
不知道大家遇到/聽到的狀況是否也都是如此呢？
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 118.168.203.87
1F：→ chenCT:應該是看學校和主事者 01/01 08:49
2F：→ chenCT:有聽說有些學校會讓資深教授組成一個教學組 教導年輕老師 01/01 08:50
3F：→ chenCT:怎樣分配教學跟研究時間, 以及如何有效率的完成申請的計畫 01/01 08:51
4F：→ chenCT:或是如何拿錢等等... 但當然也聽過跟極盡所能壓榨新進老師 01/01 08:51
5F：→ chenCT:的學程或研究單位 01/01 08:52
6F：→ lomaka:有啊... 但是已經十年以上沒拿過國科會計畫、沒有SCI論文的 01/01 12:34
7F：→ lomaka:資深教授指導完，你覺得有什麼幫助? 01/01 12:35
8F：→ lomaka:指導完,就是你寫一個計畫給他批改,然後他當主持人你當共同 01/01 12:36
9F：推 hkw:true for major universities.. this is why they become 01/01 14:11
10F：→ hkw:better and better.. 01/01 14:12
11F：推 pttptt2009:lomaka真是一針見血，道破大老橫走學術、小咖只能靠邊 01/01 23:45
12F：→ pttptt2009:站的現象。 01/01 23:45
13F：→ firekylin:It's true, at least, in my university. 01/02 10:24
14F：推 ggg12345:洋人親疏較淡薄也看重天才,愛惜天才.能容天才溢格而出! 01/02 11:40
15F：→ ggg12345:天才常會有內在無法消除的驅動力,相對就缺常人都有的私心 01/02 11:45
16F：→ ggg12345:所以Apple Jobs很確定亞洲各國無法逕自超越他設計的產品 01/02 11:51