作者lovedenmark (迈向专业口笔译员)
看板translator
标题《Re: 鼓鼓掌，首届的翻译比赛》 （内有批判性话题，请勿笔战）
时间Mon May 5 23:17:03 2008
: : 个人觉得这次比赛真正让版上变成一个讨论翻译的园地，加油了版主。
: : 虽然工作繁忙，还是要花心思在经营这块园地。
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
其实我说这段话，是期许蛋头版主主办，但是看了他的推文感觉
感觉『不期不待』。
～～～～～～～～～～～～～～～
来发泄一下，最近写稿的压力，讲一下对版上的意见跟想法。
乡民lovedenmark斗胆进言：
版上的文章几乎有1/2都是徵求翻译的case，并不是说不好。
只是有点失去原本，讨论翻译的初衷。
虽然版大不是翻译学院出身，但是还是有丰富的经验，应该三不五时丢个话题
大家出来讨论。而不是，连办一个翻译比赛都牵拖来牵脱去，（办个比赛有这麽严重吗
就小弟看来，版大好像都只出没在推文海当中。
乡民誓死进言：
版大有时候在推文会出现情绪化的用词，或是发言不当（个人认为)，虽然
人人都有犯错的权力，但是有时版大的推托之词也过於官话，出了社会说话技巧
还是要修饰修饰。
乡民再度情绪化进言：
什麽叫『我不看中文』，我非常不认同版主这一句话。
不看中文，你还上BBS做啥？？
身为一位翻译版的版主，而且也是从事笔译多年的版主，居然说出这种话来。
翻译，必须要精通你的target and source language.
就算你的英文可以称为母语级，那你是不是该要努力加强你的中文。
（从你的经验来看，你应该是从事英-中双向翻译）。
怎麽会出现这种的想法ꄊ我每天都在写英文的文章，看英文的资料，用英文采访。
但是我还是很努力的练习中文，就是希望做到两个语言的精通。
----------------------------------------------------------------
虽然最後发言，有点情绪，但是希望版大能够听进去，苍天甚幸、PTT甚幸阿
--------------------------------------------------------------------
最後..这几天我出差..所以..ㄝㄝ也不用笔战拉..版大觉得不妥直接删了吧
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 218.167.87.110
1F：推 upyours2:"source" language 05/05 23:20
※ 编辑: lovedenmark 来自: 61.230.87.159 (05/05 23:32)
2F：→ egghead:i meant i'm not seeing quality chinese articles on 05/06 02:04
3F：→ egghead:any reasonable basis... therefore I'd ask someone to 05/06 02:05
4F：→ egghead:suggest me source text for competition purpose. 05/06 02:06
5F：→ egghead:my day work is writing reports in Chinese, but I'm not 05/06 02:07
6F：→ egghead:seeing them as most finance info are from abroad. 05/06 02:08
7F：→ egghead:and I've never done E-> C in 4years, I'd leave it to 05/06 02:09
8F：→ egghead:some other with better Chinese composition skills 05/06 02:09
9F：→ egghead:about trowing out topics... On translation I only do 05/06 02:10
10F：→ egghead:an extremely narrow field for the sake of competency 05/06 02:11
11F：→ egghead:and I personally haven't meet much doubts for a long 05/06 02:12
12F：→ egghead:time. 05/06 02:14
13F：→ egghead:Since I'm very concentrated, I won't see much new 05/06 02:16
14F：→ egghead:stuff during performing translation, and I won't 05/06 02:17
15F：→ egghead:produce topics just for the sake of doing so. 05/06 02:17
16F：→ egghead:As for "over formal response" I meant every word I've 05/06 02:19
17F：→ egghead:said. Don't take it as formal language. 05/06 02:20
18F：→ egghead:As for a contest, remember TheRock set a high bar for 05/06 02:21
19F：→ egghead:everyone else, and as a BM if I am holding a contest 05/06 02:22
20F：→ egghead:as BM, there are many extra things to consider than 05/06 02:22
21F：→ egghead:having one in the name as an individual organizer. 05/06 02:23
22F：→ egghead:And, in my opinion, though I like the idea of contest 05/06 02:23
23F：→ egghead:and will have one eventually, it is good if occasional 05/06 02:25
24F：→ egghead:but this is not the main business of this board. 05/06 02:27
25F：推 swissotel:与其推文这麽长, 何不回文? 看到一堆躺在那, 就不想看了 05/08 00:06