作者flymyfinger (键盘时事评论员)
看板movie
标题Re: [讨论] 台湾演员都演不好「酒醉」?
时间Fri Aug 8 02:26:55 2025
※ 引述《generalfungi (香菇将军)》之铭言:
: 喝醉酒的戏码是不是最能看出演技的地方?
: 台湾演员真的很容易在这个地方上穿帮
: 大部分都只呈现走路不稳、说话含糊、神智不清的样子,只演外在的表面而已,很像很用力的要告诉观众我醉薰薰的哦,都没有什麽层次感
: 即便谢盈萱吴慷仁这类的我也觉得很假
: 演员有没有料,请他演喝醉的戏就知道
: 丹佐华盛顿在机密真相里喝醉酒的样子至今让我念念不忘
: 宋康昊在韩国电影里也常常喝酒也演得非常好
: 国内演员是不是每次只要演喝醉酒的戏就破绽百出,非常不自然?
: 宋康昊
: -----
: Sent from JPTT on my Google Pixel 6a.
我看过michael caine的一个访谈
觉得满有意思的 跟大家分享一下
“The modern film actor knows that real people in real life struggle NOT to
show their feelings. It is more truthful, and more potent, to fight against
the tears, only yielding after all those defense mechanisms are exhausted.”
Caine goes on to explain further:
“The same is true of drunkenness. In real life, a drunk makes a huge effort
to appear sober. A coarsely acted stage or film drunk reels all over the
place to show you he’s drunk. It’s artificial. And eventually, that kind
of acting puts up a barrier between the actor and the audience, so that nothing
the character says or does will be believed.”
It’s a lesson Michael Caine learned the hard way, as a young actor.
He described the experience in an interview with the BBC:
“I was supposed to be a drunk, when I was a young actor. And I came in drunk.
And the producer stopped it and said, ‘What are you doing?’”
“I said, ‘I’m drunk, sir. I’m drunk, in this scene.'”
“He [the producer] said, ‘I know you’re drunk in the scene, but you’re not
a drunk. You’re an actor trying to be drunk.’”
“I said, ‘I don’t understand what you mean.’”
“He said, ‘Well, you’re an actor who’s trying to walk crooked and talk
slurred. A drunk is a man trying to walk straight and talk properly. Go out
and do it again!’”
“That is a wonderful basis for movie acting,” Caine concluded.
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc), 来自: 36.231.93.121 (台湾)
※ 文章网址: https://webptt.com/cn.aspx?n=bbs/movie/M.1754591217.A.19C.html
1F:推 eylrock : 推 08/08 03:14
2F:推 eylrock : 所以演醉汉应该都会喝点酒吧?没有酒精怎麽入戏? 08/08 03:17
3F:推 shirman : 制片人就不要他真的喝酒啊 08/08 08:13
4F:→ shirman : 他的意思就是演技从心法做起,能够从精神上说服自己 08/08 08:16
5F:→ shirman : 才叫专业,若是酒精药物能被允许,片场就一堆瘾君子 08/08 08:16
6F:→ shirman : 了。 08/08 08:16
7F:→ shirman : 「这种状态我不嗑药演不出来」这种事片场是不允许的 08/08 08:16
8F:推 n61208 : 有人没酒醉过怎麽办 08/08 10:22
9F:→ sunnyyoung : 没酒醉过也可以看酒醉的人 08/08 10:36
10F:推 fragmentwing: 所以意思是不要假装酒醉 要假装自己假装没有酒醉的 08/08 16:39
11F:→ fragmentwing: 意思吗? 08/08 16:39
12F:推 micbrimac : 照某些人的说法,没作奸犯科过,不就不能演戏... 08/08 16:57
13F:→ peterw : 这某些人的说法,演强暴戏就一定要来真的 08/08 17:06
14F:→ skywu1026 : 演醉汉我觉得志村健演得最好! 08/08 22:03
15F:推 lsjean : 拍戏常常要换角度再演多次,真的喝醉很难连戏还容 08/10 09:51
16F:→ lsjean : 易增加善後成本 08/10 09:51