作者frankshyu (Frank)
看板WomenTalk
标题Re: [新闻] 艾玛华森自打脸!3年前攻击碧昂丝被起底
时间Wed Mar 8 10:37:13 2017
稍早Watson自己的Twitter上PO的当年访问的原文
https://twitter.com/EmmaWatson?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw
Watson 说"My words are in bold" -> "粗体字是我说的部分"
图片的连结可以看这里
http://i.imgur.com/Els2d3s.jpg
小弟英文破烂,尝试翻译一点粗体字的原文,有许多翻不好的地方还请指教。
"I'm quite nervous to bring it up because I still haven't really for-
mulated my own ideas about it"
接下来的议题我其实也不太敢提出来,因为
我自己还没想清楚这个议题
"Beyonce's new album. I don't know if you have spoken to anyone about
it, but my friend and I sat and we watch all the videos back-to-back
and I was really conflicted."
我不知道你有没有和别人聊过碧昂丝的新专辑。我和我朋友坐下来把其中每部影
片(应该是指MV)看完了,看完後我感到非常矛盾
"So I admire her confidence to put her music out in that way, in amidst
all these very sensationalist MTV performances, I was so psyched about
it. On the one hand she is putting herself in a category of feminist,
this very strong woman - and she has beautiful speech by Chimamanda Ngozi
Adichie in one of her songs - but then in the camera, it felt very male,
such a male voyeuristic experience of her and I just wondered if you had
thoughts about that?"
我觉得她出了这样一张专辑实在是勇气可嘉,里面有好些颠覆性的MV镜头,让我
思考了很久。一方面她以女性主义者自居,她是一个强而有力的女性,而且在MV
中还有一段Adichie的精彩演讲(Adichie为美国的非裔知名作家)。但另一方面,
在镜头底下的她看起来却是为了男人而活(very male,不知道怎麽翻妥当),因为
她展现了这麽多露骨的镜头。你有甚麽想法吗?
=================(记者讲了一些自己的想法)===============
"I would say two things. One is that in her position, and for a lot of
young musicians, actors or people in our industry, it's as though you
get a memo: don't be seen with your boyfriend or your wife or your child
because you still want your audience to believe or male fans of Beyonce
to believe that the could still possess her; that in some alternative
universe the could be with her."
我的感想有二。首先,碧昂丝的身分让她和其他许多音乐人、演员都必须接受一个
潜规则: 不要让人发现你有男朋友/老婆/小孩。因为我们(演艺人员)会希望让观众
相信自己可以拥有我们,或是在某个平行宇宙中可以和我们在一起。以碧昂丝的例
子来说,就是她的男性粉丝。
"So by publically exposing her marriage, that she is in a committed rela-
tionship, that she has a child, is probably really against that kind of
memo and she does make clear that she is performing for him. And the fact
she wasn't doing it for a label, she was doing it for herself and the con-
trol she has directing it and putting it out there, I agree is making her
sexuality empowering because it is her choice."
而在她的MV中她公开了她的婚姻、小孩,这是对於潜规则的巨大的反抗。另外她也
明确让观众知道她是为了她老公而表演,但她不是为了某个标签而表演,而是为了
她自己。此外,她对於MV中的表演有充分的主导权,这再次强调了她的性别权利(
sexuality,不知道怎麽翻比较好),因为这完全是她自由意志的展现。
"The second is that I would say you get a sense of,"I can be a feminist,
I can be an intellectual, I can be all these other things, but I can also
be okay with my femininity and being pretty and with all these things that
I thought might negate my message or negate what I am about". That really
is the most interesting thing about the album. It is so inclusive and puts
feminism and female empowerment on such a broad spectrum."
除此之外,我认为在MV中你可以感受到一个讯息:「我可以是女性主义者,我可以是
一个有知识的人,我可以身兼多种身分,但我也同时认可我的女性身分并且用我认为
可以表现自己、表达自己的方式让我自己漂漂亮亮的。」我认为这是这张专辑最引人
入胜的一点。这个讯息的包容性很强,它把「女性主义」带到了一个更开阔的境界。
看来应该是断章取义想攻击Watson,如果翻译有不妥的地方还请指教。
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc), 来自: 140.122.151.189
※ 文章网址: https://webptt.com/cn.aspx?n=bbs/WomenTalk/M.1488940637.A.1EB.html
1F:推 varda0821: 推翻译 03/08 10:39
2F:推 susuqi: 感谢翻译 所以 原原po 所说的妖魔化在? 03/08 10:44
3F:→ ShiningRuby: 这件事情跟华尔街日报说Youtuber首富PewDiePie是新纳 03/08 10:46
4F:→ ShiningRuby: 粹一样,都是断章取义制造假象. 03/08 10:47
5F:推 DenTisGirl: 推翻译!艾玛勇於发问! 03/08 10:47
6F:推 iamcnc: 现在艾玛懂了 03/08 10:58
7F:推 sue180563: 感谢翻译! 03/08 11:02
8F:推 honeysugar: 推,断章取义ㄎㄨㄚˉㄓ 03/08 11:03
9F:推 uini: 推。断章取义的不可取 03/08 11:04
10F:推 thenorth: 断章取意不可取 03/08 11:11
11F:推 chihchuan: 推。 03/08 11:15
12F:推 thebirds: 断章取义不可取 03/08 11:16
13F:推 NavyWind: 自由的选择餐点! 03/08 11:36
14F:推 deutyi: 但是她的说法还是把"漂亮的装扮"和女性主义划分开并视作 03/08 11:56
15F:→ deutyi: 冲突,这才是引起争议的地方?你没有把争议段(negate my t 03/08 11:56
16F:→ deutyi: hought)翻出来? 03/08 11:56
17F:推 yoida2: 推推 03/08 11:57
18F:推 deutyi: "它把女性主义带到一个更宽广的境界"这里我也觉得和原文意 03/08 12:05
19F:→ deutyi: 思有出入,因为明明就是"那张专辑把其它三样东西带到更宽 03/08 12:05
20F:→ deutyi: 广的境界。" 03/08 12:05
21F:→ deutyi: 她这段访谈的争议,就是把装扮漂亮性感女性力和女性主义 03/08 12:05
22F:→ deutyi: 区分开来,才让人误会 03/08 12:05
23F:→ saylove33: 肯定别人的作法与保持着自己的想法是并存的. 03/08 12:06
24F:→ deutyi: 是觉得国外对feminist也是定义未清吧? 03/08 12:07
25F:→ saylove33: 即使後段说了对碧昂丝的感想,但不能否认的是她个人的 03/08 12:07
26F:→ saylove33: 主观上的对女性主义的认知. 03/08 12:08
27F:→ saylove33: 否则她在聊这个话题时根本不需要先去讲人家镜头下如何 03/08 12:09
28F:→ saylove33: 这个对谈在当时就引发热议了,只是现在又被炒出来而已 03/08 12:10
29F:推 deutyi: 如楼上大大所说,正是如此才有争议和冲突?他们还在 argue 03/08 12:11
30F:→ deutyi: 一个定义不明的主义,大概是这样吧? 03/08 12:11
31F:推 jdarch: 推 03/08 12:28
32F:推 ooooooxxxxxx: 看到打脸文94爽 03/08 12:57
33F:→ kuromu: I can also be okay with all these things that I though 03/08 13:04
34F:→ kuromu: t might negate my message 03/08 13:04
35F:→ whitehow: 推 03/08 14:53
36F:推 psycheee: 推 03/08 15:04
37F:推 gj6sm3: 推 03/08 17:10
38F:推 t1478963: 推 03/08 17:51
39F:推 phoebe9256: 推 03/08 18:50
40F:推 geniusturtle: fine 03/08 22:23