看板PhD
标 题Re: [台大研协]三"乌"斗法~全国研究生助学金大呛声
发信站批踢踢参 (Fri Dec 9 21:18:33 2005)
转信站ptt!Group.NCTU!grouppost!Group.NCTU!ptt3
※ 引述《[email protected] (zzzzboy)》之铭言:
: : Since protest became a culture in the country last century, there have been
: : too many protests every day, which ask for more and more and paying less and
: : less, until eventually they all get everything form nothing.
: : Think about it.
: 总之
: 以前研究生的状况比现在好太多了
: 现在就是一堆不想研究的人在当研究生
: 只因为硕士毕业是基本学历
: 既然是基本学历
No degree should be treated as a 'foundation' certificate.
You only go to take it as you are very clearly know you need it.
Certainly, you need to pay for it, as it is your degree.
: 国家也不想把他们当人才吧
In most of the fully developed country with well-established education system,
Master-degree students are more like advanced undergraduates.
Of course, there are still many good master students who can do very good
research. (Some of them will go for a PhD later.)
However, the requirements of master degree don't include 'showing
evidences of ability to conduct an independent research'.
: 不仅没钱 也不想花钱
You probably can get sponsorship from somebody;
It is clear that, research sponsorship is not a sort of charity.
They cannot just go to ask free money just because someone had that before.
Another thinking, which might be interesting.
I guess, the ratio between Master degree students and PhD degree stuents in
Taiwan might be higher than 6. Assuming this is correct, If the government
is going to give every Master degree student NTD6000/month, they can use the
same money to give NTD36000 to every PhD student. This is quite a reasonable
sponsorship, comparing to the other countrys' systems.
Comparing to spending and training cost for a two-year Master student,
it would be much more economic for training a five-year PhD student.
Moreover, the research work is usually more reliable and useful.
It might be argued that that could be unfair for master students.
However, if somebody argues for this, I would just answer:
'if you think PhD is good, and good payment, why don't you go to get it?'
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢参(ptt3.cc)
◆ From: 82.22.90.37
1F:推 switcherBPC:最後一段真是说得好 12/10 05:48