作者SetsunaLeo (卡勒)
看板Eng-Class
标题Re: [文法] 请问一个句子的文法
时间Sun Nov 4 08:41:14 2012
※ 引述《tbscsh (小蜗牛)》之铭言:
: 我最近在读文法书 但是书中的一个句子看不懂
: 书中讨论到分词构句时 举了下例
: ------------------------------------------
: My father, a pipe in his mouth, is in deep thought.
: { a pipe (being) in his mouth }
: = My father, with a pipe in his mouth, is deep in thought.
: ------------------------------------------
: 我完全看不懂作者的意思 >_<
: 第一句my father, a pipe in...
: fatherc和pipe不能当同位语 为什麽可以这样写啊
: 又..... 第一句如何变成第三句的 为什麽会多一个with
: 请帮忙解惑 感激不尽
先姑且不论现在式在这样的句子中不太成立(用过去式更好)。
My father, who has a pipe in his mouth, is in deep thought.
^^^^^^^常常可以做with(介系词:拥有、带有)解
所以"with"本是从这样的句子变来的。
至於原句my father和a pipe in his mouth,是从两个子句结合而来的。
My father is in deep thought.
A pipe is in his mouth.
可以先看成是这样:
My father─a pipe is in his mouth─is in deep thought.
想用双破折号(等同括号)补充说明此时爸爸嘴里叼根烟斗,
"My father is in deep thought"是主要句子。
双破折号中的子句是独立於"My father..."主句之外的,所以可以完整呈现,
但如果我们想把破折号去掉,改为逗号,就会变成:
My father, a pipe
is in his mouth,
is in deep thought.
根据英文句法,一个基本句子不能有两个动词(两个is),
至少得把两个逗号中的句子改为「独立分词构句」:
My father, a pipe being in his mouth, is in deep thought.
而由於be动词的性质(基本上只有语法功能,没有实质意义),
常常可以省略,所以简化成:
My father, a pipe in his mouth, is in deep thought.
这样稍微了解了吗?
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 1.162.16.136
1F:→ BLUEMILTON:感觉这边写成with a pipe in his mouth也可以~~ 11/04 08:45
2F:→ SetsunaLeo:可以啊,第三行有写到 11/04 09:16
3F:→ BLUEMILTON:歹势~刚刚看太快没看到第三行XD 11/04 10:24