作者tijj (my two cents)
看板Eng-Class
标题Re: [文法] whose的用法
时间Mon Oct 22 09:58:36 2012
※ 引述《l10nel (小失)》之铭言:
: 本文旨在总结以下这考题所引起的多种看法。虽非最近的话题,但觉得当时的讨论没结果
: ,悬在那里,故在此整理,以资参考。
: 问题句:They were the Boy Scouts whose job it is to help elderly people cross
: the street.
: 1. it 什麽作用?可不可省?
: :作者: tijj (my two cents) 看板: Eng-Class 标题: Re: [文法] whose的用法
: :时间: Fri Jan 20 10:42:10 2012
: :这里的it可以省略, 是否为非限定或限定,并不是差在有无it (或有无comma).
※ 引述《l10nel (小失)》之铭言:
: 这里的 it 不可省略,虽然 it 有无和关系子句限定/非限定无关。後有详述。
: (1) The Boy Scouts' job is to help elderly people cross the street.
: 意义:童子军的工作即是/主要是扶老人过马路。
: (隐含:A's job is B 这句型,通常意味着是 B 是唯一工作,若非唯一,至少也是主要
: 工作。)
: => 因此,这句的表达方式不通,因为我们知道,童子军的工作显然不只是扶人过马路,
: 其主要工作也不是这个。
: 结论:(1)因带有「唯一工作」暗示,不通。其他的(2)和(3)皆可。
:
: 结论:
: They were the Boy Scouts whose job it is to help elderly people cross the
: street.
: (1)此句 it 不可省。it 的有无决定有没有「唯一工作」隐义。
嗯.
听听教授怎麽说.
主旨: "it" canNOT be omitted ?
去信:
Professor Mao,
I have some questions about linguistics.
(1) They were the Boy Scouts, whose job it is to help elderly people cross
the street.
(2) I want a President, whose job is to keep the machine of State in fine
whack.
"it" cannot be omitted; otherwise, native speakers would think that Boy
Scouts' ONLY or MAIN job is to help elderly people cross the street.
回信:
I don't think that in any of these cases a native speaker would think that
the point is that the subject's main or only job is the task indicated. I
suppose the "it" could clarify a bit in some cases. But it's not necessary.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Douglas
Department of English
Johns Hopkins University
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 210.69.13.1