1.年级:高二上
2.科目:英文
3.章节:远东第一课
4.题目:Jane, who had been interested in astrology since entering college,
asked Christine to find out when her classmates were born.
5.想法:
昨天看到学生课本上学校老师把since entering代换成since she entered
但是这样不就无法表现enter college这个动作发生在ask Christine之前?
是不是应该改为since she had entered呢?
但如此一来 since 前後的句子都变成过去完成式...感觉怪怪的
麻烦各位指点一下 谢谢~
※ 编辑: dolphan 来自: 114.36.97.17 (08/11 13:22)
1F:推 DarkD:怎觉得是要改had been-->has been.. 08/11 13:26
2F:→ DarkD:然後..关代who子句不一定得跟主句有时序关系 08/11 13:27
3F:→ dolphan:感谢D大回答 但这篇文章通篇都用过去式 应该不能has been 08/11 13:31
4F:→ dolphan:我也在想是否应忽略关代子句跟主句的时序 但是不知何时 08/11 13:33
5F:→ dolphan:该忽略何时不该忽略... 08/11 13:33
6F:→ hopeliu:他上次改一篇作文,改到时态也是错很多. 08/11 14:05
7F:→ dunchee:"since she had entered ..." 也可以。 08/11 23:59
8F:→ dunchee:"是否应忽略..."->倒不是忽不忽略的问题,因为本来就没 08/11 23:59
9F:→ dunchee:有忽略。换个角度来看...-> 08/12 00:00
11F:→ dolphan:非常感谢楼上d大详尽的解说!我也有到国外的论坛发问 08/12 01:15
12F:→ dolphan:有个英国人认为since she had entered 听来不自然且没必要 08/12 01:16
13F:→ dolphan:但另外一个英国人觉得两个都正确且听起来也都OK 08/12 01:16
14F:→ dolphan:也提供您参考~ 08/12 01:17
15F:推 DarkD:拍谢,had ved since had ved的用法我不太熟悉,误导到了, 08/14 03:57
16F:→ DarkD:不过我私信问dunchee,他意思是我的说法也是没错的,只是这 08/14 03:58
17F:→ DarkD:不需要改成我说的 08/14 03:59