作者tijj (my two cents)
看板Eng-Class
标题Re: [文法] 文意考题
时间Thu Jul 19 10:18:36 2012
※ 引述《hopeliu (阿翔)》之铭言:
: I did not say Paul lied.
: a) I said Paul lied.
: b) I said nothing.
: c) I said Paul told the truth.
: 请问这题答案为何是 c ?
: 要怎判断? 感谢大家
→ anne4u:题目是我没说他说谎 07/19 02:05
→ anne4u:A. 我说他说谎 07/19 02:06
→ anne4u:B. 我什麽都没说 07/19 02:07
→ anne4u:C. 我说他说的是实话,所以 AB 是错的 07/19 02:08
c没比b好.
A Semantic Approach to English Grammar
by Robert M. W. Dixon (Oxford University Press, 2005)
p 435
The preferred position for the negator not is after the Wrst word of the
auxiliary or after a copula, in a main clause. Under various circumstances,
a negator that should properly be placed elsewhere is attracted into this
position.
Firstly, note that what is here called sentential negation can apply either
to a main clause, as in (79), or to a complement clause, as in (80).
(79) I didn't say [that he lied] (I said nothing)
(80) I said [that he didn’t lie] (I said that he told the truth)
还有, "→ anne4u:B. 我什麽都没说" , 这如果是 "I said nothing" 的翻译
可能也不太对.
1F:→ anne4u:其实我觉得这个考题有问题, 看原po标题是文意考题, 勉强选c 07/19 10:36
2F:→ anne4u:不好意思, 我中文不好, 如果B翻成"我没说什麽" 比较好吗? 07/19 10:36
3F:→ anne4u:如果是逻辑考题, 我觉得三个答案都不对 07/19 10:37
4F:→ tijj:既然题目是文意考题, 就用Semantic角度来解并无不妥. 07/19 10:38
5F:→ tijj:如dunchee所说, 语言不能无线上纲. 07/19 10:38
6F:→ tijj:还有请拿出权威着作加以辅助. 07/19 10:39
7F:→ priv:没错,以逻辑来说三个答案都不对 07/19 10:45
8F:→ priv:但是以实际情形考量b还是比较接近一点 07/19 10:45
9F:→ priv:如果他有提过或暗示过 Paul 说的是真话 07/19 10:46
10F:→ priv:那後面再出现 I did not say Paul lied. 就会不连贯 07/19 10:47
11F:→ anne4u:不好意思,半夜2:00多超过睡觉时间很久被丢水球问的, 只能 07/19 11:07
12F:→ anne4u:先用手机简短回答一下 07/19 11:08
13F:→ anne4u:而且那个时间一直丢水球问,大太恰当吧 07/19 11:17
14F:→ anne4u:不太恰当吧 07/19 12:05
15F:→ heike:那真的不妥,即使对方在线上也没有义务回答问题 07/19 12:35
16F:→ tijj:我想很多高手都常被丢水球,但被丢水球不代表一定要回. 07/19 12:44
17F:→ tijj:习惯就好,单单就回答问题即可,无需在推文部份写这些. 07/19 12:44
18F:推 iSee:同意t大的见解 这题只能勉强选b 07/19 17:48
※ 编辑: tijj 来自: 146.115.61.107 (07/22 22:16)