作者tijj (my two cents)
看板Eng-Class
标题Re: [文法] 有人看过这一条文法规则吗?
时间Thu Jul 12 15:45:42 2012
(1) The woman living next door is on holiday.
(2) The woman who lives next door is on holiday.
(The woman is on holiday. The woman lives next door. )
但是,The woman lives next door 有下列两种可能:
(2a) The woman lives next door [but the woman is NOT living next door].
(2a')The woman lives next door [and the woman is living next door].
我也认为网站所要主张的是(2)的意思,也就是The woman lives next door 是指(2a),
因为人去渡假了,所以现在、此刻不在隔壁,虽然他住隔壁.
所以,
(2)-> (2a) The woman lives next door [but the woman is NOT living next door].
这时,检视暂时性或边界(boundary)是存在的."先" 检视是否具有暂时性"应该"是必要的.
-> (2b) The woman who is NOT living next door is on holiday.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
(2)因此不能简化为(1).
若The woman lives next door 是指(2a'),
(2)-> (2a') The woman lives next door [and the woman is living next door].
这时,检视暂时性或边界(boundary)也是存在的,其为"the woman is living next door".
-> (2b') The woman who is living next door is on holiday.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^
-> (1) The woman living next door is on holiday.
(2)就可以简化为(1). 那英语母语网页应该是在举(2a)的意思.
(我没有中文语法书) 关於句法推论,可以参考Kuno教授所写得 Functional Syntax.
※ 引述《tucson (tucson)》之铭言:
: http://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/fr/grammar-reference/participle-clauses
: Notice that the participle clauses with the present participle have a
: continuous meaning. If we replaced them with a relative clause it would
: be in a continuous tense.
※ 编辑: tijj 来自: 146.115.61.107 (07/14 01:40)