作者tijj (my two cents)
看板Eng-Class
标题Re: [文法] 有人看过这一条文法规则吗?
时间Tue Jul 10 19:23:48 2012
※ 引述《Widder8 (维德八)》之铭言:
: 我不知道有没有中文书提到这规则。
: 但我对这规则很有兴趣,因为十分罕见,
: 当然要不要相信这规则的存在是个人的选择:)
: 我去翻了一下Quirk et al.那本
: <<A Comprehensive Grammar of the English Language>>,
: 在第17章28节(17.28)提道、兹节录如下:
: │will write │
: │will be writing │
: The person who│writes │reports is my colleague. [1]
: │is writing │
: │wrote │
: │was writing │
: The person writing reports is my colleague. [1a]
: The nonfinite clause writing reports in [1a] may be interpreted, according to
: the context, as equivalent to one of the more explicit versions in [1]. ...
: .
: .
: .
: It must be emphasized that -ing forms in postmodifying clauses should not
: be seen as abbreviated progressive forms in relative clauses. Stative verbs,
: for instance, which cannot have the progresssive in the finite verb phrase,
: can appear in participial form(...):
: This is a liquid with a tase resembling that of soapy water.
: ['which resembles'; not:'*which is resembling'] [2]
: It was a mixture consisting of oil and vinegar.
: ['that consited of'; not:'*that was consisting of'] [3]
: .
: .
: .
: 按照该网站的规则,似乎[1]里面第3句就不该存在了,
并不冲突.
: 更遑论其他未来式、过去式,似乎是都不符合规则。
因为这里的write属於action verb, 所以Quirk的 [1a] 可等价 [1].
而resemble 属於stative verb, 还原成关系子句应该是简单式而非进行式.
live的性质,事实上介於stative verb与action verb之间.
所以类似直接还原为 "who writes"或 "which resembles" 会是有问题的.
→ Widder8:可是一端的action verb "write"可以,另一端的stative 07/10 18:01
→ Widder8:verb "consist"、"exist"可以,位於中间的"live"却不行, 07/10 18:01
→ Widder8:不是有点怪怪的吗 @@? 07/10 18:01
语言不要用数学去想. 因为权威语法家R.A.Close 告诉我们:
"An -ing can replace a stative verb as well as an action verb;"
这是语法家的归类. 当然有时stative verb 与 action verb的分野并非绝对.
但这是另外议题, 就不在此讨论.
还有,比如live/study/work这三组属性是相近的.不能随便抓一个动词就可以类比live.
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 210.69.13.1
1F:→ Widder8:那麽这个句子还原成who lives问题在哪? 07/10 20:58
在於who lives 与 who is living 不一样
2F:→ Widder8:其实应该说,简化成living会有什麽问题? 07/10 21:00
语意不精准
※ 编辑: tijj 来自: 146.115.61.107 (07/11 00:16)