作者dunkjames (Firefighter)
看板Eng-Class
标题Re: [文法] 关系子句-补述用法
时间Thu Jul 5 01:57:39 2012
※ 引述《appletv (onionlover)》之铭言:
: 刚刚在读剑桥英文文法
: 请用补述用法合成句子
: 1. There were a lot of people at the party. (I had met only a few of these
: people before )
: 我的答案是
: there were a lot of people, a few of whom i had met before, at the party.
: 正确答案是
: there were a lot of people at the party, a few of whom i had met before.
补述顾名思义就是补充叙述 所叙述的内容对整句的"文法结构"来说
既使去掉 也不会造成影响或错误
通常只会用"一个"逗号来连接对应的补述句
格式如下 S+V,补语
[通常很容易跟复杂句混淆 格式如右 S+V, 连接词+S+V ]
第一题你用了两个逗号 所以步行 只能把後面at the party往前挪
使用捕述用法检查法:去掉补述句会变成
there were a lot of people, at the party. 造成多一个逗号[赘词]
如果用两个逗号会容易让人误会成同位语
EX: A man, standing over there, is my father.
依照正确答案去掉捕述句的话
there were a lot of people at the party. 文法格式正确 故是正解
: 2. the people applied for the job (none of these people were suitable )
: 我的答案
: the people, none of whom were suitable, applied for the job.
: 正确答案
: the people applied for the job, none of whom were suitable
: 请问我的答案哪里错了 不可以吗?? 非常感谢!!
因为你有两个逗号 会让人误会成同位语
the people=none of whom were suitable , applied for the job.
检查去掉捕述句 会不会造成文法错误呢?
会!因为 the people, applied for the job. 是错误的 句子中间多余逗号
正确应该是 the people applied for the job. 才不会有文法上的问题
3. The people, none of whom were suitable, applied for the job.
4. The people applied for the job, none of whom were suitable.
以上两句中文都一样 文法也都没错 差只差在书写法 (或说文法不同)
3.是以同位语的方式书写
4.是使用捕述用法
两者都对 但是如果限定要使用捕述 则只能写4.
如果题目说 限定使用同位语方式改写 正确就是3罗
个人浅见
有错请指教
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 42.75.235.97
※ 编辑: dunkjames 来自: 42.75.235.97 (07/05 02:00)
1F:推 DarkD:=?=同位语本来就是补述的一种不是吗..。然後插入补述位置的 07/05 07:18
2F:→ DarkD:不同非是文法考量,而该是为了诸如当句子复杂不会让其修饰到 07/05 07:20
3F:→ DarkD:其他受修饰字而产生歧义/或避免同种脚轻之类的问题。至於不 07/05 07:23
4F:→ DarkD:会产生歧意或理解困难的句子则没讲究位置,差别可能是写作风 07/05 07:25
5F:→ DarkD:格或者是读/念起来感觉不同 07/05 07:25
6F:→ dunkjames:谢谢 那能解释原po的问题吗 07/05 20:42
7F:推 DarkD:有回文提供我的看法 07/06 11:33