作者tucson (tucson)
看板Eng-Class
标题Re: [文法] should作"竟然"时後面可否用完成式?
时间Mon Jul 2 22:10:10 2012
统合一下大家所提供的资料与意见并加上个人的点点看法
我把should当竟然的用法整理如下:
http://www.wretch.cc/blog/alclctw/33025064
因为有表格所以无法贴图 请点选上面进去看整理的表格
should当"竟然" 该注意的事项
1. 使用should + V 与使用should + have + Vpp 其中最主要的差距应该是在後者强调的是时间发生的前後距离长短, 使用前者离发生的时间较短,是不久前才刚发生过,但若使用後者则发生的时间是较久之前的事,.
若非一定要很强调发生时间的长短,建议使用should + V 既可,这种句型也较常见。
2. 否定句时可在should 後加上not
I was shocked that she shouldn't have invited Phyllis.
I was shocked that she shouldn't invite Phyllis.
= I was shocked she didn't invite Phyllis.
3. 主要子句的主词可以是人或it : 人+be + adj/Vpp 与 It + be + adj/Ving 的转换
I was surprised that he should feel lonely when he was in California.
= I was surprised that he should have felt lonely when he was in California.
= It was surprising that he should feel lonely when he was in California.
= It was surprising that that he should have felt lonely when he was in California.
4.
4-1. should 的翻译不只是: 竟然 还可是翻成 居然/ 竟然会 /居然会 /会
4-2. should的此种用法在美式英语中较常用would而英式英语较常使用should
(美式) It was natural that they would want him to go to a good school.
(英式) It was natural that they should want him to go to a good school.
他们会想要他上好学校是很自然的事。
这句中的should/would 不应该翻成竟然或居然。
※ 引述《lulu1993 (雨枫)》之铭言:
: 在书上看到一个句子
: "她竟然用那种方式跟你说话,真令人吃惊。听起来好像她才是你的老板。"
: 书中附的翻译是:
: "It was astonishing that she should speak to you in that manner.
: She sounded as if she were your boss."
: 我觉得有点怪怪的,既然是过去发生的事情,那应该要说
: "It was astonishing that she should have spoken to you in that manner."
: 才对吧???是因为这里不能用完成式吗?还是我误解了什麽呢??
: 希望有对文法较了解的人能为我解惑> <
: 感恩!!!
--
嘉义免费Toeic试听
http://www.wretch.cc/blog/alclctw
免费Toeic视讯
https://www.youtube.com/user/allinternet#grid/uploads
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 219.85.141.152