作者tijj (my two cents)
看板Eng-Class
标题Re: [文法] should作"竟然"时後面可否用完成式?
时间Mon Jul 2 09:46:38 2012
※ 引述《lulu1993 (雨枫)》之铭言:
: 在书上看到一个句子
: "她竟然用那种方式跟你说话,真令人吃惊。听起来好像她才是你的老板。"
: 书中附的翻译是:
: "It was astonishing that she should speak to you in that manner.
: She sounded as if she were your boss."
: 我觉得有点怪怪的,既然是过去发生的事情,那应该要说
: "It was astonishing that she should have spoken to you in that manner."
: 才对吧???是因为这里不能用完成式吗?还是我误解了什麽呢??
: 希望有对文法较了解的人能为我解惑> <
: 感恩!!!
→ dunchee:www.macmillandictionary.com/dictionary/british/should 06/30 22:43
→ dunchee:-> 5 ... (第3个例句) 06/30 22:43
→ dunchee:"既然是过去发生的事情,那应该要说" -> 我有点好奇你没 06/30 22:43
→ dunchee:有想到简单过去式,反而是过去完成式的原因是? 06/30 22:43
→ dunchee:这用法的"should"其实没有时态上的变化(注意,我是单指字 06/30 22:44
→ dunchee:典上的 5 的这一个特定用法。其它用法你有兴趣的话自己看 06/30 22:44
→ dunchee:一下),且这时後的用法并不是subjunctive(你以为是过去完 06/30 22:44
→ dunchee:成式的理由?)(因为(意思上)确实有发生,并不是和事实相反 06/30 22:44
→ dunchee:)。如果你是因为发生在过去就要用过去完成,那麽你还要再 06/30 22:45
→ dunchee:查一下过去完成式的用法 06/30 22:45
→ dunchee:"....时後面可否用完成式?"-> 是有这用法,但是这不表示你 06/30 22:56
→ dunchee:可以任意拿来套用。参考: 06/30 22:56
→ dunchee:
http://dunchee.blogspot.com/2011/10/temp.html 06/30 22:56
何不直接回答人家呢, 若真的知道? 所以本题should have pp到底能不能用?
l10nel大说的是对的. 可以用. 本题这种东西就是putative should.
A Comprehensive Grammar of the English Language
p 1014
Putative should is used in that-clauses when the matrix clauses contain
verbs, adjectives, or nouns that convey an emotional reaction or that
express a necessity, plan, or intention for the future.
p 1015
A past verb in the matrix clause does not necessarily affect the form of
should in the subordinate clause, even though the subordinate clause
refers to a past situation:
I was surprised that he should feel lonely when he was in California.
But it is also possible to use a perfective form:
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
I was surprised that he should have felt lonely when he was in California.
(I was surprised that 与 It was surprising that 是视为等价的.)
※ 编辑: tijj 来自: 146.115.61.107 (07/04 21:56)