作者shousaki (呵~)
看板Eng-Class
标题Re: [考题] 台大考古题95(A)
时间Wed Feb 22 19:01:13 2012
※ 引述《ryanchan1993 (猪宝)》之铭言:
: ※ 引述《diony7 (七)》之铭言:
: : 考题:研究所考题
: : 题目:20. The moment an agreement was ______ after the long talk, everyone
: : shouted, "Hurrah!"
: : (A)arrived with (B)to arrive (C)arrived at (D)arrived
: : 提问:我查麦克米兰线上辞典,上面说达到某个结论通常都用arrive at,
: : 我自己也是觉得(C)比较合情理,但是有坊间参考书答案采用(D)。
: : (详解却也没解释......)
: : 想说arrive不及物应该配at比较恰当吧?
: : 不知道有没有人了解arrive用法的可以帮忙想想?>"<
: 这篇回文没针对答案来回, 而是斟酌另一个地方,
: 因为 arrive 是非及物动词, 所以跟OBJ 前面一定要加perp.
: 以小弟的愚见, 我认为题目本身是犯了一个很严重的错误
: 那句是用了 noun noun verb pattern
: (例句: The book I read is interesting),
: 可以拆简单一点成为:
: An agreement was arrived at the moment after the long talk,
: everyone shouted, "Hurrah!"
这边就有问题了,这个句子不能这样拆。
: 然後我把附加的东西(adj. clause)删掉, 句子变成:
: An agreement was arrived, everyone shouted, "Hurrah!"
你说你把附加的东西删掉,比较你所谓"拆简单一点"的句子和你删掉後的句子,
你删掉了at the moment
意思是你觉得at the moment在这句是里连在一起的吗?
这句里的at是因为arrive而存在,跟the moment没有关系。
: 或许乍看之下可能察觉不到有问题, 可是细心点看, 这句中间怎麽会有个逗号!
: 是不是缺少了个连接词?
: 若有错请不吝指正 ^^"
有关连接词的问题,
这句话的用法是
The moment an agreement was arrived at after the long talk, everyone shouted
, "Hurrah!".
利用英英字典查阅moment此字,可得到以下用法:
the moment (that) somebody does something
意思是 as soon as someone does something
例句为:
He said he'd phone you the moment he got home.
因此原句是将The moment (that) we arrived at an agreement after......
以被动语态呈现: The moment (that) an agreement was arrived at after.....
因此在这个句子之中,the moment不能如你所说的删去,
也没有缺少连接词的问题。
以上个人浅见,若有错误请高手指正,谢谢。
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 114.47.169.186
1F:→ shousaki:补充一下,你有提到arrive一定要加介词,所以有可能 02/22 19:10
2F:→ shousaki:你漏掉at只是手误,但此句和你举的例子 02/22 19:11
3F:→ shousaki:The book I read is interesting 也不相同 谢谢 02/22 19:11
4F:→ ryanchan1993:那想问一下 The moment 在这里可理解成什麽 词性? 02/22 21:50
5F:→ shousaki:我手边的文法书把他归成连接词,等於as soon as... 02/23 00:28
6F:→ shousaki:而oxford字典将其归於idioms 意思也是as soon as 02/23 00:30
7F:推 ryanchan1993:好, 谢谢^_^ 02/23 00:33
8F:→ shousaki:moment也可以换成minute/instant/ 意思也一样:) 02/23 00:36
9F:→ ting0901:i'm sorry, but D is wrong. It should be arrived AT 02/23 07:56
10F:→ shousaki:I tatally agree with you, but we are now discussing 02/23 12:24
11F:→ shousaki:the structure of this sentence instead of its answer. 02/23 12:24
12F:→ shousaki:And I think I DIDN'T mention the answer is D. Tks :) 02/23 12:30
13F:→ shousaki:"totally" 03/02 16:30