作者cloud7556 (Chemical Romance)
看板Eng-Class
标题[文法] 同位语要不要用冠词?
时间Mon Jun 21 14:41:04 2010
题目:活用图解B p-19
Hemingway, _____ of "The Old Man and the Sea," killed himself in 1961.
A) an author
B) the author
C) one author
D) author
答案为D ,一开始我的想法为B 。我是把句子还原成
"who is the author of...."因此应保留the ,但是
答案的解释为「人名之後的同位语,名词之前不加冠
词。」确实在该书的前面也提到类似观念。
Brown,
leader of our class, is an able man.
我书念的不是很多,但是我在网路上面看到很多跟这
有些微冲突的说法。
http://grammar.about.com/od/basicsentencegrammar/a/buildappositive.htm
Jimbo Gold,
a professional magician, performed at my sister's birthday party.
http://www.chompchomp.com/terms/appositive.htm
During the dinner conversation, Clifford,
the messiest eater at the table,
spewed mashed potatoes like an erupting volcano.
因此我是有点混乱,因为就我本人使用以及过往的语
感(当然有可能是错的)我是认为冠词应该是存在的
。
麻烦有经验以及熟悉这块文法的高手,帮忙指点迷津。:)
感谢万分。
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 114.39.1.95
1F:推 noruas:XXX of XXX 不加冠词 06/21 14:51
2F:→ noruas:Barack Obama, president of the United States,...... 06/21 14:52
3F:→ noruas:Barack Obama, the first black president,..... 06/21 14:53
4F:→ noruas:Barack Obama, a popular president at home and overseas, 06/21 14:54
5F:→ dunchee:"答案的解释为「人名...名词之前不加冠词.."-> "不加冠词" 06/21 22:23
6F:→ dunchee:是用法之一,但这并不是唯一的用法。加the的用法也有,尚 06/21 22:23
8F:→ dunchee:看内容,多看几个) 06/21 22:25
9F:→ cloud7556:thanks a billion. :) 06/21 23:53
10F:→ memorabilia:我看过类似的解释,像是Hemingway这种几乎是家喻户晓 06/22 14:10
11F:→ memorabilia:的人,同位语通常都不加冠词;反之则通常加a 或 the 06/22 14:11