作者dragon0905 (好学的人)
看板Eng-Class
标题[文法] 请问when的用法?
时间Thu Apr 22 22:56:34 2010
请问:
John did his homework when his mom came back.这样的写法可以吗?
还是要写
John was doing his homework when his mom came back.
或是
John had done his homework when his mom came back.
哪一句是比较接近英文的写法?
麻烦知道的人，可以帮我吗?谢谢您!
--
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 61.227.100.66
1F：→ B95730101:第一句不恰当(我认为啦)第二句文意像是说妈妈回来的时候 04/23 00:06
2F：→ B95730101:他还在做功课(从妈妈还没回来到回来为止都在做功课) 04/23 00:06
3F：→ B95730101:第三句是他在妈妈回来之前就做完功课,过去完成就像是 04/23 00:07
4F：→ B95730101:过去式的过去式 04/23 00:07
5F：→ dragon0905:那请问第一句为什麽不恰当?理由是什麽? 04/23 00:15
6F：→ B95730101:不好意思,我只能说是根据我的语感,有请楼下高手>< 04/23 00:20
7F：→ dunchee:你要先思考的是 "when his mom came back" 是表达怎样的 04/23 00:31
8F：→ dunchee:意思/是怎样的情况 his mom回来就是回来了，"回来"这动作 04/23 00:31
9F：→ dunchee:需要多少时间? 中文我们可以说"那当时"(比如如果你是John 04/23 00:32
10F：→ dunchee:那麽这指的可以是"听到key在门锁上转动的声音" 等到John 04/23 00:33
11F：→ dunchee:的妈妈已经进到屋里头，这时候就已经过了"when his mom 04/23 00:33
12F：→ dunchee:came back"的时刻. 那麽要描述在"这样短"的时刻期间所发生 04/23 00:34
13F：→ dunchee:的动作哪一个时态适当? 04/23 00:34
14F：→ dunchee:(你同时也要想 (to) do his homework 这描述的是"怎样"的 04/23 00:36
15F：→ dunchee:一个动作 04/23 00:36