作者DarkerDuck (達克鴨)
看板politics
標題Re: 紐西蘭當局認安全值為5PPM
時間Sun Sep 28 10:31:31 2008
※ 引述《manfale (戰神 吱見愁)》之銘言:
: 資料來源: 紐西蘭通訊社
: 紐西蘭食品安全局(NZFSA)今日說 5 PPM的門檻已經是 "保守"
: 食物含有 5PPM 的三聚 不會對人體健康造成危險
: http://nz.news.yahoo.com/a/-/top-stories/5042666/nzfsa-says-its-acceptable
: -for-people-to-eat-low-levels-of-melamine/
: NZFSA said today its 5ppm threshold was "conservative": "Foods containing
: up to 5ppm of melamine do not pose a risk to human health".
: 補一下紐國安全局的官方網站說明:
: http://www.nzfsa.govt.nz/publications/media-releases/2008/
: 26-sep-melamine-response-update.htm
: “Over the past week, our scientists have been exchanging information
: with their international colleagues. Last night, the European Food Safety
: Authority updated its opinion on the estimated tolerable daily intake (TDI)
: of melamine and left it unchanged at 0.5 mg/kg bodyweight (ie, for every
: kg a person weighs they can safely consume 0.5 mg every day – for a 20 kg
: child this is 10 mg; for a 70 kg adult the safe amount is 35 mg).”
: 歐盟的TDI是;
: 20公斤以下孩童的每日安全攝取量是 10mg
: 70公斤成人的每日安全攝取量是 35mg
: Based on this figure, which is very close to but lower than that of the
: United States, NZFSA has adopted a conservative threshold of 5 ppm for most
: foods. This means that it has been considered that foods containing up to 5
: ppm of melamine do not pose a risk to human health. However for starter
: infant formula, this level will be set to the current level of test
: detection of 1 ppm.
: 紐西蘭食品安全局(NZFSA) 採取保守標準 認為食物終究算有高達5PPM的三聚
: 仍然不會對身體造成危險
: 不過嬰兒仍為 1 PPM
既然三聚氰胺被大家說是種劇毒,那來看看同樣是毒物的眾多農藥的標準來看看好了,
絕大部分的農藥保證比三聚氰胺還要毒,喝個一兩滴就準備口吐白沫了,但三聚氰胺
也就是美耐皿卻可以被當作食物容器使用,而且在高溫及酸性環境下都會釋出到食品中,
高達數十ppm。
以下是各種農藥的檢出標準:
http://food.doh.gov.tw/law/pesticide_standard.asp#2
許多標準都高達1至2 ppm,最誇張的是亞烈寧這種殺蟲劑是3 ppm,吃殺蟲劑吃的比
三聚氰胺還多是怎樣,食品污染物的容許檢出量本來就是種妥協,農業有劇毒都容許
這麼高的檢出量了,依造三聚氰胺的TDI,容許檢出量更高都不會有事,當然以民眾的
觀感來說,污染物的容許檢出量越低越好,只是我不覺得吃2.5 ppm的美耐皿會比吃
3 ppm的殺蟲劑還恐怖,而且歐盟和紐西蘭的容許檢出標準也大約在數ppm左右。
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 219.80.133.106
1F:推 jeanvanjohn:那你每天都把塑膠碗吃下肚子裡好了^^ 203.203.28.46 09/28 10:46
2F:推 nalee:所以版大一天一杯三鹿奶? 211.74.53.4 09/28 10:52
3F:→ DarkerDuck:三鹿奶三聚氰胺檢出值為3000 ppm 219.80.133.106 09/28 10:55
4F:→ DarkerDuck:腦結石的人才會想要喝 219.80.133.106 09/28 10:56
5F:→ DarkerDuck:但我目前並未改變我喝奶茶吃麵包的習慣 219.80.133.106 09/28 10:57
6F:推 freeRD:我希望洗腎不會變成另一個習慣 203.67.54.211 09/28 21:46
7F:推 freeRD:只能說農藥我吃就好了,其他兩種你們吃 203.67.54.211 09/28 21:52
8F:→ DarkerDuck:樓上真的要吃農藥?那我也只好無言了 219.80.134.131 09/29 03:23