※ 引述《ftziya (ftziya)》之銘言： : 規則的討論不會因為是裁判或者等級比較高的裁判說的就對, : 都還是要回歸到規則本身去討論, : 而個人引述和老師的討論只是在說明那段話是有根據的, : 於此合先敘明, : 那w大所引述的原文, : 25.1.2只是中樞足的定義 不要玩文字遊戲.. 我不懂你說定義是中樞足的定義是哪來的 Art. 25 Travelling 25.1 Definition 明明是走步的定義 25.1.1 Travelling is the illegal movement of one or both feet beyond the limit s outlined in this article, in any direction, while holding a live ball on the court. 25.1.2 A pivot is the legal movement in which a player who is holding a live b ^^^^^^^ 不知道是不是英文不好 　已經說的很清楚只有軸心旋轉是持球時合 法的移動 all on the court steps once or more than once in any direction with the same f oot, while the other foot, called the pivot foot, is kept at its point of cont ^^^^^^^^^^ 從這邊才開始提到軸心足 act with the floor. : 25.2.1是指接到球後中樞足如何建立 然後呢?中樞足建立好玩的嗎? : 而我們現在討論的25.2.2是指中樞足建立後球員如何前進 : 有句法諺說凡有原則必有例外, 扯太遠了吧 : 如果規則沒有25.2.2的話,那上述的情形依25.1以及25.2.1的確是走步, : 但是現在籃球受到nba趨勢的影響, nba趨勢是啥? 你找出來 我看到的這一部份是沒啥不同 : 在規則上對於一些限制不斷在做修正, : 25.2.2部份內容就是放寬對中樞足的限制, 放寬在哪了?? 25.2.2 Progressing with the ball for a player who has established a pivot foot while having the control of a live ball on the court: ‧ While standing with both feet on the floor: ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ 這邊講的是站定　就是之前在討論的 . To start a dribble, the pivot foot may not be lifted before the ball is rele ased from the hand(s). . To pass or shoot for a field goal, the player may jump off a pivot foot, but neither foot may be returned to the floor before the ball is released from th ^^^^^^^^^ 雙足都不可以　不是只說哪足　　都特別強調加嚴了　還硬說是"放寬"? e hand(s). While moving or dribbling: ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ 這裡才是在講移動 . To start a dribble, the pivot foot may not be lifted before the ball is rele ased from the hand(s). 連運球下球軸足都不能離地 FIBA如此 NBA也如此 . To pass or shoot for a field goal, the player may jump off a pivot foot and land on one foot or both feet simultaneously but, after that, neither foot may be lifted from the floor before the ball is released from the hand(s). 只有移動及運球後才可以軸心腳離地後再著地 While coming to a stop when neither foot is the pivot foot: 若不建立中樞足 下面還有更嚴的咧 . To start a dribble, neither foot may be lifted before the ball is released f rom the hand(s). . To pass or shoot for a field goal, one or both feet may be lifted but may no t be returned to the floor before the ball is released from the hand(s). : 讓籃球的動作更好看精彩, : 因此個人認為可以把25.2.2與定義不同之處當作是例外來處理, : 以上論理內容僅是個人想法, : 而前篇個人的論述卻是有FIBA授權,我國國際籃球裁判翻譯的ez話籃球為證, : 也就是FIBA對規則文字所做出來的解釋, : 或許版友對於規則文字的應用可以作不同認定, : 但至少在國際賽上, : 關於之前版友所提問的情形與個人的答覆殊無二致, 喔 殊無二致？ : 希望這段內容對版友能有所幫助. --

※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 59.112.29.47 ※ 編輯: wilson1000 來自: 59.112.29.47 (06/25 02:58)