作者mayfirst (2010AL冠軍遊騎兵)
看板Rangers
標題[討論]Whose potential Zack Greinke deal is better
時間Mon Dec 6 17:35:47 2010
Whose potential Zack Greinke deal is better: Toronto or Texas?
哪隊提出的交易包裹比較好?
There has been a lot of talk lately about the possibility of the Texas
Rangers acquiring Zack Greinke if they are unable to retain Cliff Lee.
However, the Toronto Blue Jays appear to making a strong push for Greinke as
well. They recently traded Shaun Marcum to the Brewers in a deal that
includes power hitting second base prospect Brett Lawrie. The Blue Jays now
have a glutton of prospects in their minor league system and appear to be
able to put together a strong package for Greinke. So the question is...
Whose potential deal is better: Toronto or Texas?
We can only speculate on the players that could be involved but lets just
assume a 3 prospects for Greinke. Here are the Baseball America top ten
prospects for each team. (For the Blue Jays I added in Lawrie and Snider to
the list as 1B and 1C because they could also be part of the deal, For the
Rangers I added Derek Holland as 1B)
Toronto
1. Kyle Drabek, rhp
2. Deck McGuire, rhp
3. Anthony Gose, of
4. Travis D'Arnaud, c
5. Zach Stewart, rhp
6. Asher Wojciechowski, rhp
7. J.P. Arencibia, c
8. Carlos Perez, c
9. Aaron Sanchez, rhp
10. Jake Marisnick, of
1B. Travis Snider (LF)
1C. Brett Lawrie (2B)
Texas
1. Martin Perez, lhp
2. Jurickson Profar, ss
3. Tanner Scheppers, rhp
4. Robbie Erlin, lhp
5. Engel Beltre, of
6. Michael Kirkman, lhp
7. Mike Olt, 3b
8. Luis Sardinas, ss
9. Jake Skole, of
10. Miguel de los Santos, lhp
1B. Derek Holland (LHP)
Here are some possible deals:
Texas Rangers deal: Derek Holland (LHP),
Martin Perez (LHP) or Tanner Sceppers (RHP),
Jurickson Profar (SS)
Toronto Blue Jays deal:Kyle Drabek (RHP) or Brett Lawrie (2B),
J.P. Arencibia (C) or Travis D'Arnaud (C),
Zack Stewart (RHP) or Travis Snider (LF)
新聞來源:
http://www.royalsreview.com/2010/12/5/1857778/whose-potential-zack-greinke
-deal-is-better-toronto-or-texas
Poll
Whose Potential Zack Greinke deal is better: Toronto or Texas?
53%
Toronto(17 votes)
46%
Texas (15 votes)
截稿為止總投票數:32 votes
編按:一個去年防禦率四點多加上心裏有焦慮症的投手，需要動到那三隻頂級新秀嗎??
--
2010 Texas Rangers Postseason Franchise Roster
(SP)Cliff Lee (C)Benjie Molina (1B)Mitch Moreland (2B)Ian Kinsler
(SS)Elvis Andrus (3B)Michael Young (LF)David Murphy (CF)Josh Hamilton
(RF)Nelson Cruz (DH)Vladimir Guerrero (SP)C.J. Wilson (SP)Colby Lewis
(CL)Neftali Feliz (RP)Darren O'Day (RP)Darren Oliver (SP)Derek Holland
(RP)Alexi Ogando (RP)Michael Kirkman (C)Matt Treanor (OF)Julio Borbon
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 210.243.5.253
※ 編輯: mayfirst 來自: 210.243.5.253 (12/06 17:36)
1F：推 seekforever:說Greinke是去年防禦率四點多加上心裏有焦慮症的投手 12/06 18:07
2F：→ seekforever:那Holland是什麼? 投不進好球帶的投手? 12/06 18:08
3F：→ seekforever:Greinke約到2012(27M) 以市價來說很便宜 代價高很正常 12/06 18:09
4F：→ mayfirst:樓上言重了，說Greinke的部份是指GM談判間的計策，藉以 12/06 19:07
5F：→ mayfirst:拉低送出更多新秀的代價。若有冒犯之處我先行道歉m(_._)m 12/06 19:07
6F：→ mayfirst:Holland是天花板No.1~2的投手 12/06 19:08
7F：→ mayfirst:我是認為Greinke 2010年的表現會降低他的交易價值嗎? 12/06 19:08
8F：推 cloudfour:我也這麼認為~而且同時要冒的風險也不少 12/06 19:17