作者bear6350 (熊)
看板PhD
標題[問題] revise 的內容
時間Fri Apr 22 14:33:29 2011
請問各位前輩
我投稿的論文revise了
主編回信給我
內容如下：
The evaluation of your manuscript indicates that it is not acceptable for
publication in its present form.
However, if you feel that you can suitably address the review comments (see
below),
I invite you to revise and resubmit your manuscript.
In so doing, please
a) outline each change made (point by point) as raised in the reviewer comments;
and/or b) provide a suitable rebuttal to each reviewer comment not addressed.
請問a)與b)是啥意思阿
a)與b)要一起回送給主編嗎？
謝謝
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 210.240.34.205
1F：→ puec2:a)因接受reviewer的建議而進行的更動要逐條列出(頁碼+行號) 04/22 14:44
2F：→ puec2:b)如果不願意照reviewer的意見進行更動，請提出反駁的理由。 04/22 14:45
3F：推 guare:這是很普通的revise回函，問一下你的老闆吧 04/22 14:49
4F：推 luegg100:就把reviewer意見,用一問一答方式 04/22 20:08
5F：→ luegg100:再說明詳細內容加在revised version中的第幾行第幾頁 04/22 20:09
6F：→ luegg100:就在送回去review了喔 04/22 20:09
7F：推 lorance:只要好好的REVIS,好好的回覆(逐條),應該可以很樂觀被接受 04/24 23:33
8F：推 Tiunn:請問reviewer comment not addressed是什麼意思? 04/25 18:16