SKY 球迷 評分 Edwin van der Sar 6 6.3 Little to do all game but was assured when called upon. John O'Shea 6 5.1 Had a frustrating game but dealt with Gutierrez well. Chris Smalling 7 6.3 Great pace and strength all game. Made life very difficult for Newcastle's frontline. Nemanja Vidic 8 7.3 Superb throughout. Dominated the Man United penalty area and gave Newcastle scraps to feed on. Patrice Evra 6 5.7 Solid defensively but rarely threatened the Newcastle defense like he is capable of. Anderson 6 4.4 Not the midfielder's best game and was lucky to avoid conceding a penalty for a challenge on Lovenkrands. Ryan Giggs 7 5.3 Could have won the game with a golden second half chance. Full of fine deliveries all night. Michael Carrick 6 4.8 Good running but lacked the killer touch in midfield to really hurt Newcastle. Wayne Rooney 7 5.6 Beautiful long balls all game but never had an effort that caused Newcastle any damage. Javier Hernandez 7 5.2 Brilliant movement all game and was involved in a controversial penalty claim late on. Nani 7 5.3 Was an attacking threat all night but never found the accuracy to challenge Krul. Michael Owen (Sub) 4 3.9 Barely touched the ball upon his introduction into the game Antonio Valencia (Sub) 5 4.8 Provided an extra option but was neutralised well by Newcastle. http://www.skysports.com/football/user_ratings/0,19768,11065_3380693,00.html M.E.N http://tinyurl.com/3slete5 Edwin van der Sar - 6 Veteran keeper had very little to do after the early onslaught from the Toon as United dominated possession John O'Shea - 6 Continued to raid down the right flank but got little ball from Nani. Was rarely troubled in defence and made vital tackle at the end Patrice Evra - 6 Produced great ball to set up Giggs for what should have been the opening goal, not tested too much in defence Chris Smalling - 6 Lucky not to be punished by Lovenkrands after losing him in first half but recovered well after the interval Nemanja Vidic - 7 Bloodied but battled on as United's Mr Consistent put in another solid performance at the heart of defence Anderson - 6 Lacklustre show and had a lucky escape having made contact with Lovernkrands in the box in the second half Ryan Giggs - 5 Should have done better with free header in second half and then missed an absolute sitter from 12 yards out Nani - 7 Improved in second half, tested the Toon with a couple of decent crosses and some lively runs, but no end product Michael Carrick - 7 Some sublime passing at times and made couple of runs through the middle but couldn't unlock the door for United Wayne Rooney - 7 Looked lively after two-match break, but missed a great chance in first 20 minutes to mark his return with a goal Javier Hernandez - 6 Missed great chance to put the Reds in front in opening minutes and then booked for diving in injury time Substitutes Antonio Valencia - 6 (Anderson, 70) Failed to make an impact Michael Owen - 6 (Nani, 81) Not the warmest of welcomes from the Toon faithful and couldn't find a winner -- 浪費機會與評分有正相關 --

※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 210.242.135.125