作者tty0102 (酒精)
看板MLB
標題[情報] 今年將在3A測試揮棒過半挑戰系統
時間Tue Mar 17 14:47:03 2026
https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2026/03/mlb-to-test-check-swing-rule-changes-in
-triple-a.html
擷取文章一些重點
The most notable is the introduction of the check-swing challenge system in th
e Triple-A Pacific Coast League, beginning in early May. That allows a batter,
pitcher, or catcher to challenge an umpire’s check-swing decision against ba
t-tracking technology. MLB had tested this rule in the Low-A Florida State Lea
gue and the Arizona Fall League last year
MLB To Test Check-Swing Rule In Triple-A
March 16th, 2026 at 11:02pm CST ‧ By Anthony Franco
Major League Baseball will implement a handful of rule changes at various leve
ls of the minor leagues during the 2026 season. Eric Longenhagen of FanGraphs
first reported the slate and those interested in the topic are encouraged to r
ead that post in full.
The most notable is the introduction of the check-swing challenge system in th
e Triple-A Pacific Coast League, beginning in early May. That allows a batter,
pitcher, or catcher to challenge an umpire’s check-swing decision against ba
t-tracking technology. MLB had tested this rule in the Low-A Florida State Lea
gue and the Arizona Fall League last year.
Advertisement
A check-swing challenge system requires an objective cutoff point. The thresho
ld is whether the bat head breaks a 45? angle relative to the handle (essentia
lly aligning with the opposite base line). Major League Baseball’s rulebook d
oesn’t have an official check-swing cutoff, instead leaving it at the umpire
’s discretion as to whether the hitter offered.
As Longenhagen demonstrates with video, the 45? threshold is further along tha
n what umpires have generally treated as the cutoff. That led hitters to succe
ssfully challenge a lot of calls last year. It appears that’s a deliberate co
nsideration by the league. MLB’s memo notes a slight drop in the Florida Stat
e League strikeout rate after the check-swing challenge was implemented, “hav
ing a positive impact on balls in play and encouraging more extensive testing
at higher levels.” It’s not a huge effect but one that would turn more swing
ing strikes into balls than vice versa.
今年5月開始會在3A太平洋聯盟PCL測試揮
棒過半挑戰系統,判斷標準是是球棒頭部相
對於握把的角度是否超過45度,會允許打者
投手 捕手挑戰,而國際聯盟IL則是僅提供裁
判判決標準,不提供球隊挑戰。
根據去年在1A測試的結果,45度通常比裁判
判決出棒過半的臨界點靠前,如影片所示,
在引入挑戰系統後1A的聯盟整體三振率有顯
著下滑。
看似過半但實際上不到45度
https://youtu.be/dRw89dkKFRI?si=McLLW4YtFX8duNMN
挑戰影片
https://youtu.be/_kieqgvRWno?si=4cIuIKaulZhMW4LD
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 49.216.172.220 (臺灣)
※ 文章網址: https://webptt.com/m.aspx?n=bbs/MLB/M.1773730026.A.B51.html
※ 編輯: tty0102 (49.216.172.220 臺灣), 03/17/2026 14:49:02
1F:推 jerryklu: 一直在想45度到底從哪開始算 原來是用三壘線看 雖然有 03/17 15:35
2F:→ jerryklu: 明確規則是好事 但這跟過往慣例好像差的有點多 03/17 15:35
3F:推 carlchang092: 用平行壘線當判定標準其實也有部分裁判這樣判 03/17 15:40
4F:→ carlchang092: 原因也很簡單因為一般認知平行本壘板前緣 03/17 15:40
5F:→ carlchang092: 從裁判角度是斜的根本沒辦法有明確參考 03/17 15:40
6F:→ carlchang092: 改成45度可以讓裁判也有統一判決的可能 03/17 15:40
7F:推 lowl99: Acuna表示 03/17 15:54
8F:推 Johseagull: 酷 有統一都好 03/17 16:13
9F:→ uranusjr: 改 45% 有顯著下滑很合理, 和現行標準比寬鬆很多 03/17 16:29
10F:推 kenkuo1688: 原來是45度 我以為過本壘版就是了 03/17 18:24
11F:→ ProducerChen: 好酷喔 03/17 19:16
12F:推 carlchang092: 原本是沒有明確標準裁判自由心證 03/17 19:17
13F:→ carlchang092: 看棒頭(接近45度) 看本壘板前緣平行(90度) 03/17 19:18
14F:→ carlchang092: 看手腕甚至身體重心什麼的都有聽說被當標準 03/17 19:18
15F:→ carlchang092: 現在統一成裁判比較能一致的標準也好 03/17 19:18