作者leddy (耿秋)
看板MLB
標題[評比]John Dewan 評2003-2005年的右外野手
時間Tue May 15 23:55:08 2007
※ [本文轉錄自 NY-Yankees 看板]
作者: leddy (耿秋) 看板: NY-Yankees
標題: [評比]John Dewan 評2003-2005年的右外野手
時間: Tue May 15 23:54:17 2007
John Dewan 提出新ZR作法, Google了一下引起很多的討論
可以查到他用統計後對右外野手的評比, 就把他貼出來給大家看看
右外野手評比
年份 聯盟 金手套得主 應該得的是
2003 AL Ichiro Suzuki Ichiro Suzuki
NL Jose Cruz Richard Hidalgo
2004 AL Ichiro Suzuki Ichiro Suzuki
NL none Richard Hidalgo
2005 AL Ichiro Suzuki Ichiro Suzuki
NL Bobby Abreu Geoff Jenkins
(只有一朗是實至名歸)
Dewan個人的評價
前十名 倒數五名
1 Ichiro Suzuki, Sea 26 Emil Brown, KC
2 Richard Hidalgo, FA 27 Jeromy Burnitz, Pit
3 Trot Nixon, Bos 28 Sammy Sosa, FA
4 Geoff Jenkins, Mil 29 Matt Lawton, Sea
5 Austin Kearns, Cin 30 Gary Sheffield, NYY
6 J.D. Drew, LAD
7 Alexis Rios, Tor
8 Jeff Francoeur, Atl
9 Jose Guillen, Was
10 Jose Cruz, LAD
(Sheffield還真慘)
右外野手排名
三年正/負(Plus/Minus)排名(2003-2005年)
1 Ichiro Suzuki +48 11 Raul Mondesi +2 21 Vladimir Guerrero -14
2 Trot Nixon +26 12 Jose Cruz +1 22 Sammy Sosa -14
3 J.D. Drew +25 13 Shawn Green +1 23 Jody Gerut -15
4 Richard Hidalgo +21 14 Brian Giles -2 24 Jacque Jones -16
5 Jose Guillen +21 15 Larry Walker -5 25 Juan Encarnacion -20
6 Austin Kearns +13 16 Aubrey Huff -6 26 Michael Tucker -20
7 Alexis Rios +12 17 Jermaine Dye -7 27 Gary Sheffield -38
8 Bobby Higginson +12 18 Jeromy Burnitz -7
9 Magglio Ordonez +10 19 Danny Bautista -10
10 Jay Gibbons +3 20 Bobby Abreu -12
2005年正/負(Plus/Minus)排名
1 Trot Nixon +18 11 Magglio Ordonez +3 21 Jermaine Dye -6
2 Casey Blake +14 12 Mike Cameron +2 22 Jacque Jones -8
3 Geoff Jenkins +13 13 Alexis Rios +1 23 Victor Diaz -8
4 Jose Guillen +10 14 Nick Swisher -1 24 Sammy Sosa -8
5 Vladimir Guerrero +10 15 Brad Hawpe -3 25 Larry Walker -8
6 Jay Gibbons +10 16 Jeromy Burnitz -4 26 Emil Brown -9
7 Jeff Francoeur +10 17 Shawn Green -4 27 Juan Encarnacion -12
8 Richard Hidalgo +8 18 Jason Lane -4 28 Bobby Abreu -13
9 Ichiro Suzuki +7 19 Aubrey Huff -4 29 Matt Lawton -17
10 Austin Kearns +7 20 Brian Giles -5 30 Craig Monroe -18
31 Gary Sheffield -25
2004年正/負(Plus/Minus)排名
1 Ichiro Suzuki +30 11 Abraham Nunez +4 21 Bobby Abreu -6
2 J.D. Drew +21 12 Brian Giles +3 22 Jacque Jones -7
3 Brady Clark +20 13 Jay Gibbons +2 23 Jose Cruz -8
4 Alexis Rios +11 14 Juan Encarnacion +1 24 Danny Bautista -8
5 Richard Hidalgo +9 15 Larry Walker 0 25 Michael Tucker -8
6 Bobby Higginson +8 16 Jermaine Dye -1 26 Miguel Cabrera -8
7 Gabe Kapler +8 17 Sammy Sosa -2 27 Gary Sheffield -11
8 Kevin Mench +5 18 Jeromy Burnitz -3 28 Craig Wilson -14
9 Austin Kearns +5 19 Reggie Sanders -4 29 Jody Gerut -15
10 Juan Rivera +4 20 Lance Berkman -5 30 Vladimir Guerrero -18
2003年正/負(Plus/Minus)排名
1 Ichiro Suzuki +11 11 Bobby Higginson +3 21 John Vander Wal -2
2 Jose Guillen +11 12 Larry Walker +3 22 Aaron Guiel -3
3 Jeff DaVanon +11 13 Jose Cruz 0 23 Sammy Sosa -4
4 Magglio Ordonez +10 14 Jermaine Dye 0 24 Bobby Kielty -4
5 Bobby Abreu +7 15 Dustan Mohr -1 25 Reed Johnson -4
6 Trot Nixon +7 16 Reggie Sanders -1 26 Vladimir Guerrero -6
7 Xavier Nady +6 17 Terrence Long -1 27 Tim Salmon -6
8 Raul Mondesi +5 18 Gary Sheffield -2 28 Roger Cedeno -7
9 Richard Hidalgo +4 19 Shawn Green -2 29 Juan Encarnacion -9
10 Jody Gerut +4 20 Aubrey Huff -2 30 Jay Gibbons -9
(Abreu的防守區域評價是直直落, 但Sheffield則是Orz)
三年外野臂力排名(2003-2005)
1 Richard Hidalgo .427 11 Gary Sheffield .528 21 Juan Encarnacion .575
2 Alexis Rios .432 12 Vladimir Guerrero .532 22 Sammy Sosa .585
3 Jacque Jones .471 13 Jay Gibbons .543 23 J.D. Drew .586
4 Larry Walker .472 14 Magglio Ordonez .544 24 Michael Tucker .592
5 Ichiro Suzuki .477 15 Jose Guillen .555 25 Jody Gerut .593
6 Jose Cruz .491 16 Trot Nixon .557 26 Bobby Higginson .595
7 Raul Mondesi .500 17 Jermaine Dye .563 27 Danny Bautista .611
8 Bobby Abreu .507 18 Brian Giles .564
9 Austin Kearns .511 19 Jeromy Burnitz .572
10 Aubrey Huff .519 20 Shawn Green .574
2005年外野臂力排名
1 Victor Diaz .379 11 Bobby Abreu .492 21 Jay Gibbons .545
2 Alexis Rios .424 12 Jeff Francoeur .493 22 Brad Hawpe .551
3 Jason Lane .432 13 Richard Hidalgo .494 23 Nick Swisher .561
4 Matt Lawton .447 14 Aubrey Huff .510 24 Trot Nixon .564
5 Gary Sheffield .449 15 Jermaine Dye .513 25 Geoff Jenkins .567
6 Vladimir Guerrero .458 16 Juan Encarnacion .524 26 Ichiro Suzuki .572
7 Larry Walker .464 17 Craig Monroe .531 27 Magglio Ordonez .573
8 Jacque Jones .475 18 Jose Guillen .537 28 Sammy Sosa .574
9 Austin Kearns .485 19 Shawn Green .544 29 Casey Blake .594
10 Mike Cameron .491 20 Brian Giles .545 30 Emil Brown .617
31 Jeromy Burnitz .629
2004年外野臂力排名
1 Richard Hidalgo .421 11 Abraham Nunez .500 21 Jermaine Dye .597
2 Ichiro Suzuki .434 12 Jeromy Burnitz .516 22 Bobby Abreu .597
3 Alexis Rios .441 13 Bobby Higginson .535 23 Jody Gerut .600
4 Kevin Mench .453 14 Austin Kearns .540 24 Miguel Cabrera .614
5 Jay Gibbons .462 15 Vladimir Guerrero .547 25 Gabe Kapler .619
6 Jacque Jones .462 16 Gary Sheffield .557 26 Michael Tucker .621
7 Juan Rivera .468 17 Juan Encarnacion .573 27 Larry Walker .625
8 Lance Berkman .484 18 Brian Giles .580 28 Craig Wilson .625
9 Reggie Sanders .493 19 Danny Bautista .586 29 Sammy Sosa .656
10 Jose Cruz .493 20 J.D. Drew .594 30 Brady Clark .736
2003外野臂力排名
1 Richard Hidalgo .383 11 Raul Mondesi .522 21 Jose Guillen .583
2 Jeff DaVanon .396 12 Aubrey Huff .529 22 Jay Gibbons .584
3 Larry Walker .398 13 Sammy Sosa .530 23 Jermaine Dye .596
4 Ichiro Suzuki .400 14 Bobby Kielty .533 24 Tim Salmon .597
5 Bobby Abreu .421 15 Reed Johnson .564 25 Reggie Sanders .598
6 Jose Cruz .465 16 Xavier Nady .570 26 Shawn Green .610
7 Dustan Mohr .475 17 John Vander Wal .571 27 Roger Cedeno .611
8 Trot Nixon .492 18 Gary Sheffield .574 28 Juan Encarnacion .627
9 Aaron Guiel .495 19 Vladimir Guerrero .576 29 Bobby Higginson .657
10 Magglio Ordonez .500 20 Jody Gerut .582 30 Terrence Long .683
(Abreu的臂力還算不錯, Sheffied則大約為平均值)
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 220.132.198.21
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 220.132.198.21
※ 編輯: leddy 來自: 220.132.198.21 (05/15 23:56)
1F：推 googoodoll:Hidalgo那傢伙用打擊掩蓋了防守，而且已經完全退化 -_- 05/16 00:07
2F：推 mikehu:Vlady這三年來的差異還真大 不知道去年如何? 05/16 00:15
3F：推 A1pha:看下面的數據之後，不懂為什麼一朗金手套還是名至實歸？ 05/16 00:37
4F：→ A1pha:我是說2005年 05/16 00:38
5F：→ A1pha:05年 臂力第26 +-排名第9..... 05/16 00:39
6F：→ A1pha:順便問一下，那個臂力怎麼算的@@" 05/16 00:40
7F：推 leddy:我想這就是他為什麼要分享這些內容的原因 05/16 00:53
8F：→ leddy:其他內容不可得, 要買書 05/16 00:53
9F：→ leddy:他的介紹如下 05/16 00:54
10F：→ leddy:Ichiro Suzuki's play in right field, while still "Top 10 05/16 00:55
11F：→ leddy:" stuff in 2005, is no longer the creme of the crop 05/16 00:55
12F：→ leddy:that it was in 2003 and 2004 (除了+/-,arm以外內容未公開) 05/16 00:56
13F：推 A1pha:XD 瞭解了XD 謝謝樓上～～辛苦囉<(_ _)> 05/16 01:04
※ 編輯: leddy 來自: 220.132.198.21 (07/18 22:59)