1.Mariah Listened To What The People Wanted Reviewer: J. W. Guinn 走抒情,迎合大眾路線,從butterfly後最好的一張album 2.Great CD!, April 12, 2005 Reviewer: Wendy Norris 如果你連I like that都喜歡的話,其他歌你一定會喜歡!(我跟Wendy Norris有同感,ILT so-so而已,) 3.Mariah proves to still be the BEST singer EVER!!!!!!, April 12, 2005 Reviewer: Joy Elizabeth Teets (Fairfax, VA USA) review寫一大堆,瘋狂女歌迷, 4. The Voice is Back!!!!!!!!!, April 12, 2005 Reviewer: S. Duchon (MI United States) 我很久沒有不跳歌而聽完一張CD了 5.Very Good Cd!!!!!!, April 12, 2005 Reviewer: Ray (Michigan) 這張專輯比較少whispering,就算有也都在適當的地方出現 6.Best Album of Mariah's Career, April 12, 2005 Reviewer: Bryan L. Jacobs (Columbia, SC United States) 這老兄覺得每支歌都有潛力當single,每首歌最低給九分..... 7.The Emancipation of Mimi by Mariah Carey, April 12, 2005 Reviewer: Joseph "JoMo" (Texas) 這德州佬喜歡MC唱ballads,覺得之前兩張專輯曲風走偏了, 浪費diva的歌聲 這張很合他胃口 8.The Apreciation to Mimi, April 12, 2005 Reviewer: Josephll "Josephll" (CET) 跟德州佬意見一樣 9.Freedom for Mimi!, April 12, 2005 Reviewer: Matthew G. Sherwin (Bayside, New York United States) 講些好話,不過沒啥建設性 10She is back, April 12, 2005 Reviewer: gmsosco (Edinburgh, Scotland) 這蘇格蘭人覺得除了Shake it off不合他胃口,其他都不錯, 尤其是眾ballads(Stay The Night, We Belong Together, Fly Like A Bird, I Wish You Knew.) 11.The Emancipation Of Mimi will be #1, April 12, 2005 Reviewer: Leroy Larsen (Jacksonville, FL USA) 節奏像Usher,這個人覺得這張沒有一首爛歌 12.Best album of 2005., April 12, 2005 Reviewer: Steve! "S-love" (ohio, usa) 又是個愛聽ballads的男生,意見同上 13Essential for 2005!, April 12, 2005 Reviewer: Meryl Streep 也是個愛聽ballads的傢伙,不過他說,跟Music box時代比起來,這張的ballads比較有節奏感,讓人感覺不老套 14.Lovin' Mimi, April 12, 2005 Reviewer: Elizabeth Taylor 瘋狂女歌迷,不予置評 15.WORDS CANNOT EXPRESS HOW GOOD THIS IS!!!, April 12, 2005 Reviewer: Newton C. Gordon (Fullerton, CA USA 覺得Glitter跟Charmbracelet沒有傳言中的那麼糟糕,頂多是whispering的問題 新專輯用full voice,他覺得不錯,然後說他也喜歡ballads,說有點70's soul feel的味道. 16.Mariah is BACK!........and better than Ever, April 12, 2005 Reviewer: B. Hiro "b rocka" (Hawaii, USA) 從小就支持MC的人,不過沒啥建設性發言 17.Mimi Does Good, April 12, 2005 Reviewer: Winona Ryder 覺得mimi改邪歸正了,ballads才是MC最擅長的 18.A Perfect way to do music!, April 12, 2005 Reviewer: M. Govanni (ITALY) 講了堆廢話,結尾寫了"SHE IS BACKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK " 19Golden Goddess Finally Emancipated!, April 12, 2005 Reviewer: Jagged Little Teenager (Leeds, United Kingdom) 他覺得在 Tori Amos, Madonna, Britney Spears, Coldplay, Fiona Apple, Bjork, Missy Elliott, Radiohead, Janet Jackson,MC等女藝人中,MC是最愛,她展現了其他金髮女歌手所沒有的才華-->指會寫歌 (金髮=無腦?呵呵) butterfly他心中第一,這張新專輯算第二 20Vocally astonishing and perfectly balanced, April 12, 2005 Reviewer: MovedbyMusic "lishaz3" - 像to the floor等歌還不算太urban,算是比較照顧老歌迷了 以下是兩位只給一顆星的傢伙 21.Boring/Overbearing, April 12, 2005 Reviewer: dsitruc 這張專輯無聊,mc自大(MC hater常說的話) 對whispering,screaming,震破耳膜的高音等很不滿(註:明明就已經收斂很多,MC hater) MC從來就不是soul singer,這張專輯可以證明(註:mimi是pop diva,ok?) 唱歌沒放感情(註:這張算是很放感情了吧) 寫歌都是引用他人,沒有想像力,抄襲以前的trend跟現代的trend(註:還好吧) Fly like a bird-->為了迎合美國基督價值觀做出來的歌,阿諛奉承這老兄很不爽 22.Does she even know what emancipation means?, April 12, 2005 Reviewer: Tom Tom (New York) 這傢伙認為,MC是個捨不得spotlight的diva,為了東山再起, 不惜讓曲風又回到之前ballads,很老套, (註:其實這張的ballads還蠻有節奏感蠻現代的) 這老兄認為MC根本不懂解放的意思 (註:這老兄認為解放就是要文化大革命,破四舊,打倒孔家店才算emancipation,難到要MC做些怪怪音樂才算解放嗎?像是重金屬搖滾之類的嗎? 的確MC這張沒有很新的概念,但我覺得還是蠻好聽的) 好啦,再打下去會沒完沒了,我睡囉! --

※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 163.29.211.201