作者LesBleus (Fansé)
看板KoreaStar
標題[情報] Billboard 25首最佳K-Pop單曲 (2019)
時間Mon Dec 30 08:03:10 2019
Billboard評論者之選:2019最佳的25首K-Pop單曲
The 25 Best K-pop Songs of 2019: Critics' Picks
http://bit.ly/2Sxr3Wq
1. EXO "Obsession"
2. Apink "%% (Eung Eung)"
3. Chung Ha "Gotta Go"
4. TXT "9 and Three Quarters (Run Away)"
5. Heize "We Don't Talk Together (feat. Giriboy)"
6. GOT7 "You Calling My Name"
7. AKMU "How Can I Love the Heartbreak,
You're the One I Love"
8. Hwasa "Twit"
9. (G)I-dle "Lion"
10. Stray Kids "Miroh"
11. CLC "No"
12. N.Flying "Rooftop"
13. ATEEZ "Say My Name"
14. TWICE "Fancy"
15. BTS "Boy With Luv (feat. Halsey)"
16. NCT 127 "Highway to Heaven"
17. R.Tee & Anda "What You Waiting For"
18. Red Velvet "Psycho"
19. IU "Blueming"
20. ITZY "Dalla Dalla"
21. BLACKPINK "Kill This Love"
22. AB6IX "Breathe"
23. Seventeen "Fear"
24. Jvcki Wai, Young B,
Osshun Gum & Han Yo Han "DDING"
25. SuperM "Jopping"
內文引言寫到,
評選過程中特別將鄭俊英與崔鍾訓入獄、
TWICE的Mina因心理健康問題缺席活動、
Burning Sun醜聞、Sulli與Hara離世等,
一連串不公正的結構和社會問題納入考量。
不過我自己是看不懂這份榜單跟這些事件有什麼關聯,
或有替這些問題傳達了什麼訊息。
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 1.169.35.50 (臺灣)
※ 文章網址: https://webptt.com/m.aspx?n=bbs/KoreaStar/M.1577664195.A.E4E.html
1F:→ LesBleus: R.Tee & Anda那首入選倒是滿驚喜的,應 1.169.35.50 12/30 08:03
2F:→ LesBleus: 該是榜單上最冷門的一首了吧? 1.169.35.50 12/30 08:04
3F:推 linjolene: 推 GOT7 “you calling my name” 118.160.49.22 12/30 08:34
4F:推 general77413: 感覺把那些寫進去應該是想表達Kpop 118.150.195.65 12/30 08:45
5F:→ general77413: 產業背後不可忽視的問題在今年一一 118.150.195.65 12/30 08:45
6F:→ general77413: 爆發?內容蠻用心而且中肯,作者有 118.150.195.65 12/30 08:45
7F:→ general77413: 認真研究。給推! 118.150.195.65 12/30 08:45
8F:推 dbey4010314: 都是不錯的好歌!給推! 110.28.102.56 12/30 08:46
9F:推 Necuta: 推TXT的《在九又四分之三月台等你》用耳機114.137.235.165 12/30 08:46
10F:→ Necuta: 聽真的非常享受!114.137.235.165 12/30 08:46
11F:推 nike923123: 推作者 61.220.255.19 12/30 08:48
12F:推 keroceroppi: 推TXT 39.11.162.228 12/30 08:50
13F:推 sunny61629: 推防彈 推小娟寫的Lion和NO都入選 125.230.100.43 12/30 08:56
14F:推 cty03: 5. Heize 那首 是feat. “Giriboy” 中間應180.217.165.168 12/30 09:01
15F:→ cty03: 該沒有空格喔180.217.165.168 12/30 09:01
Thx!
16F:推 iiooppoi: 推防彈!推TXT! 39.8.170.175 12/30 09:05
17F:推 hermes20372: 推Apink、樂童、貝貝、BLACKPINK 。 114.41.108.140 12/30 09:13
18F:→ hermes20372: 最後路人推TXT的九又四分之三月台, 114.41.108.140 12/30 09:13
19F:→ hermes20372: 很好聽! 114.41.108.140 12/30 09:13
20F:推 chihjooo: 推防彈!推TXT!122.116.148.248 12/30 09:13
21F:推 qq134: 推apink 推nct 101.12.66.99 12/30 09:14
22F:推 BlaBlaBon: 推17 got7 新飛 還有lion! 223.136.97.48 12/30 09:15
23F:推 jaugnl: 推EXO!! 1.200.193.122 12/30 09:16
24F:推 bmfd1106: 推SEVENTEEN!150.116.254.239 12/30 09:20
25F:推 Amazingbomi: 推Apink~ 101.12.56.42 12/30 09:22
26F:推 dbnkks: 推EXO 125.227.145.85 12/30 09:27
27F:推 abopj80: 推防彈 36.232.42.248 12/30 09:30
28F:推 baekhyunbias: EXO AB6IX大推 111.71.18.58 12/30 09:35
29F:推 rabbithotty: 推GOT7 You Calling My Name 49.216.47.164 12/30 09:35
30F:推 swagstliou: 推防彈小詩,推TXT九又四分之三月台180.217.216.174 12/30 09:35
31F:推 BunnyBerry22: Mtv那篇前面也有這種引言XD 117.19.167.97 12/30 09:35
32F:→ BunnyBerry22: 我沒翻就是了 117.19.167.97 12/30 09:35
33F:推 realpcyyyyyy: 推EXO!!!!!120.113.180.129 12/30 09:40
34F:推 loxe9: 推EXO 越聽越上癮180.217.222.193 12/30 09:44
35F:推 chrissyqaz: 推CLC180.204.225.143 12/30 09:57
36F:推 zasxcdfv: 推樂童 推SEVENTEEN 114.136.219.76 12/30 10:06
37F:推 PinkBnN: 推APINK 39.13.32.187 12/30 10:11
38F:推 sport123456: 推IU推IU!!! 101.12.66.205 12/30 10:12
39F:推 dddai0118: 推 114.137.35.184 12/30 10:22
40F:推 Sky3631: 推Apink 推IU 101.12.102.163 12/30 10:25
41F:推 Panda1319: 是Apink啊啊啊啊~ 有點意外哈哈 203.71.94.31 12/30 10:29
42F:推 nn516turtle: 推EXO Apink AKMU TWICE IU!!! 101.12.102.152 12/30 10:34
43F:推 st5350268: 推SEVENTEEN 140.109.56.153 12/30 10:35
44F:推 fah06: 祝賀阿粉! 219.76.18.79 12/30 10:37
45F:推 flora0910: 推Apink 推樂童 36.235.118.58 12/30 10:39
46F:推 annis9001: 推Apink !! 115.82.229.138 12/30 10:42
47F:→ willy040609: 推阿粉 請夏!180.217.165.133 12/30 10:42
48F:推 Lovemylife: 推防彈TXT~推所有上榜的歌~ 49.216.0.194 12/30 10:46
49F:推 puppy5271: 推阿粉 59.124.167.151 12/30 10:49
50F:推 mon60819: 居然是嗯嗯欸! 117.19.202.93 12/30 10:50
51F:推 closeadoor: 推防彈推新飛! 117.19.229.205 12/30 10:53
52F:推 apt04191020: 推阿粉~~180.204.226.150 12/30 10:55
53F:推 ten0227: 推ATEEZ 27.247.96.154 12/30 11:02
54F:推 chris1102: 推Apink 123.194.10.30 12/30 11:22
55F:推 yang122: 推TXT 180.217.179.66 12/30 11:26
56F:推 yamyrose: 推防彈推(G)I-DLE推Heize! 1.200.35.244 12/30 11:28
57F:推 HuaeatHua: 推Straykids!!!!!!223.136.138.198 12/30 11:34
58F:推 manmani: 推CLC,期待快快回歸~ 14.199.217.22 12/30 11:34
59F:推 monica861103: 推EXO! NCT127! Red Velvet!223.139.255.131 12/30 11:38
60F:推 a130598050: bp那首聽久好像還可以 223.136.232.32 12/30 11:41
61F:推 JSHRMVK: 推TXT!推防彈! 27.246.200.72 12/30 11:47
62F:推 hsygchieh: 推TXT~101.136.215.212 12/30 11:49
63F:推 ningning0506: 推EXO NCT127 Red Velvet SuperM! 140.123.239.36 12/30 11:52
64F:推 YouliCo: 推TXT Heize 防彈! 39.9.222.21 12/30 11:54
65F:推 peipeipig: 推GOT7 You Calling My Name 223.140.4.94 12/30 11:57
66F:推 Snoopyyap: 推EXO NCT127 Red Velvet ! 115.82.245.9 12/30 11:57
67F:推 zxc93528: 推CLC 42.77.178.98 12/30 12:00
68F:推 EMILYJR225: 推TWICE Apink 110.26.200.105 12/30 12:01
69F:推 willy610: 推阿粉 39.8.68.145 12/30 12:03
70F:推 stella1013: 推防彈小詩 推TXT943 推Heize!!140.123.232.138 12/30 12:09
71F:推 cura4404: 大推EXO Obsession 和AKMU!!!! 一直re 223.139.144.53 12/30 12:10
72F:→ cura4404: ~ 223.139.144.53 12/30 12:10
73F:推 iamseanx: Gotta go Twit Fancy Boy with luv Psy 49.219.133.73 12/30 12:17
74F:→ iamseanx: cho Dalla Dalla 真的最常re!! 49.219.133.73 12/30 12:17
75F:→ iamseanx: 看到What you waiting for以為是zgirls 49.219.133.73 12/30 12:18
76F:推 yuesusu: Anda那首很好聽啊 59.102.220.102 12/30 12:19
我也覺得不錯,
但發歌時剛好遇上同公司藝人出事有點可惜。
不過至少她有上打歌節目,
後來YGX發歌的VIINI跟Blue.D都沒得上。
77F:推 lifelong: 推TWICE ! 219.68.244.166 12/30 12:24
78F:推 s48813024: 推EXO! 111.241.2.234 12/30 12:28
79F:推 mattmchang: 推賽口! 223.137.117.40 12/30 12:29
80F:推 peiyu0725: 推Apink IU~ 42.74.63.108 12/30 12:29
81F:推 pppan: 推全能IU 1.162.138.74 12/30 12:30
82F:推 gdpeiyun: 推防彈!推IU !推gotta go! Run away!Tw 219.71.126.70 12/30 12:31
83F:→ gdpeiyun: it! Lion!Rooftop!Dalla Dalla 這幾首真 219.71.126.70 12/30 12:31
84F:→ gdpeiyun: 的可以一直重複聽 219.71.126.70 12/30 12:31
85F:推 pig9731: 推CLC,希望2020年可以發展得更好 49.215.132.86 12/30 12:40
86F:推 eunji70041: Apink這首真的中毒 211.75.187.186 12/30 12:44
87F:→ ling843286: 推ITZY 180.204.204.3 12/30 12:45
88F:推 Khadijah: 很愛聽What You Waiting For 42.77.131.62 12/30 12:45
89F:推 wendysweet: 推AB6IX!!! 49.214.197.208 12/30 12:48
90F:推 enjoy31401: 推TWICE! 36.228.78.3 12/30 12:51
91F:推 asdf941016: 推GOT7 You Calling My Name!118.167.178.244 12/30 12:59
92F:推 c10016338: 推EXO AB6IX 17~~ 27.242.196.70 12/30 13:01
93F:推 vlychn: 推GOT7 59.124.25.160 12/30 13:05
94F:推 kkyyliao1: 推請夏 1.165.97.61 12/30 13:09
95F:推 mikiworldpea: 推GOT7!!! 101.15.216.234 12/30 13:10
96F:推 clairewang: 推IU~ 111.249.113.78 12/30 13:12
97F:推 spolight: 推Apink114.136.249.220 12/30 13:12
98F:推 wasd0012: 推Apink 223.137.30.182 12/30 13:13
99F:→ mo1010174: 推GOT7~ 211.75.233.174 12/30 13:16
100F:推 mercinana: 推TWICE 61.62.186.71 12/30 13:19
101F:推 steve91240: 推Apink 180.217.130.25 12/30 13:22
102F:推 wsylh: 推阿粉跟貝貝! 42.77.234.198 12/30 13:25
103F:推 Raymond6411: 推我們粉~114.136.234.160 12/30 13:34
104F:→ QAQb: 推 2. 3. 名 27.52.38.129 12/30 13:47
105F:推 lunasiao: Obsession真的是首錯過可惜的好歌 42.73.242.206 12/30 14:06
106F:推 iceafu: 推N.flying 跟AB6IX!放歌單循環好久 101.13.230.150 12/30 14:07
107F:推 shwd: 推TWICE 39.8.62.24 12/30 14:07
108F:推 JDFc: 推EXO Hwasa!!!101.137.241.235 12/30 14:24
109F:推 aitnu: 推推APINK!! 114.137.71.5 12/30 14:47
110F:推 Kristoflower: 推貝貝 Psycho 111.71.216.8 12/30 14:52
111F:推 summervalley: 推APINK跟所有認真工作的藝人們 42.74.95.144 12/30 15:00
112F:推 airbs69: 推ATEEZ,謝謝EDEN總是做出優秀的作品 49.215.136.178 12/30 15:12
113F:推 bomiii2414: 推apink~~ 180.217.238.39 12/30 15:32
114F:推 yvklej: Obsession越聽越上癮 111.71.63.130 12/30 15:41
115F:推 smonke: 他引言提到的那些是指今年一些 Kpop 潮流 36.230.76.41 12/30 15:54
116F:推 cp527ee: 推GOT7 36.225.0.238 12/30 15:55
117F:→ smonke: 以及偶像文化背後的議題~尤其韓國的女性 36.230.76.41 12/30 15:56
118F:→ smonke: 以及女偶像遭受到的一些特殊眼光 36.230.76.41 12/30 15:58
對呀,
但我不懂的是這25首跟這些議題的關聯在哪?
畢竟原文明確寫了他們是考量這些議題後選的
(Taking this all into account)。
舉例來說,
既然都知道Mina的心理健康問題,
TWICE的歌卻還是選了FANCY,
而不是相對勵志的Feel Special,
讓我有點覺得提那些事件只是為提而提而已。
119F:推 smonke: 另外~這25首是"picks"~應該沒有排名 @@a 36.230.76.41 12/30 16:01
120F:推 chengruby14: 推EXO!!223.139.208.234 12/30 16:04
121F:推 lf2ntr: 推EXO 這次超洗腦! 27.241.0.12 12/30 16:11
122F:推 RyanChang: 推Apink 推IU 114.136.27.111 12/30 16:33
123F:推 VanessaHazi: 推阿粉! 14.0.227.27 12/30 16:37
124F:推 drapee: 推GOT7~~~ 14.0.156.162 12/30 16:39
125F:推 jillmax: 推GOT7,Apink,150.117.194.137 12/30 16:45
※ 編輯: LesBleus (1.169.38.206 臺灣), 12/30/2019 17:01:48
126F:推 aaa90213: 推孩子們~~~~~111.253.113.151 12/30 16:53
127F:推 chloelin56: 推Stray Kids!!! 39.9.204.111 12/30 17:08
128F:→ chloelin56: 每一首歌曲下方都有寫入選原因 可以 39.9.204.111 12/30 17:09
129F:→ chloelin56: 參考一下? XDD 39.9.204.111 12/30 17:09
130F:推 yihsuan1122: Highway to heaven!!! 140.115.225.39 12/30 17:10
131F:推 UFO1010: 推華莎~ 1.34.189.49 12/30 17:25
132F:推 a2350221: 推EXO 42.74.254.152 12/30 17:38
133F:推 peiumi: 推EXO! 117.19.172.115 12/30 17:39
134F:推 hoonydooly: 推N.Flying 走吧屋塔房看星星吧啊啊 180.217.115.23 12/30 17:39
135F:→ hoonydooly: 啊 180.217.115.23 12/30 17:39
136F:推 smalllily: 推AB6IX~123.110.209.143 12/30 17:39
137F:推 general77413: 想另推N.Flying的Good Bam,雖然不 223.140.3.83 12/30 17:43
138F:→ general77413: 在25名單上。但這首真的有驚艷到我 223.140.3.83 12/30 17:43
139F:→ general77413: ! 223.140.3.83 12/30 17:43
140F:推 peggy0410: 推N.Flying ~入坑曲 39.12.199.129 12/30 17:47
141F:→ peggy0410: 屋塔房阿布機2020也要做出好聽的曲子 39.12.199.129 12/30 17:48
142F:→ peggy0410: 啊 39.12.199.129 12/30 17:48
143F:推 chc93022: 推Stray kids!!!114.136.139.104 12/30 17:53
144F:推 nyeong0224: 推EXO!! 180.204.172.46 12/30 17:53
146F:推 hahatoma: 推GOT7 42.74.21.178 12/30 18:14
147F:推 ryan414133: 推Apink~~~ 58.114.199.197 12/30 18:16
148F:推 joy27481913: 推EXO 114.24.73.132 12/30 18:36
149F:推 APB0829: 推(G)I-DLE 39.9.171.72 12/30 18:41
150F:推 DukeMonkey: 推阿粉123.195.250.172 12/30 19:00
151F:推 Hannim95: 推EXO~ 125.230.248.33 12/30 19:48
152F:推 shinyolive: 推GOT7! 39.11.226.131 12/30 19:58
153F:推 heinancy: 推GOT7 101.12.50.134 12/30 20:07
154F:推 GODISDOG: 推阿粉 110.26.232.241 12/30 20:10
155F:推 postero: 推GOT7 61.61.92.150 12/30 20:23
156F:推 rp20031219: 推(G)I-DLE 39.9.62.31 12/30 20:30
157F:推 winniebob264: 推(G)I-dole 101.9.215.55 12/30 20:47
158F:→ winniebob264: *(G)I-DLE 101.9.215.55 12/30 20:47
159F:推 darkdanger: 推知恩跟阿粉~~~223.138.189.206 12/30 20:51
160F:推 Leonieee: 推TWICE、請夏、貝貝還有IU! 42.77.150.42 12/30 20:53
161F:推 milkypine: 的確給fancy比較好,畢竟TWICE用這首歌 114.25.160.62 12/30 21:10
162F:→ milkypine: 展現了不同與以往的風格 114.25.160.62 12/30 21:10
163F:推 wingfun: 推GOT7 You Calling My Name 我的第一名 1.175.179.126 12/30 21:20
164F:推 lovelife9999: 推N.flying屋塔房 123.194.15.227 12/30 21:23
165F:推 maruko621: 推 EXO! 42.74.42.206 12/30 21:23
166F:推 ally0326: 推EXO 1.164.0.44 12/30 21:31
167F:推 ya75: 推GOT7!!! 124.218.49.8 12/30 21:59
168F:推 rungrung9631: 推GOT7-You Calling My Name101.136.231.227 12/30 22:16
169F:推 BbbbbTWang: 推Highway to heaven!!180.217.155.250 12/30 22:20
170F:推 weichen1030: 推 IU 貝貝 39.8.102.167 12/30 22:27
171F:推 Yvonnesc2317: 推SEVENTEEN!!! 42.76.212.117 12/30 22:34
172F:推 kioya: 推防彈 1.164.251.84 12/30 23:59
173F:推 yfl1024: 推GOT7 58.115.127.248 12/31 00:13
174F:推 meineepcy: 推EXO! 1.172.209.226 12/31 00:35
175F:推 sakota: 推(G)I-dle!223.137.107.148 12/31 01:05
176F:推 jywm43967: 推GOT7 You calling my name! 223.138.236.50 12/31 01:48
177F:推 crazy1009: 推貝貝 36.231.72.244 12/31 02:02
178F:推 g841018walk: Anda推推 111.83.131.205 12/31 04:14
179F:推 nubeans: 推AB6IX!!! 39.10.107.168 12/31 08:26
180F:→ turtleimage: 推EXO 貝貝 210.61.176.67 12/31 08:48
181F:推 catlee: 推貝貝!! 140.96.131.21 12/31 09:18
182F:推 kyfkyf: 推EXO 貝貝 36.231.151.135 12/31 10:04
183F:推 asserv1: 推IU 39.10.228.187 12/31 10:06
184F:推 BeiBeiBei: 推防彈 36.236.18.136 12/31 10:34
185F:推 Hannim95: 推EXO~180.217.219.147 12/31 11:15
186F:推 moLchA: 推EXO 27.247.70.176 12/31 13:08
187F:推 AKLOVER: 推EXO~真的會Obsession ~123.193.249.159 12/31 15:44
188F:推 yychcp: 推推GOT7 ~AKMU’ 114.136.183.47 12/31 15:45
189F:推 fresh888: Apink %%真的很好聽 101.9.198.104 12/31 18:44
190F:推 pida: 推Stray Kids113.183.234.158 12/31 21:48
191F:推 qaz2230: 推APINK!!!推%%!!! 59.126.108.177 01/01 02:23
192F:推 LilykoKun: EXO這張樂評真的反應很好!114.137.222.228 01/02 12:23
193F:推 Bettyyy: 推EXO! 163.27.8.81 01/02 17:38
194F:推 ancs99: 推EXO 223.138.246.95 01/02 18:07
195F:噓 PttGod: 原爆 218.161.55.187 01/13 23:02