: : If this was his own memory, why would Dumbledore have stored this memory : in a bottle rather than just pull it out his head the way he and Snape : had done before? : 如果這是他自己的記憶，為什麼鄧不利多要把這個記憶儲存在瓶子裡，而不只是將 : 他們從腦袋裡抽出，就像他和石內卜先前做的那樣？ : : Although I consider this unlikely, fans are pointing to this clue to : theorize that Dumbledore hasn't been Dumbledore for all of, or at least : a great portion of, the book, and that the Dumbledore we see is someone : using Polyjuice potion to pretend to be him, and therefore the real : Dumbledore isn't dead. Only a fake Dumbledore would have to have the : memory in a bottle, because only the real Dumbledore could take it directly : out of his head. : 雖然我認為這不可能是真的，但是書迷們指出這個線索去推論，鄧不利多根本不是 : 鄧不利多，或者至少絕大部分不是，(the book?) 我們看見的鄧不利多是某人利用 : 變身水來假裝是他，因此真正的鄧不利多並沒有死。只有假的鄧不利多必須從瓶子 : 裡得到記憶，因為真正的鄧不利多能夠直接從他的腦海中得到記憶。 : : But it's also just possible Dumbledore sealed the important memory in the : bottle for safe-keeping... : 但這也有可能只是鄧不利多封印重要的記憶在瓶子裡以便妥善保存．．． : 阿波佛˙鄧不利多，豬頭酒吧的酒保， 各位別忘了這個人！ 如果一找此發展， 那假的老鄧， 很有可能是他， 畢竟， 那是他的兄弟， 老鄧的習性、舉動，他應該很瞭， 又或許他會提示阿波佛 就像第四集瘋眼穆敵那樣的形式...變身水.... --

※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 220.129.21.16