作者marukoooo (that's all)
看板GMAT
標題[問題] PP2-SC-Q114
時間Sat Apr 26 13:17:45 2008
pp2-SC-Q114
While Hans Holbein the Younger is most often identified with his English
portraits, scholars have long
been recognizing him as a superb draftsman
and a remarkably versatile artist and who was fundamental in synthesizing
the novelties of the Italian Renaissance with the rational tradition of
Northern Europe.
(A) been recognizing him as a superb draftsman and a remarkably versatile
artist and who
(B) been recognizing him for being a superb draftsman and a remarkably
versatile artist and he
(C) recognized him as a superb draftsman and a remarkably versatile artist who
(D) recognized him as a superb draftsman and a remarkably versatile artist and
he
(E) recognized him for being a superb draftsman and a remarkably versatile
artist and who
我想請問（C）和（D）選項的區別～
商咖上說（D） 的 he 指代不清 (= artist? draftsman?)，(C) who = artist
但是我和讀書會同學討論覺得不管是he或who都是指Hans Holbein...懇請各位學長姐
給我們解答了...謝謝大家！
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 118.169.179.147
※ 編輯: marukoooo 來自: 118.169.179.147 (04/26 13:19)
※ 編輯: marukoooo 來自: 118.169.179.147 (04/26 13:19)
1F：推 yhubi:用代名詞最好代替主詞(scholars)但不行 因為單複數 變成代 04/26 13:24
2F：→ yhubi:recognize的受詞 且AND兩邊 感覺沒有很平衡= =" 小小意見~~ 04/26 13:26
3F：→ yhubi:所以我是選C 04/26 13:27
4F：推 REDAMAT:如果D，最後面的and前面應該有逗號 04/26 16:03
5F：→ REDAMAT:但如果降改也是改變原句意，原句的who後面是修飾artist 04/26 16:05
6F：→ REDAMAT:這樣改以後變成修飾"he"了，改變句意 04/26 16:06