※ 引述《faultfinder (faultfinder)》之銘言： : 回KMI ： : 5. The Achaemenid empire of Persia reached the Indus Valley in the fifth : century B.C., bringing (the Aramaic script with it, from which was derived : both northern and) southern India alphabets. : A. the Aramaic script with it, from which was derived both northern and : (was 單數動詞與 both .. and …alphabets多數主詞，主詞動詞數的不一致)刪除 : B. the Aramaic script with it, and from which deriving both the northern and : the : (which子句應該有動詞，但deriving是分詞，不是動詞) )刪除 : C. with it the Aramaic script, from which derive both the northern and the : D. with it the Aramaic script, from which derives both northern and : (同A：derives單數動詞與 both .. and …alphabets多數主詞，主詞動詞數的不一致) ) : 刪除 : E. with it the Aramaic script, and deriving from it both the northern and : (把沒畫線的bringing一起讀 => bringing with it the Aramaic script, and : deriving from it both the northern and southern India alphabets. : 兩個分詞片語的平行結構只需要用and連接，不需在and前給逗號。 : 就是說：Ving and Ving 才對，Ving , and Ving 不對)刪除 : (三個以上才要逗號，就是說：Ving ,Ving , and Ving) 不好意思，補充一下個人看法^^"， 我個人覺得如果只遵循「若僅兩樣並列，則and前不需要有逗點」規則。不一定可靠。 避竟有時候長句，或是含兩個不同分辭修飾的句子也可能出現and前逗號合理的情況， E要找錯誤，直接從1.)both後的the nothern and __southern缺the沒對稱， 或是2.)從文意看，主詞the Achaemenid empire會deriving出啥東西？說不通得之。 : P.S. : 老方也知道with it (兩個字)必須放在the Aramaic script(三個字)之前以免頭重腳輕， : 就如同答案C 裏的from which derive(動詞一個字) both the northern and the : southern India alphabets (主詞八個字)一樣也是主詞與動詞的位置對調，以免頭重腳 : 輕。不過，這些倒裝句型都是在用簡單規則找出答案之後再補充的。他認為：這些規則不 : 是很重要，因為OG例題及上千考古題幾乎都不需要用這規則就通通可解出正確答案。總之 : ，教英文文法規則的老師，教了幾十年，大概對英文文法規則的知識都差不多，只是常考 : 的是哪些，就有賴老師去歸納了，我們補習的不就是需要這些嘛！？ -- --

※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 122.121.37.175 ※ 編輯: SABC 來自: 122.121.37.175 (09/26 01:47)