作者PatsyGallagh ('cause we believe...)
看板Brit-pop
標題Re: 都沒人提起Oasis??
時間Thu Jun 2 11:46:16 2005
※ 引述《pulp (Before Sunrise)》之銘言：
: ※ 引述《Connick (Harry Connick,Jr)》之銘言：
: : 挺喜歡他們這次的新歌
: : 不過還是要等星期五專輯出來~!
: : 會有CD+DVD進口的
: to be honest. i quite like this one.
to be honest, I'm quite pissed off by your review...
(the following is my personal and extremely emotional feelings)
First, you sarcastically slagged Heathen Chemistry to the degree that
I consider it's an insult to any die-hard Oasis fan (which I am of course;)
Then, you're fuckin' reserved about your appreciation for D.B.T.T., which
I think it's pathetic and hypocritic.
You seem to have some issues with listening to Oasis' music,
or with the fact that you were once a Oasis fan before, but now apparently
not anymore. Maybe for you, especially these days, to admit that you like
some of their stuff, or even love them, is soemthing tasteless or disgraceful.
That's why you try so hard to make your favorable review look like a
"neutral" one: "Well, to MY surprise, I KIND OF like them, but as you can see,
I only like SOME of them, and they are NOT even from the Gallaghers!!!"
I perfectly know that you have every damn right to claim how you feel about
any piece of music. I guess I just feel sad that you're not one of us anymore.
Far and long gone you are. I repeat, you have every damn right to say whatever
you like about music, but once you start to sound like the god damn critic,
you've lost it--certain passion and insight that only belong to a fan.
Surely you don't care much about being a fan, do you? What you care about
is how to sound clever and tasteful, otherwise you wouldn't be so harsh
like a fuckin' spectator, throwing stones at bands, whether at Coldplay, Oasis
or any other bands.
I have every respect for you being a music lover and critic, but I loath
you being such a lousy music fan.
For the Gallaghers, especially Our Kid
Cheers!
Patsy "Gallagher"
--
Well I've seen things
That scarred and bruised and left me blind
So come on, listen along with me
I think you need a little company
--Verve, A NEW DECADE
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 218.175.25.230
1F：推 boxerspirit:非常非常的能感同身受~~ 61.64.84.115 06/02
2F：推 searoad:passion? oasis?? 140.112.7.59 06/02
3F：推 IanEnoch:everyone has the right to criticize... 140.115.200.20 06/02
4F：推 pulp:thanx for your comments. i accept them all. :) 24.193.220.9 06/02
5F：推 hedrich:若拿批評板友與批評樂團相比 我比較喜歡後者140.112.215.194 06/02
6F：推 lirqa:No offence, but you spoke like the brothers. 220.135.3.169 06/02
7F：推 S6000:die-hard fan是神聖不可侵犯的。 *筆記中* 211.22.22.6 06/02
8F：推 earthshake:不喜歡版大的評論 也不必人身攻擊吧! 140.113.92.167 06/02
9F：推 jojo5:你想得好多~~~ 203.70.52.119 06/02
10F：推 quiff:Fans沒那麼神聖，Critics也沒那麼下賤吧。反之亦同 59.121.203.117 06/02
11F：推 Miralles:坦誠面對自己的感受很重要，world peace! 61.217.107.141 06/02
12F：推 Lovetech:每張專輯都有人喜歡與不喜歡 看第三段開頭就懶 218.167.10.252 06/02
13F：→ Lovetech:得看全文了 標準的護航文 218.167.10.252 06/02
15F：→ Noel:pulp's review is consistent with Gallagher's in 140.112.23.165 06/02
16F：→ Noel:some way, be cool! 140.112.23.165 06/02
17F：推 S6000:音樂什麼都可談，碰上fans就沒得談。╮(╯_╰)╭ 221.169.18.15 06/02
18F：推 littlekix:我覺得Patsy版友不是在表達對專輯的不同意見， 211.74.220.181 06/02
19F：→ littlekix:而是在說"Passion"這東西 211.74.220.181 06/02
20F：推 tomx:可以翻譯成中文嗎?我看不懂 61.230.193.37 06/02
21F：推 inung:是的，這也許跟聽音樂的熱情有關，重點不在粉不粉될218.162.230.107 06/02
22F：→ inung:斯....218.162.230.107 06/02
23F：推 showerr:應該是指對某團有沒有熱情吧? 59.115.130.168 06/02
24F：→ jason917:音樂變難聽 fans講話也跟著難聽起來 59.104.162.161 06/03
25F：推 gotthebend:還好呀 也沒多難聽... 140.114.224.22 06/03
26F：推 xanthous:上兩樓的再用的就是很尖酸的critics218.175.150.178 06/03
27F：→ jason917:蠢140.117.110.226 06/03
28F：推 LadyEvil:呵呵 calm down men 聽音樂要開心阿 218.169.95.88 06/03
29F：推 xcl:no need to be so harsh... 220.134.141.19 06/04
30F：推 PaulDraper:dont blind yourselves with "passion". 24.87.5.199 06/06
31F：推 brightfish:好像在練閱讀 61.224.41.149 06/18