2006 中華盃決賽有兩個上訴案, 上訴隊對於上訴委員的組成很有意見, 強烈要求 更換委員, 結果委員會重組. 今年為了避免再發生類似糾紛, 橋協秘書處要我幫忙 找資料, 看洋人如何組成上訴委員會. 找美國橋協的相關規定當然是最方便的啦. 不過找完之後發現, 這些文件對於解決 去年臺灣公開組選拔賽那樣的糾紛, 好像不是很有幫助. XD ------------------------------------------------------------------------ 以下檔案是美國代表隊選拔賽的一般規定 (general conditions of contest): http://usbf.org/docs/COC/GCOC.pdf 第一頁的右側, 有美國橋協 (USBF, 有別於北美橋協 ACBL) 常設上訴委員會名單. 相關規定在檔案的第 21 頁, 也就是文件的第 18 頁: B. Jurisdiction of Committees and Regulations. By participating in a USBF Championship players agree to the following regulations and procedures. 上句意思是說: "賽員來參加選拔賽, 就表示認同以下的規定和程序." (很酷的一句話) 1. Tournament Committees Two committees will be available at any USBF Championship to hear director's rulings and appeals of assessed penalties, conduct disciplinary proceedings and similar matters. a) The Appeals Committee for the USBF Championship will appoint a Tournament Appeals Committee and an Appeals Administrator. 由上述常設上訴委員會, 指派該項競賽(選拔賽)的上訴委員會和上訴管理人. 下文說明上訴管理人組織委員會, 並使會議順利進行, 以及一些相關事項. 但並未說明委員會各委員的來源或背景. The Tournament Appeals Committee will handle matters usually referred to committees at tournaments (e.g., appeals of director's rulings, review of late play penalties, etc.). The Appeals Administrator shall organize appeals committees in such a way as to have a procedure as close to that which would exist if all of the members of the Committee hearing an appeal were at the tournament. Normally, this will involve a telephone conference call. If a telephone conference call is not feasible, the Appeals Administrator may use some other procedure, but shall attempt to use a procedure that allows interaction among the committee members. The members of the Tournament Appeals Committee will normally be listed on the front page of the Special Conditions of Contest for the USBF Championship, but the Appeals Administrator may appoint people not listed to a committee for a specific appeal, if it is not possible to form a committee from listed Tournament Appeals Committee members. The decision of a Tournament Appeals Committee shall be subject to appeal only on questions of law. Otherwise, the decision of the Committee is final. Any appeal on a question of law must be made in accordance with the provisions of the USBF Bylaws. 各組代表隊選拔賽都有一份特別規定 (special conditions of contest) http://usbf.org/docs/COC/usbc2006final.pdf 以上檔案是針對 2006 年美國公開組國家代表隊選拔賽. 在第一頁, 有 ITTC Appeals 和 USBC Appeals 名單, 人數並不多. 但有句附註: "Balance of Committee to be selected (將另選委員使得委員會平衡)" --

※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 218.164.136.2