作者Yjizz (Zz菊池z大谷z西舘zZ)
看板Baseball
標題[新聞] MLB - 道奇 2027 陣容難題 (非完整原標)
時間Tue Nov 17 10:57:15 2026
How Ohtani creates a roster-building puzzle for the Dodgers
L.A. has to figure out how pieces fit around its star DH
大谷翔平如何為道奇製造陣容建構難題
洛杉磯道奇隊必須設法圍繞這位明星指定打擊來完成陣容拼圖
Mike Petriello
https://www.mlb.com/news/how-ohtani-affects-dodgers-2027-roster
以下機翻(稍微挑一些怪語病) /
剛好 BA 又有躲人的相關文,搭在文末接續看。
The Dodgers won 100 games in 2026, along with their 13th NL West title in 14
years, and may still be taking the most talented roster in the game into the
winter, so there’s no need to pretend that the dynasty is over, or any
similar nonsense. They’ve long been very good, and will continue to be very
good.
道奇隊在 2026 年球季拿下 100 勝,並且在 14 年內第 13 次奪得國聯西區冠軍。他們進
入休賽季時,可能依然擁有全聯盟最具天賦的陣容,因此完全沒有必要假裝這個王朝已經
結束,或是相信其他類似的無稽之談。道奇隊長期以來都是一支非常出色的球隊,而且未
來仍將維持這樣的水準。
Still, the second half of the 2026 season was occasionally a slog. A
veteran-laden team looked old and slow, then got completely wiped out by the
more athletic Brewers in the National League Championship Series, which
certainly didn’t do much to dispel that notion.
儘管如此,2026 年球季下半段有時仍顯得相當艱辛。這支由大量資深球員組成的球隊,看
起來老態且缺乏速度,接著又在國聯冠軍賽遭到運動能力更出色的釀酒人隊徹底擊潰。這
樣的結果,顯然更無法消除外界對道奇隊老化、速度不足的印象。
That older, veteran team we just saw will simply get one additional year
older and more veteran this winter, as nearly all of the position player
group is set to return, save for backups Miguel Rojas (who retired) and Kiké
Hernández (who, we assume, will return for his usual one-year engagement
some months from now). Once Kyle Tucker celebrates his 30th birthday in
January, only one projected starter will be in his 20s next year, that being
26-year-old center fielder Andy Pages.
我們剛剛看到的這支老將陣容,到了今年冬天只會再老一歲,資深球員的比例也會進一步
提高。因為除了替補球員 Miguel Rojas(已經退休),以及 Kiké Hernández(我們推
測,他幾個月後仍會按照往常的模式,再簽下一年合約)之外,幾乎所有野手都預計會回
歸。等到 Kyle Tucker 在明年 1 月慶祝自己 30 歲生日之後,道奇隊預計明年擔任先發
的球員當中,將只剩下一人還在 20 多歲,那就是現年 26 歲的中外野手 Andy Pages。
That all leaves the Dodgers with an interesting and somewhat complicated
roster-building puzzle, as the quest to get younger runs into a veteran group
that is, for the most part, still performing at a very high level.
這些情況讓道奇隊面臨一道有趣、但也相當複雜的陣容建構難題。球隊希望讓陣容年輕化
,卻又必須面對一群大多數仍維持極高競技水準的資深球員。如何在兩者之間取得平衡,
將是道奇隊接下來必須思考的課題。
There's one additional complication, too. The Dodgers can’t use their
designated hitter spot as an occasional ‘half-day off’ spot, thanks to the
immovable presence of Shohei Ohtani.
此外,還有另一個讓事情更加複雜的因素。由於大谷翔平固定占據指定打擊的位置,道奇
隊無法像其他球隊一樣,偶爾利用 DH 安排其他球員擔任指定打擊,讓他們獲得所謂的「
半天休息」。
It’s certainly not that having maybe the most talented player we’ve ever
seen is a problem for which anyone should have sympathy. But it still adds
some complications to manager Dave Roberts’ daily lineups, and to the
offseason choices of the front office.
當然,擁有一位可能是我們有史以來看過最具天賦的球員,絕對不是什麼值得讓人同情的
問題。但這樣的情況,確實也為總教練 Dave Roberts 每天安排先發打線,以及球團管理
階層在休賽季做出陣容決策時,增添了一些複雜性。
Consider these three issues that Ohtani's presence helps create for the
Dodgers, as they try to look ahead to 2027.
當道奇隊開始為 2027 年球季做準備時,不妨來看看大谷翔平的存在,為球隊帶來的三個
相關問題。
We’ve almost never seen corner infielders this old.
我們幾乎從未見過年齡如此高的角落內野手組合。
First baseman Freddie Freeman, who turned 37 in September, is locked into
first base in the final year of his contract. Third baseman Max Muncy, who
turned 36 in August, is in the same spot at the other corner, also in the
final year of his deal. Each performed well enough in 2026. Muncy had one of
the better years of his career, while Freeman, if clearly past his peak, was
still an All-Star who hit 20% better than league average, with some defensive
value.
一壘手 Freddie Freeman 在今年 9 月滿 37 歲,合約也即將進入最後一年,他已經確定
將繼續鎮守一壘。三壘手 Max Muncy 則在今年 8 月滿 36 歲,情況與另一個內野角落的
Freeman 相同,同樣進入合約最後一年。兩人在 2026 年的表現都還算出色。Muncy 打出
了職業生涯表現較好的球季之一;至於 Freeman,雖然很明顯已經過了生涯巔峰期,但他
仍是一名全明星球員,打擊表現比聯盟平均水準高出 20%,而且在防守方面也仍具有一定
價值。
Neither is in danger of losing his starting job in 2027, and normally, that’
s a recipe for a day or two at DH per week for each, to get the proverbial “
half-day off.” But that’s obviously not really an option here, given the
presence of Ohtani, which means the Dodgers are set up to have something we
have rarely ever seen: two corner infielders, playing every day, at 36 years
old (or more).
兩人在 2027 年都沒有失去先發位置的危機。按照一般球隊的安排方式,這種情況通常代
表他們每週可以各自有一、兩天改任指定打擊(DH),藉此獲得大家所說的「半天休息」
。但顯然,道奇隊並沒有這樣的選項,因為大谷翔平已經占據了 DH 的位置。這也意味著
,道奇隊可能出現一種我們極少見到的情況:兩名鎮守內野角落位置的球員,都已經 36
歲或以上,卻仍然必須每天上場比賽。
After all, look at what they did in 2026. Freeman and Muncy (along with spot
appearances from Rojas and Hernández) just combined for 1,211 plate
appearances at the corners. It's the second-most playing time any team in the
Divisional Era (1969-present) has given to corner infielders 35 years or
older.
畢竟,看看他們在 2026 年的使用情況就知道了。Freeman 和 Muncy(另外還包括 Rojas
與 Hernández 偶爾支援的出賽),在一壘與三壘兩個位置合計累積了 1,211 個打席。
這是自分區制度時代(Divisional Era,1969 年至今)以來,任何一支球隊讓 35 歲或
以上的內野角落手累積的第二高打席數。
▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁
[ Most PA from 1B/3B at 35+ years old, since 1969 ]
YEAR TEAM PA
1985 Padres 1,343
2026 Dodgers 1,211
1984 Padres 1,194
2001 D-backs 1,142
2008 Orioles 1,112
2007 Orioles 1,079
1998 Padres 1,021
▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁
The 1984 Padres, obviously in a pre-DH era, had 35-year-old Steve Garvey and
39-year-old Graig Nettles, plus 37-year-old Kurt Bevacqua as a backup, and
they went to the World Series. The 2001 D-backs won the title, while playing
35-year-old Mark Grace at first, receiving throws from 37-year-old Matt
Williams. It's not how you'd draw it up, but it can be done.
1984 年的教士隊,當時顯然還處於沒有指定打擊制度的年代,陣中有 35 歲的 Steve
Garvey、39 歲的 Graig Nettles,以及擔任替補的 37 歲 Kurt Bevacqua,而那支球隊最
後還打進了世界大賽。2001 年的響尾蛇隊則是另一個例子。當年他們在一壘安排 35 歲的
Mark Grace,並由 37 歲的 Matt Williams 負責三壘防區,最終成功奪得世界大賽冠軍
。這並不是一般球隊在規劃陣容時會刻意採取的配置,但事實證明,這樣的安排並非不可
行。
This list also tells us what the 2027 Dodgers are up against, because the '85
Padres brought back the same trio, but older, so 1,343 plate appearances is
also the Divisional Era record for most corner infield PA given to players 36
or older. That '85 team won nine fewer games than the year before and
finished third in the NL West.
這份紀錄同時也揭示了道奇隊在 2027 年可能面臨的挑戰。因為 1985 年的教士隊讓前一
年相同的三名球員繼續留在陣中,只不過他們又老了一歲。因此,當年這三名球員合計獲
得的 1,343 個打席,也創下分區制度時代以來,36 歲或以上球員在一壘與三壘兩個角落
位置累積最多打席的紀錄。而那支 1985 年的教士隊,最終比前一年少拿了 9 勝,並且只
排名國聯西區第三名。
The Dodgers probably won't get there. But that it's even a topic to discuss
is because, like those 80s Padres, DH is not really available for their older
players, either. Even if it was, neither Freeman nor Muncy is necessarily the
ideal candidate on this roster to be taking any non-Ohtani days there. That’
s because ...
道奇隊大概不至於走到那種地步。但這件事之所以值得拿出來討論,是因為道奇隊和 1980
年代的教士隊一樣,並沒有真正能夠提供給年長球員使用的指定打擊位置。即使有這樣的
空間,Freeman 和 Muncy 也未必是目前這支道奇隊陣容中,最適合在大谷翔平沒有擔任
DH 的日子接替這個位置的人選。原因就在於……
Their best young hitter’s best position is “designated hitter.”
道奇隊最出色的年輕打者,最適合擔任的位置就是「指定打擊,DH)」。
That’s 21-year-old Josue De Paula, who came up late in the season and then
was carried on the postseason roster. We absolutely will not put too much
stock in him hitting .323/.500/.581 in 41 Major League plate appearances, but
there’s a reason he’s a consensus top-five prospect, and you could see that
even in such a small sample at the highest level. De Paula drew 11 walks
against only five strikeouts, with a top-five chase rate, and those are
things that are not only meaningful quickly, but also align quite well with
the scouting reports.
這名球員就是 21 歲的 Josue De Paula。他在球季後段升上大聯盟,隨後也被列入季後
賽球員名單。我們當然不會過度解讀他在大聯盟僅有 41 個打席的表現,當中繳出 .323
打擊率/.500 上壘率/.581 長打率的成績。不過,他之所以被各方評選一致認定為聯盟
前五名新秀,並不是沒有原因的,即使在最高層級的大聯盟,僅有這麼小的樣本數,也已
經能看出他的潛力。De Paula 在這 41 個打席中選到 11 次保送,僅吞下 5 次三振,而
且追打壞球的比率(Chase Rate)也名列前五名。這些數據不僅能夠在短時間內展現出球
員的打擊特質,也與球探報告對他的評價相當吻合。
The problem is that De Paula’s defensive game lags far behind his hitting,
with most reports considering his glove to be inferior to that of teammate
Teoscar Hernández – who himself is a poor defender. The Dodgers clearly did
not trust him to play the outfield, either. (“We view him as a DH,” said
president of baseball operations Andrew Friedman, speaking about the
right-now situation of late 2026.) While he’s expected to spend all winter
on his defense, it’s an open question as to how playable De Paula can get in
just one year.
問題在於,De Paula 的守備能力遠遠落後於他的打擊能力。大多數球探報告都認為,他
的手套守備能力甚至比隊友 Teoscar Hernández 還要差,而 Hernández 本身就是一名
守備能力不佳的球員。道奇隊顯然也不信任他能夠勝任外野守備。道奇隊棒球事務部總裁
(President of Baseball Operations)Andrew Friedman 在談到 2026 年球季後段當時
的情況時,曾表示:「我們將他視為一名指定打擊。」雖然預計 De Paula 整個休賽季都
會把重心放在改善守備上,但問題是,僅僅透過一個休賽季的訓練,他究竟能將自己的守
備能力提升到什麼程度,仍然存在很大的疑問。
De Paula has drawn comparisons to Astros DH and AL MVP Yordan Alvarez, in
ways both good (the elite offensive approach and command of the strike zone)
and poor (you ideally never want either to wear a glove). If De Paula can get
the glove to be merely competent, then he’s likely to play left field every
day and potentially see Hernández depart via trade. But if he can’t, then
there may not be a way to keep him on the roster right now, despite a bat
that is clearly Major League ready immediately.
De Paula 經常被拿來與太空人隊的指定打擊、也是美聯 MVP 的 Yordan Alvarez 相提並
論。這種比較有正面的一面,例如兩人都擁有頂尖的打擊策略,以及對好球帶的出色掌握
能力;但也有負面的一面,那就是理想情況下,你絕對不希望這兩名球員中的任何一人需
要戴上手套負責守備。如果 De Paula 能夠將守備能力提升到至少合格的水準,那麼他很
可能每天都能擔任左外野手,而 Hernández 也可能因此透過交易離隊。但如果 De Paula
無法改善守備,那麼即使他的打擊能力顯然已經具備立即在大聯盟出賽的水準,道奇隊目
前仍可能找不到適合將他留在大聯盟名單中的方式。
Their other best young hitter isn’t healthy enough to field.
道奇隊另一位最出色的年輕打者,目前的健康狀況還不足以負責守備。
That’s Dalton Rushing, a catcher who turns 26 in February, and showed
himself to have a quality left-handed bat in 2026, posting a 115 OPS+ in
part-time play. He’s already blocked behind the plate by Will Smith, one of
baseball’s best all-around backstops, and that’s another situation where
the usual “get him a start at DH each week” would help, if it were
available. But there’s a larger issue here, too: Rushing, at least for
months to come, is unlikely to be healthy enough to get behind the plate.
這名球員就是捕手 Dalton Rushing,他將在明年 2 月滿 26 歲。2026 年球季,他展現了
相當不錯的左打能力,即使只是以部分時間出賽的方式,仍繳出 115 的 OPS+。不過,他
在捕手位置上已經被 Will Smith 擋住了先發機會。Will Smith 是大聯盟最出色、攻守俱
佳的捕手之一。這又是另一種適合透過每週安排一次指定打擊先發,讓球員獲得更多出賽
機會的情況,前提當然是球隊有這樣的空間。但這裡還存在一個更大的問題:至少在接下
來幾個月內,Rushing 的身體狀況恐怕還不足以讓他回到捕手位置上負責守備。
In early August, Rushing injured his throwing elbow, costing him weeks on the
injured list. He returned in September as a hitter only, but lasted just five
days before aggravating the elbow, which knocked him out for the playoffs and
eventually led to surgery in October. “His timeline to return to catching is
nine months,” wrote Dodgers beat reporter Sonja Chen on Oct. 21, “and he is
expected back as a hitter well before then.”
8 月初,Rushing 的傳球手肘受傷,因此在傷兵名單上待了好幾個星期。他在 9 月以純打
者的身分回歸,但只過了五天,手肘傷勢就再次惡化,不僅讓他無法參加季後賽,最終也
導致他在 10 月接受手術。道奇隊隨隊記者 Sonja Chen 在 10 月 21 日撰文指出:「他
預計需要九個月才能重新回到捕手位置,而在那之前,他就有望先以打者的身分回歸。」
Nine months would put him around the All-Star break before he’s able to get
behind the plate, but he’d be available to hit long before that. Another
example of, “it sure would be great to let him DH at least part of the time.
” The Dodgers will either have to spend a roster spot on a pinch-hitter, or
otherwise send Rushing back to Triple-A until he’s healthy enough to catch.
如果需要九個月才能重新擔任捕手,代表 Rushing 大概要等到明年全明星賽前後,才能重
新回到本壘後方負責守備。但在那之前,他就有機會先恢復打擊能力並投入比賽。這又是
一個很好的例子,說明「如果能夠讓他至少有部分時間擔任指定打擊,那就太好了」。道
奇隊將面臨兩種選擇:要不然就在球員名單中保留一個位置給代打,要不然就只能先將
Rushing 下放至 3A ,直到他的健康狀況恢復到足以重新擔任捕手為止。
∞∞五名球員都需要 DH,但這個位置只有一個∞∞
So, what we’re left with is that the Dodgers have five players (Freeman,
Muncy, Rushing, De Paula, and Hernández) who really should be getting some
or much of their time at designated hitter in 2027, but none of them can
expect any significant time there because DH is simply spoken for and
unavailable, as long as Ohtani is healthy enough to be in the lineup.
因此,現在的情況就是,道奇隊陣中有五名球員──Freeman、Muncy、Rushing、De Paula
和 Hernández──在 2027 年球季其實都應該有部分、甚至相當多的出賽時間安排在指
定打擊位置。但這五個人當中,沒有任何一個人能夠期待自己獲得大量的 DH 出賽機會。
原因很簡單,只要大谷翔平的健康狀況允許他繼續排入先發打線,指定打擊這個位置就已
經有人占據,其他球員根本沒有使用的空間。
It's not the worst problem to have, obviously. This only happens since the
Dodgers have Ohtani's bat -- once again expected to be one of baseballs best
-- in the lineup. But it is a problem nonetheless.
顯然,這並不是最糟糕的一種問題。畢竟,會出現這樣的情況,完全是因為道奇隊的打線
中擁有大谷翔平的棒子,而他的打擊火力,再一次被預期將名列全大聯盟頂尖之列。但即
使如此,這終究仍然是一個必須面對的問題。
So what can be done about it?
那麼,究竟有什麼辦法可以解決這個問題?
For 2027, barring a wildly unexpected trade of a core piece, there are really
only two realistic options. The first is obviously to put De Paula in left
field, if the Dodgers trust him enough defensively to give that a shot.
展望 2027 年,除非球隊出乎意料地交易掉核心主力,否則實際上只有兩個可行的選項。
第一個選項顯然是讓 De Paula 守左外野,前提是道奇隊在防守方面足夠信任他,願意給
他這樣的機會。
The second is to have Tommy Edman (who will be 32 in May) shift from being
the regular starter at second base to more of the multi-positional role he
filled earlier in his career and which he may be better suited to handle at
this point. Maybe that opens up the keystone for 25-year-old Alex Freeland,
though more likely he’s taking over Rojas’ backup infielder spot, and a new
second baseman comes from outside the organization. That could be either via
free agency, which wouldn’t likely add youth, or from dealing out of the team
’s excess of young outfield prospects for a younger infielder.
第二個選項,是讓 Tommy Edman(他將在明年 5 月滿 32 歲)從固定擔任先發二壘手,
轉而回到他職業生涯早期所扮演的多守位角色。以他目前的狀況來看,或許這樣的安排反
而更適合他。這或許能為 25 歲的 Alex Freeland 騰出二壘的位置。不過,更有可能的情
況是,Alex Freeland 接替 Rojas,成為球隊的替補內野手,而道奇隊則從組織外尋找一
名新的二壘手。引進新二壘手的方式可能有兩種:透過自由球員市場簽約,但這種方式恐
怕無法讓球隊的年齡結構變得更年輕;或者利用球隊目前過剩的年輕外野手新秀作為交易
籌碼,換來一名年輕內野手。
Really, though, this is a problem that comes into focus after 2027, not
before it. Not that Ohtani is going anywhere, but Freeman’s contract will be
up, and so will Muncy’s, and Hernández’s as well. That doesn’t mean
neither infielder can return, but at least it some options will be available.
Plus, Mookie Betts will be heading into his age-36 season and potentially isn
’t an everyday shortstop any longer, with a likely slide over to second base
in his future at some point.
不過,嚴格來說,這個問題真正浮上檯面,應該是在 2027 年之後,而不是之前。這並不
是說大谷翔平會離開球隊,而是 Freeman 的合約屆時將到期,Muncy 和 Hernández 的合
約也一樣。這並不代表這兩名內野手都不會續留,但至少球隊屆時將擁有一些不同的選擇
。此外,Mookie Betts 屆時將進入 36 歲球季,屆時他可能已經不再適合每天擔任先發游
擊手。未來某個時間點,他很可能會轉往二壘發展。
None of this is the end of the Dodgers’ run of success. Far from it, really.
But it’s feeling a little like an inflection point, just like how the core
in the earlier part of this successful run was more about Justin Turner, Cody
Bellinger, Corey Seager, Clayton Kershaw and Kenley Jansen before that group
moved on and was replaced by the current one. It’ll happen again, too, as
the baton is passed to De Paula, Mike Sirota, Eduardo Quintero and other
prospects from MLB Pipeline's top-ranked farm system.
這些問題都不代表道奇隊的成功時代即將結束。事實上,距離那一天還很遙遠。不過,球
隊目前的確有些來到了一個轉折點的感覺。就像道奇隊這段成功時期的早期,核心陣容主
要由 Justin Turner、Cody Bellinger、Corey Seager、Clayton Kershaw 和 Kenley
Jansen 等人組成;後來這批球員逐漸離隊,才由目前這一代核心陣容接手。未來也會再次
出現相同的世代交替。球隊的接力棒將逐漸交到 De Paula、Mike Sirota、Eduardo
Quintero,以及其他來自 MLB Pipeline 全大聯盟排名第一農場體系的潛力新秀手中。
It’s not all about youth, because the youngest teams tend to be rebuilding
clubs with few established veterans, and older teams like the Dodgers and
Phillies have superstars who have been doing this for a long time. But as the
game gets younger and faster and more athletic, it’s not a topic that can be
overlooked, either.
球隊的競爭力並不完全取決於年輕化。因為陣容最年輕的球隊,往往是正處於重建階段、
缺乏成熟資深球員的隊伍;而像道奇隊和費城人隊這類平均年齡較高的球隊,則擁有許多
已經在大聯盟征戰多年、實力出眾的超級球星。然而,隨著棒球比賽的發展,球員逐漸年
輕化,速度更快、運動能力也更出色,因此球隊年齡結構的議題,同樣不容忽視。
The Dodgers have to find a way to make this work. The evolving game demands
it.
道奇隊必須設法找到解決之道,讓這套陣容能夠順利運作。因為棒球比賽不斷演變的趨勢
,已經讓這件事成為球隊不得不面對的課題。
-Mike Petriello is a stats analyst for MLB.com, focusing on Statcast and
Baseball Savant, and is also a contributor to MLB Network.*
-Mike Petriello 是 MLB.com 的數據分析師,主要負責 Statcast 與 Baseball
Savant 相關分析,同時也是 MLB Network 的撰稿人。
▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁
Baseball America 文章 -- LAD道奇 新秀 TOP10 (付費)
Josue De Paula 位列第一
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/HXQTwWQXEAAXYdM.jpg
https://x.com/BaseballAmerica/status/2122343399219249357
LAD道奇 農場各天賦(tool)最佳球員
Best Hitter: Josue De Paula
Best Power Hitter: Emil Morales
Best Strike-Zone Discipline: Josue De Paula
Fastest Baserunner: Kendall George
Best Athlete: Jaron Elkins
Best Fastball: Christian Zazueta
Best Curveball: Zach Root
Best Slider: Cam Leiter
Best Changeup: Christian Zazueta
Best Control: Christian Zazueta
Best Defensive Catcher: Eduardo Rojas
Best Defensive Infielder: Noah Miller
Best Infield Arm: Chase Harlan
Best Defensive Outfielder: Eduardo Quintero
Best Outfield Arm: Abel Lorenzo
https://x.com/BaseballAmerica/status/2122412559454130609
至 2030 年,控制權下最佳道奇隊球員
Catcher: Will Smith (35)
First Base: Dalton Rushing (29)
Second Base: Charles Davalan (26)
Third Base: Emil Morales (23)
Shortstop: Mookie Betts (37)
Left Field: Josue De Paula (25)
Center Field: Eduardo Quintero (24)
Right Field: Andy Pages (29)
DH: Shohei Ohtani (35)
No. 1 Starter: Yoshinobu Yamamoto (31)
No. 2 Starter: Christian Zazueta (25)
No. 3 Starter: Roki Sasaki (28)
No. 4 Starter: Blake Snell (37)
No. 5 Starter: Justin Wrobleski (29)
Closer: Edgardo Henriquez (28)
The best Dodgers under team control through 2030
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/HXQwJGOWoAAHw45.jpg
https://x.com/BaseballAmerica/status/2122374261566251044
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 49.217.49.157 (臺灣)
※ 文章網址: https://webptt.com/m.aspx?n=bbs/Baseball/M.1794884239.A.5E8.html
1F:推 OhtaniHR: 能這個戰績肯定陣容不是大問題,重點就是季後賽熄火 11/17 11:05
2F:→ Yjizz: BA有提到 洛杉磯需要交易來提供新秀的 MLB 位置 11/17 11:08
3F:→ Yjizz: BA's J.J. Cooper 一些看法和 Mike Petriello 一樣Y 11/17 11:09
4F:→ Yjizz: 位置卡住沒地方練 11/17 11:09
5F:推 Werth: 擠不下的新秀跟國民交易腿砲SS 退化的木屐回去站二壘 11/17 11:20
6F:→ darren2586: 卡DH確實是該拿出成績,前幾年不會有人說話,今年打不 11/17 11:24
7F:→ darren2586: 好被質疑也合理,但誰也不知道明年會不會復活 11/17 11:24
8F:推 tsaumond: 打不好是在說大谷嗎?他今年那樣還是OPS國聯第三耶 11/17 11:29
9F:推 www10618: 先把左外野那咖換掉吧 看了就倒彈 11/17 11:34
10F:推 lookers: 道奇問題蠻無解的都卡死了 11/17 11:39
11F:→ joeduck: 柯敬賢接棒 11/17 11:44
12F:→ tsaumond: 現在真的就是期待寶拉防守能拉到至少堪用,然後老師交易 11/17 11:49
13F:推 shinchen: 主陣明星球員長約走到後期就會比較頭痛 躲人農場不缺人 11/17 11:55
14F:→ shinchen: 但被卡住名單很難上來 11/17 11:56
15F:→ bigyo: 很簡單啊,上述幾位就是打不贏健康的大谷,沒位置只能說誰 11/17 12:02
16F:→ bigyo: 叫你守位不夠多或守備不夠好, 11/17 12:02
17F:→ Diaw0803: 哪有什麼問題 一樣是宇宙躲 11/17 12:25
※ 編輯: Yjizz (49.217.49.157 臺灣), 11/17/2026 12:40:37
18F:推 TopGun2: 通篇每段結尾結論:大谷佔據DH,讓其他人無法獲得打數。 11/17 12:49
19F:→ TopGun2: 廢話,大谷過往DH成績(除了受傷),道奇哪一位火力能夠幹 11/17 12:51
20F:→ TopGun2: 掉大谷? 11/17 12:51
21F:推 xpon: 看來只能交易掉大谷騰出DH了(咦? 11/17 13:19
22F:推 TopGun2: 道奇要做的是,找其他位置有火力的新血補35-37歲的位置。 11/17 13:39
23F:→ TopGun2: 怎麼一直想到當打之年的大谷DH,卡到這些資深球員打DH的 11/17 13:39
24F:→ TopGun2: 機會咧 11/17 13:39
25F:推 TopGun2: 所以現在是大谷36歲,Freeman, Maxcy 32歲? 11/17 13:42
26F:推 polanco: 除了左外野的幾個位置要換血沒你想的這麼容易 11/17 14:05
27F:推 shengping: 要換血又要維持競爭力,沒這麼容易,嘴巴講一講就有 11/17 14:09
28F:推 TopGun2: 本來就要有取捨,老人輪休給新血練不是最直接的方式嗎。 11/17 14:38
29F:→ TopGun2: 一天到晚討論要大谷讓出DH,給大家輪打..... 11/17 14:38
30F:推 cchmaddux: 大谷投球的場次不上場打擊 這樣就可以空出20多場DH了 11/17 17:04
31F:推 TopGun2: 樓上這也是種方案 11/17 17:53
32F:推 duke0529: 找內野工具人讓自由人跟芒西可以輪流休息不就好了,要休 11/17 18:09
33F:→ duke0529: 就休整場硬要去打個DH幹嘛 11/17 18:09
34F:→ william80730: 其實要輪休就輪休啊 何必執著輪流打DH 油彈 洗碗伯D 11/17 19:02
35F:→ william80730: 也卡著DH不就是因為他們夠強 11/17 19:07