作者SDUM (Roger)
看板AntiVirus
標題[情報] 2011/10/7 matousec 防火牆排名
時間Sun Oct 9 13:02:40 2011
官方網站：
http://www.matousec.com/projects/proactive-security-challenge/results.php
結果：
1.Comodo Internet Security 5.3.176757.1236 FREE 100%
2.Online Solutions Security Suite 1.5.14905.0 99%
3.Privatefirewall 7.0.25.4 FREE 98%
4.Outpost Security Suite Free 7.0.4.3418.520.1245.401 FREE 97%
4.Outpost Security Suite Pro 7.5.1.3791.596.1681 97%
4.BitDefender Internet Security 2011 14.0.30.357 97%
7.Kaspersky Internet Security 2012 12.0.0.374 93%
8.Malware Defender 2.7.3.0002 FREE 91%
9.PC Tools Internet Security 2011 8.0.0.655 90%
10.Jetico Personal Firewall 2.1.0.10.2451 88%
11.ZoneAlarm Extreme Security 2012 10.0.250.000 72%
12.Rising Internet Security 2011 23.00.41.42 34%
13.CA Internet Security Suite Plus 2011 7.0.0.279 30%
14.Norton Internet Security 2012 19.1.1.3 20%
15.avast! Internet Security 6.0.1000 15%
16.Dr.Web Security Space Pro 6.0.2.07290 14%
17.F-Secure Internet Security 2011 10.51.106 9%
17.Trend Micro Internet Security Pro 2010 17.50.1647.0000 9%
19.FortKnox Personal Firewall 6.0.205.0 7%
19.ZoneAlarm Free Firewall 9.2.076.000 FREE 7%
21.ESET Smart Security 4.2.64.12 6%
22.AVG Internet Security 2011 10.0.1153 3%
22.Avira Premium Security Suite 10.0.0.608 3%
22.Look 'n' Stop 2.07 3%
22.Sunbelt Personal Firewall 4.6.1861.0 3%
26.G Data InternetSecurity 2011 21.1.1.0 2%
26.McAfee Internet Security 2011 11.5.141 2%
26.Panda Internet Security 2011 16.00.00 2%
26.TrustPort Internet Security 2011 11.0.0.4584 2%
------------------------------------------
新增結果：
CA Internet Security Suite Plus 2011 7.0.0.279
Norton Internet Security 2012 19.1.1.3
Privatefirewall 7.0.25.4
官網評論：
It is natural that new versions of the products score higher than the older
ones. This time, however, only Privatefirewall and CA Internet Security Suite
Plus improved their score.
Norton Internet Security felt down from 40% score to 20 %. Although we see
that some new techniques are handled by Norton Internet Security, other
techniques that were handled in the 2011 version are not handled anymore.
CA Internet Security Suite Plus went the opposite way. From 12% score it
jumped up to 30 %, which is still not a good result, but it definitely is a
better one and a possible promise for its future versions.
The best product from today's testing is thus the new Privatefirewall. Its
score has been improved by 7 % to the Excellent, and close to perfect, 98 %.
Good job.
其他：
Private firewall 進步很多。
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 114.43.215.197
1F：推 asiasssh:PC Tools被擠到下面去了 不過還是10+等級 =w= 10/09 13:12
2F：→ SDUM:pc tools好像退流行了，坐等 NOD V5 的成績(≧<>≦) 10/09 13:17
3F：推 chromeOS: 10/09 13:21
4F：推 pttdog:22.Avira Premium Security Suite 10.0.0.608 3% 有裝=沒裝 10/09 18:32
5F：推 pipiboy1980:支那的瑞星好厲害有上榜 比知名品牌還強 10/09 20:26
6F：→ t0042380:11→12有嚴重斷層耶… 10/10 11:56
7F：推 Avenger:Outpost用免費版的就好 XD 10/10 14:21
8F：推 bestpika:懂這站的測試就知道為什麼有些防毒軟體的fw分數為什麼低 10/11 12:06
9F：→ sicao:請樓上的可以說明一下嗎 10/14 21:49
10F：推 asiasssh:這個站就是在測HIPS 所以純防火牆分數差是正常的 10/17 11:54
11F：→ asiasssh:一些套裝軟體都有內建HIPS 所以分數高正常 10/17 11:54