高中英文不管是哪个版本 在讲分词构句上 都出现很多问题 教师手册上写的是错的(或是应该说是 外师认为不对的) (有请教过学校外师) 请问这种情况下 是要照教师手册上写的教还是外师认可的教? 有经验的老师会如何做呢? EX: 三民版 Book3 Lesson 2 Q1 Q2 from Part 3 Q1: Part 3 Second sentence. 手册说是1 但外师跟我都认为是2 Original: Chained to a fire hydrant and beaten badly, this dog howled miserably while the man laughed loudly. Which of the following sentence(s) equal to or carry the same meaning as the original sentence? 1. (cause and effect relationship) original = Because/As/Since this dog was chained to a fire hydrant and beaten badly, this dog howled miserably while the man laughed loudly. 2. (simply give additional or extra information about the dog) original = This dog, (that was) chained to a fire hydrant and beaten badly, howled miserably while the man laughed loudly. Q2: 三三民版 Book 3 Lesson 2 Part 3 Fifth sentence Original: Carrying out human flesh search, some netizens started to track down this man. 外师跟我都认为是 1 但手册 根本就没写 手册上的翻译写 开始人肉搜寻 1. Method used By is omitted, “(by) carrying out …” indicates the method that used by netizens to track down this man. Original = By carrying out human flesh search, some netizens started to track down this man. 2. Time sequence After is omitted, “(After) carrying out …” indicates the time when netizens started to track down this man; netizens started tracking after carrying out human flesh Original = After carrying out human flesh search, some netizens started to track down this man. 3. Additional/Extra information “Carrying out …” is from “(who) carries out human flesh search, “ which gives extra information about about the netizens and is moved the beginning of the original sentence Original = Some netizens, who carries out human flesh search, started to track down this man. Q3 三民 Book 3 Lesson 2 Part 5 This one I am not sure. It seems to be both are acceptable. I am a bit confused on this one. 手册说是1 但是 我跟外师都认为是2 Original: Even worse, a few may become a violent cybermob, taking advantage of their freedom of speech to pursue their so-called “justice." 1. Original = Eveb worse, a few may become a violent cybermob, and they may take advantage of their freedom of speech to pursue their so-called “ justice." 2. Original = Even worse, a few may become a violent cybermob, who take advantage of their freedom of speech to pursue their so-called “justice." --

※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc), 来自: 223.139.231.171 ※ 文章网址: https://webptt.com/cn.aspx?n=bbs/teaching/M.1441885688.A.566.html