作者chuckz (月亮上的发条猫)
看板TeachEnglish
标题Re: [国中] 英文作文
时间Thu Mar 22 20:37:19 2012
※ 引述《cathywang (云淡风轻)》之铭言:
: 我家小朋友写的 可以请版上老师帮忙看一下吗
: 谢谢
: --------------------------------------------------------------------
: Learning English has been nearly six years, but I learned
整篇都有中式英文的问题, 此句but前後主词最好统一, 文法上会扣分.
: not too fast. When I was in elementary school, I was not very
改成I am a slow learner in English.
: concentrate on this. Until the summer before entering junior
此字改成concentrated.
: high school, I was transferred GEPT class. Suddenly, I had a
改成was transferred to a class for GEPT.
: big pressure. At that time, my teacher made us read novels
us 改成me 对应前面的my
: and speak them. It was a big change for learning English. I
for me to learn English
: remembered that my first novel was "Treasure Island." Reading
the first novel I read was Treasure Island.
: this novel let me suffer pain. I needed to spend a lot of time
made me suffer.
: looking up new words, translating sentences, and understanding
translating the sentences
: the meaning. For me, it's chapfallen. Fortunately, my teacher
it was 作文中通常不建议用缩写
: has been encouraging me and let me continue to make
letting 对应and前面的现在完成进行式
: breakthroughs. After one month, I finished it. That was a
One month later,
: memorable experience. Quite a sense of accomplishment.
加入I got 不然此句不完全(句子由主词和动词组成)
总评: 如果是20分作文, 长度内容10分得5分, 文法五分得2分, 用字遣词5分得2分,
共9分. 从文章判断其写作问题大致有下列几点:
1. 中式英文问题, 有些句子看得懂, 但事实上就不是这样表达,
如 a slow learner.
2. 被动式用的不正确或不清楚何时使用, 如 be transferred to.
3. 使用连接词and或but时忽略前後主词及时态要对应的问题.
4. 动词时态掌控不错, 国中生会使用现在完成进行式还蛮让我讶异的,
虽然後面and连接的时态错了(let 要改成lets 或 letting)
建议: 1. 国文作文可能要加强, 这篇很显然是用中文翻成英文後的结果, 但老实讲
翻成中文看也可以感觉出其结构松散的问题. 像这麽短的文章都无法从
中心主题严密发展, 分数不会高.
2. 文章中有些动词用法掌控不是很好, 应该是说不会用还是查字典只看中文
意思? 实务教学上, 我们都会建议学生用基础单字搭配必用句型, 以保险
的作法去写, 避免用错被扣分的情况.
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 122.121.171.140
※ 编辑: chuckz 来自: 122.121.171.140 (03/22 20:38)
1F:推 jo668790:其实chapfallen是用来形容人的,而非事件。 04/06 14:09
2F:→ jo668790:故I felt/was chapfallen较为恰当。 04/06 14:10
3F:→ jo668790:此外,使用主动也较自然。 04/06 14:19