作者newborngirl (苹果脸)
看板TeachEnglish
标题[问题] 高二英文选择题
时间Thu Nov 17 18:22:08 2011
上次帮家教学生上课解题
学生问了一题我也答不出来原因的题目
因此很不好意思来请教各位有经验的朋友们 :)
题目如下:
She would not go with us, ________________________.
A) if it were not your suggestion
B) was it for your suggestion
C) were it not for your suggestion
D) had it not been for your suggestion
正确答案为C,但学生问A为什麽不行
要如何解释答案为什麽选C
还有A为什麽是错的呢?
麻烦大家了,谢谢 :]
--
▼/◤ * ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* * ﹡* ﹡◢∕"
▇▇◣ 。 . 【我是苹果女孩。 . " ' . 。 . 。 . ▲
● ▎ ○ 。 . I'm 爱波费斯。】 ˙ ○ " ▉ ◢◢
▇ ▏ . . " ○ . . . ' ▋ ▎●
█◤ . ˙ ' 。 " ' . . NewBornGirl ▊■ ""_
_ ◤▼* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* * ﹡*▼◣▎人
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 112.104.159.237
1F:推 lovemelissa:if it were not "for" your suggestion.. 11/17 18:25
2F:推 yujr:推楼上L大 确实是少了"for" 11/17 18:27
谢谢楼上两位的回答
那请问要如何解释答案为什麽选C呢 ?
还有请问少了"for",差别在哪里呢? 谢谢 :)
※ 编辑: newborngirl 来自: 112.104.159.237 (11/17 18:34)
3F:推 chuckz:if it were not for N=Were it not for N 高中句型 11/17 19:39
4F:→ chuckz:少了for意思差很多 仔细想一下就会了解了 11/17 19:41
5F:推 Polar:要不是“因为”你的建议 所以要有for 11/17 20:19
6F:→ newborngirl:谢谢大家的详细说明 :) 11/18 01:09
7F:推 l10nel:你看出来A少了for吗?少了for意思就不对了 11/18 05:34
8F:推 l10nel:抱歉一时没看到前面推文:) 11/18 05:39
9F:推 paulchi:那...有人能有A选项造出句子吗? ;-) 11/19 12:58
10F:→ paulchi: 用 11/19 12:59
11F:推 zofloya:if it were not your suggestion, then what the hell 11/19 16:11
12F:→ zofloya:would it be? 11/19 16:11
13F:推 sweeties:哈哈哈哈哈!! 楼上害我笑惨了!! 11/19 22:35
14F:推 paulchi:屌~~ 11/20 00:00