关说的定义在这里 「公务员廉政伦理规范」第二点第（五）款规定定义为：「指 其内容涉及本机关（构）或所属机关（构）业务具体事项之决定、执行或不执行，且 因该事项之决定、执行或不执行致有违法或不当而影响特定权利义务之虞。」 至於你提的案例 我实在看不懂你的重点在哪里? 是说布希政府任意解任检察官? 还是说国会议员施压? 这跟本案有啥关系? ※ 引述《guare (瓜籽)》之铭言： : 何谓关说？或者说如何处理？ : ※ 引述《hifree (hifree)》之铭言： : : 其实这个案子刚好可以检视一下何谓妨碍司法公正的关说 : : 在国外立法例下 : : 妨碍司法公正的正式定义为「具有妨碍司法公正倾向及意图的作为、一连串的作为 : : 或行为」（an act, a series of acts, or conduct which has the tendency and : : is intended to pervert the course of justice）具体表现在任何一种下列的行为： : : 中止刑事检控以换取报酬 : : 提出虚假的指控 : : 向调查人员提供虚假的陈述 : : 刻意协助他人逃避追捕 : : 恐吓、胁迫或骚扰证人 : : 证人故意不出席聆讯，以换取报酬 : : 捏造、藏匿或毁灭证据 : : 发布文章，刻意妨碍司法公正 : : 不当地中止检控 : : 使原来可能得以提出检控的法定程序受挫 : Hifree 不愧是懂美国的人，一个实际案例刚好替 hifree 作注脚： : 来源： : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pete_Domenici#Department_of_Justice_controversy : (原文有点长，我重点解说） : Prior to the 2006 midterm election Domenici called and pressured : then-United States Attorney for the District of New Mexico David : Iglesias to speed up indictments in a federal corruption : investigation that involved at least one former Democratic state : senator. When Iglesias said an indictment would not be handed down : until at least December, Domenici said "I'm very sorry to hear : that" — and the line went dead. Domenici's telephone manners were : the subject of a later article in The Albuquerque Journal, which : quoted numerous other sources whom Domenici had treated rudely by : hanging up after making a point or receiving an unsatisfactory : answer. : 简单地说，参议员杜曼尼的竞争对手因为贪污被检察官调查，杜议员就打电 : 话给检察官，希望他赶快处理，最好赶在11月选举前。检察官不鸟他，回覆 : 说最快得12月才能侦结 : Iglesias was fired a little over one month later by the : Bush Administration. A communication by a senator or House member : with a federal prosecutor regarding an ongoing criminal : investigation is a violation of ethics rules. : 重点是，一个月以後该名检察官就被布希政府开除了！ : In a March 2007 : statement, Domenici admitted making such a call.[20] House : Judiciary Committee Chairman John Conyers, D-Mich., issued : subpoenas to require Iglesias and three other ousted U.S. : attorneys to testify before Congress.[21] : Domenici later admitted calling Iglesias, though Domenici claimed : he never used the word "November" when he called Iglesias about an : ongoing Albuquerque courthouse corruption case.[22] Domenici has : denied trying to influence Iglesias, and has hired lawyer K. Lee : Blalack II to represent him.[23] : According to the Justice Department, Domenici called the : Department and demanded Iglesias be replaced on four : occasions.[24] : According to The Washington Post, on the day of the firing : (December 7, 2006) William Kelley, a deputy to then White House : Counsel Harriet Miers, said in an email that Domenici's chief of : staff was "happy as a clam" about the Iglesias firing. A week : later, a Justice Department email to the White House counsel : stated: "Domenici is going to send over names tomorrow (not even : waiting for Iglesias's body to cool)." : 这里的重点是：有关系就没关系，没关系就有关系。你检察官哪有我参议员 : 大？一通电话就把你开除了！ : On April 24, 2008, Domenici was admonished by the Senate Ethics : Committee for "inappropriately" contacting in 2006 one of the nine : U.S. attorneys later fired by President Bush.[16] : 所谓的国会自律，仅值一纸不痛不痒的警告。 : The light punishment came after the committee found “no : substantial evidence” that Domenici tried to influence attorney : David Iglesias when he contacted him to inquire about the status : of a 2006 investigation into corruption charges on a state : Democratic official. A possible indictment could have buoyed the : re-election hopes of Rep. Heather Wilson (R-N.M.), who was seeking : to replace Domenici when the senator retires after his current : term. Iglesias charged that Domenici and Wilson were pressuring : him to wrap up the investigation before that November’s : elections, a violation of ethics rules.[20] : The Ethics Committee said that Domenici’s phone call to Iglesias, : in advance of an upcoming election, “created an appearance of : impropriety that reflected unfavorably on the Senate”.[20] In : July 2010, Department of Justice prosecutors closed the two-year : investigation without filing charges after determining that the : firing was inappropriately political, but not criminal, saying : "Evidence did not demonstrate that any prosecutable criminal : offense was committed with regard to the removal of David : Iglesias. The investigative team also determined that the evidence : did not warrant expanding the scope of the investigation beyond : the removal of Iglesias."[26] Domenici said of the closed : investigation, "The Justice Department has now confirmed what I : have always said and believed: I never attempted to interfere with : any government investigation. I am glad that this matter has : concluded."[26] : 後面细节就不多翻了。 : 总之，这羣人 (foreign or domestic) 对关说司法个案的态度就是如此。从制度面到现实 : 面，一路走来始终如一。 : 我的心得是，这羣人一旦掌握了权力，大家真的只好个人顾性命。 --

※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 111.240.215.124 那我也很想请您开示一下 本案检察官不上诉哪里违法或不当了 如何符合「公务员廉政伦理规范」第二点第（五）款：「指 其内容涉及本机关（构）或所属机关（构）业务具体事项之决定、执行或不执行，且 因该事项之决定、执行或不执行致有违法或不当而影响特定权利义务之虞。」 而构成违法关说 麻烦正面回答一下好吗? 1.背信罪无法上诉第三审 2.有无违反商业会计法部分是最高法院发回理由,高等法院应受其拘束 3.更一审判决已认定没有登载不实,违反商业会计法部分不成罪 4.第三审无法自行认定事实 请问你上诉发回的可能性在哪里? 还请明示 至少没有符合「公务员廉政伦理规范」第二点第（五）款所定义的关说 ※ 编辑: hifree 来自: 111.240.215.124 (09/23 18:41) 楼上要不要看看这篇的反驳 http://ppt.cc/3FRs 不过重点还不在那 重点是 第 376 条 左列各罪之案件，经第二审判决者，不得上诉於第三审法院。 一、最重本刑为三年以下有期徒刑、拘役或专科罚金之罪。 二、刑法第三百二十条、第三百二十一条之窃盗罪。 三、刑法第三百三十五条、第三百三十六条第二项之侵占罪。 四、刑法第三百三十九条、第三百四十一条之诈欺罪。 五、刑法第三百四十二条之背信罪。 六、刑法第三百四十六条之恐吓罪。 七、刑法第三百四十九条第二项之赃物罪。 背信罪本来就不能是诉第三审了 吵背不背信有啥意义? 有人好像没有搞清楚重点喔 第 376 条 左列各罪之案件，经第二审判决者，不得上诉於第三审法院。 一、最重本刑为三年以下有期徒刑、拘役或专科罚金之罪。 二、刑法第三百二十条、第三百二十一条之窃盗罪。 三、刑法第三百三十五条、第三百三十六条第二项之侵占罪。 四、刑法第三百三十九条、第三百四十一条之诈欺罪。 五、刑法第三百四十二条之背信罪 六、刑法第三百四十六条之恐吓罪。 七、刑法第三百四十九条第二项之赃物罪。 背信罪根本不可能上诉第三审 何来符合「有...之虞」的说法? 听我的干嘛? 法条说的那麽清楚 背信罪不得上诉第三审 你还疑问吗? http://tw.myblog.yahoo.com/chengs0112/article?mid=989&sc=1 . 背信罪依刑事诉讼法第376条第5款规定，属不得上诉於第三审法院之罪名。检察官以单一案件具有”上诉不可以分”为由，将背信罪与违反商业会计法一并上诉至最高法院，最高法院亦同此见解而将案件撤销发回。简单的说，检察官认为曹兴诚以违反商业会计法的方法，掏空联电公司(背信罪)，两罪之间具有方法与结果的关系，在法律上称为牵连犯，为单一案件，依刑法第55条规定，只论处较重刑的罪名，两者具有不可分的关系。所以在上诉来说，因为两罪具有不可分的关系，所以背信罪的部分也可以跟着违反商业会计法的部分一并上诉。 ※ 编辑: hifree 来自: 111.240.215.124 (09/23 19:11)