作者decorum (Festina Lente)
看板clmusic
标题[闲聊] 引起争议的唱片封面
时间Thu Mar 30 15:22:52 2017
曲目是小提琴协奏曲的经典作:
Beethoven, Brahms, Bruch, Mendelssohn & Tchaikovsky
独奏家是伟大的 Nathan Milstein
但封面可就......
大家怎麽看?
https://goo.gl/dexdEr
5.0 out of 5 starsMagnificent recordings of Milstein at his best
ByIntegrity Reviewson March 29, 2017
Superb digital re-mastering of magnificent playing by Milstein and
accompanying orchestras. Some reviewers have complained about the cover
illustration, but I see nothing wrong with an image of the lovely woman
instead of the usual pictures on classical albums of one or more unattractive
musicians pretending to play or joke with one another. It's the music that
counts, and the stuff on this disc is outstanding.
4.0 out of 5 stars"There is a time and place for this kind of
photography...." What is wrong with everybody?
ByGenglerVINE VOICEon December 8, 2016
Milstein's are great performances, and this is a beautiful photograph in very
good taste. I wouldn't purchase this set because of the cover - and I agree
it's unnecessary - but its a well composed photograph of a woman's body that
emulates the contours of a violin. Yes, it does.
4.0 out of 5 starsbut otherwise they're fine performances.
ByWilliam Cromwellon June 22, 2016
Art on the inside, art on the outside. I don't see the problem. The
recordings are a little hissy, but otherwise they're fine performances.
4.0 out of 5 starsSymbolism
ByAfficianadoon June 21, 2016
How can you guys not see the connection? Beethoven, Brahms, Bruch,
Mendelssohn and Milstein all had backsides. So does the lady on the cover!
2.0 out of 5 starsI'm into words...
ByDavid Alt.on June 1, 2016
The picture is seriously misplaced but (forgive the desperate reach for a
pun) perhaps the name of the label inspired the photo?
1.0 out of 5 starsRidiculous!
ByScott L. Foglesongon May 27, 2016
Beyond bad taste, beyond inappropriate. Not that I'm a prude -- but what in
the world does this have to do with the collected concerto recordings of one
of the greatest violinists of all time?
1.0 out of 5 starsDisgraceful
ByDavid E Roweon May 27, 2016
Seriously? Recorded Classical music has come to this? There is a time and
place for this kind of photography, but on a Classical Cd cover, it is
completely disgraceful.
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc), 来自: 211.74.101.171
※ 文章网址: https://webptt.com/cn.aspx?n=bbs/clmusic/M.1490858576.A.2E2.html
1F:推 Tosca: 笑死人了 以前黑胶唱片封面露点的一堆好吗 03/30 15:48
2F:→ ROMEL: 我知道我知道,改成古早裸女名画就没问题了对吧 (逃) 03/30 15:55
3F:→ donkilling: 椅子以上的身体曲线还挺像小提琴的 03/30 16:41
4F:推 yamatai: 我对裸女没什麽意见 但是那字体就真的很没美感 03/30 17:29
5F:→ yamatai: 主要的问题应该还是在整体设计上 裸女不是问题 03/30 17:29
6F:推 huguenot: 楼主是是护家盟病毒感染吗? 03/30 18:22
7F:推 yohsiatai: 你不特别提我还感觉不出有任何问题... 蠍子乐队那张才 03/30 18:37
8F:→ yohsiatai: 是大有问题的封面 03/30 18:37
9F:推 fkusa: 有这种封面的 一定考虑先入手阿 03/30 20:13
10F:推 loudness: 蠍子那张才是真的是争议超大 03/30 21:36
11F:推 nyyfederer: ....最近道德魔人特多? 03/30 23:47
12F:推 bobikung: 这设计很有质感,裸的很艺术,个人觉得很好,没有不妥 04/01 12:06