作者Piaf (...)
看板clmusic
标题Re: Furt conducts Bruckner sym no.8
时间Wed Feb 25 00:52:18 2004
※ 引述《Piaf (...)》之铭言：
※ 引述《wenthome (槛外人)》之铭言：
1F：→ wenthome:印象中CD小册里写的是Nowak版 推 211.21.59.114 02/22
>CD册子的确是标Nowak 但是这是错误的资讯 详见以下网页
>
http://home.comcast.net/%7Ejberky/Furt_1954_B8.htm
>在Ben Korstvedt的Bruckner Sym. No.8这本书 这份录音也标为1892年版
>我觉得上面两个资料来源可信度很大
I just check the Furtwangler/VPO/1954 recording of
Bruckner Symphony no.8. Yes, it's 1892 version rather
than the Nowak version. An easy way to identify these
two versions is to check mm 93-98 in the Finale, which
is cut in the 1892 version (2'49" in Furt's recording).
Also, in m. 479 a cymbal clash is added (14'29") in
the 1892 version.
I guess in 1892 version, mm. 183 (so-called Caucasian
march) is marked mp or p (ff in Nowak) with a huge cresc.
Both Furt and Knap/1951/BPO did not directly adopt ff
in mm. 183. However I don't have the full score of 1892
version, so I cannot give you exact markings, but the
above evidence will be adequate to prove this recording
a 1892 version.
(The above examples are all from the Finale. All measure
numbers are according to the 1890 version by Nowak.)
--
Piaf @ PTT; klem/Dutchman elsewhere.
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 141.212.126.245
※ 编辑: Piaf 来自: 141.212.126.245 (02/25 01:00)