作者wl00669773 (Jerry shou)
看板Warfare
标题Fw: [海战] 冲角战术，是什麽时候开始式微的？
时间Mon Sep 20 08:37:27 2021
※ [本文转录自 C_Chat 看板 #1XHzDIOy ]
作者: wl00669773 (Jerry shou) 看板: C_Chat
标题: Re: [海战] 冲角战术，是什麽时候开始式微的？
时间: Mon Sep 20 08:18:20 2021
1874年的英国海军获奖论文
The Gun, Ram, and Torpedo
主要讲述当代海军交战战术
https://imgur.com/ZOhutot
*亚马逊竟然有2017再版贩售
作者文中提到
In a general action I do not hold that the guns will be the principal weapon;
but should the ship's engines or steering gear be disabled,
＂一般来说，我不认为火炮是主要武器，除非船的引擎或船舵失效＂
对於撞角战术，他则是这样说
Rams:— As all ships of the line, lately built or at present building, are
constructed with strengthened and sharpened bows for ramming, it may be
concluded that much value is attached to this mode of attack.
"Much Value"
战术示意图
https://imgur.com/tfUvp26
1894年RUSI的文章都还要继续讨论并论证冲撞的效益跟困难度问题
https://imgur.com/79Wd4sc
https://imgur.com/P1Lt0Jq
https://imgur.com/89mpLwp
https://imgur.com/Y8GVMfi
https://imgur.com/HPMVu6h
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc), 来自: 218.166.239.211 (台湾)
※ 文章网址: https://webptt.com/cn.aspx?n=bbs/C_Chat/M.1632097106.A.63C.html
1F：推 reich3: 同期世界第二大舰队的法国，发展出绿水学派，已经强调鱼雷 09/20 09:02
2F：→ reich3: 跟潜艇的重要性。 09/20 09:02
1874那篇的作者对於鱼雷是这样说的
Torpedoes will be of immense service in warning off rams; and if Captain
Harvey's could be exploded by electricity they might be rendered safe
companions to their friends, if not so dangerous to the enemy as at present.
Their protection (as we might say) against rams would be invaluable.
※ 编辑: wl00669773 (218.166.239.211 台湾), 09/20/2021 09:07:28
※ 编辑: wl00669773 (218.166.239.211 台湾), 09/20/2021 09:21:13
3F：推 tony3366211: 问义大利怎麽会败给冲角战术 09/20 11:14
4F：→ tony3366211: 利萨海战 09/20 11:15
5F：推 rommel1: 黄海海战? 北洋舰队想撞下去的 失败 09/20 11:32
6F：→ Anjou: ....宇宙战舰大和号对加米利斯的巡洋舰都可以撞上去两半 09/20 13:09
7F：推 Su22: 特拉法加那麽多船混战,有船是被撞沉的吗? 09/20 13:35
8F：→ otis1713: 就义大利海军都到铁甲舰时代还被撞沉啊 09/20 13:36
9F：→ otis1713: 然後更之前铁甲舰的防还比炮高，火炮不破防 09/20 13:37
10F：→ otis1713: 参照板上南北战争两台铁甲舰对轰半天没造成半点决定性 09/20 13:38
11F：→ otis1713: 伤害，然後搞出撞角舰队 09/20 13:38
12F：→ kuma660224: 就早期火力太弱 轰不出成效 就先撞沉 09/20 17:58
13F：→ kuma660224: 义大利是苦主 让撞角重回市场 09/20 17:59
14F：推 HarukaJ: 这让我想到某个很荒唐的海战游戏 兵器水准是在二战 却给 09/20 18:25
15F：→ HarukaJ: 底下的船玩纳尔逊接触那套 09/20 18:25
1874那篇文章有教舰艏对敌这招!
给你用二战船打19世纪的战术 赞吧
※ 编辑: wl00669773 (218.166.239.211 台湾), 09/20/2021 18:51:52